Software
Houzz Logo Print
mclny

should this large tree be taken down?

2 years ago

I feel as though this tree is now too large for my small lot. Note how close my neighbors homes are to the left and the right. Should I remove it? If so, I would want a new landscape plan with plants to a much smaller scale.

Please help 😁

Comments (33)

  • 2 years ago

    Hmmmm. I was not aware of that. Yes, it is healthy. Really the only issue is that it’s my entire front yard.

  • 2 years ago

    You might consider having the lower branches of the tree trimmed. It’s called crown raising and will give a better view of the house.

  • 2 years ago

    I love trees and that was a big factor in choosing my neighborhood. I’d definitely keep the tree, it’s beautiful. I’d look into trimming it as cfollowell suggests, but I have no suggestions. My other home has only 2 small trees and living with trees feels more full of life for me.

  • 2 years ago

    Definitely agree on the crown raising. Get professional advice from an arborist/someone with extensive tree knowledge.

  • 2 years ago

    Wow…. Maybe it should stay.
    Does anyone have the ability to Photoshop a picture of my house without that tree in front of it?

    I really appreciate everyone’s help!

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    Removing a mature tree is a bizarre idea. i agree mature landscaping adds irreplaceable value.

  • 2 years ago

    It would be crazy to cut down a mature and beautiful tree, especially if it is a native species to your area. They are good for wildlife such as pollinators, birds and clean the air we breathe. And if that is not enough, they likely decrease your utility bills and increase the value of your property,

  • 2 years ago

    Absolutely leave it. And if you do decide to have a few--only a few-- of the lower branches removed, have the work done by someone who actually knows what he's doing, not a butcher.

  • 2 years ago

    For sure only have an arborist who is insured work on your tree. Usually when I think of trees not suited to residential areas it is due to their height. Your tree looks fine.

  • 2 years ago

    It maybe a nice tree but it doesnt look right where it is. Not just it looks out of proportion, its also blocking the sunlight and obscuring the view.


    personally i would take it down and replace with shrubs.

  • 2 years ago

    With the increasingly hotter climate, plenty of shade is a huge benefit. Don't take that tree down. It makes your front yard gorgeous.

  • last year

    I took everyone’s advice and had an arborist trim, my tricolor beach tree. The trimming was done in the dead of winter here in central New York. At that time, it was difficult to assess the impact. Just now that the tree is in full bloom am I able to compare the before and after.It doesn’t appear they took much off, but they dramatically altered the exterior shape of the tree. I don’t really care for the new shape. Thoughts?

  • last year

    This was the shape before the trimming

  • last year

    I’m a bit confused. The recommendations, which seemed good to me, were to have some of the lower limbs removed completely —I always
    called that “ limbing up”, but people have
    used other terms.
    It would not be “ trimming” the outer tips of branches , which is what looks like was done. Line a haircut for a shrub. Sure, peripheral limb removal needs to be done sometimes when limbs grow over or too close to roof. And if that is a lot of a very large or fast- growing tree, then removal is a greater consideration because it is hard to keep that up, or it’s disfiguring. plus expensive , so sometimes one would waste time & resources that could be put to planting a new tree that could be growing all that time.

    Do you recall the actual conversations you had with the tree person ( s) about what was to be done?
  • last year

    Yes. Recall that one of my concerns with the tree is that it had grown too large for my small scale home in property. The request was to remove up to 5 feet across the entire perimeter and thin out up to 20%. I just think they altered the shape significantly. It looks like they took off more on the diameter of the lower part of the tree less on the top so it looks almost square.

  • last year

    It should grow out. Personally I liked it better before and I don't think your house looks out of scale. It's a beautiful tree which gives an air of protection to your home.


    Btw you didn't mention before that it is a Tricolor Beech. Even more reason to value it highly.

  • last year

    Thank you. I also liked the before shape better. I liked the wispiness.

  • last year

    It sounds like they did what you asked them to do.

    Somewhere large trees are normal, like the northeast, scale is determined by the large trees. Not the house. Certainly not the lot size.

    See the trees *behind* the house in the first pic? Those are what is setting the scale.

  • last year

    Take it out and plant another tree.

  • last year

    But you’re still talking about “ thinning” and not the limbing- up. The limbing up , just a bit, can make the tree look less “ massive” because you have more view past the trunk and the tree isn’t hunkering as much in front of the view of your house.

    Maybe more tree experts will weigh in.

  • last year

    Did you actually consult an arborist or a guy with a bucket truck and a chain saw?

  • last year

    This work was done by a reputable arborist …the best in Syracuse, NY

  • PRO
    last year

    I think the arborist did a good job. It's a fresh haircut on the tree and you are not used to it. Give it a year or two for it to re-plush.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I agree the arborist did exactly as you asked, reduce the perimeter and thin it out. I can see sky thru the trunks so it def has been thinned.

    I Googled-not familiar- but mature height for a Tricolor Beech grows to 30-40 feet so not a huge tree but large for a small yard. Yours has been pruned to keep it in check which is a good thing...looks to scale.

    .I agree the lower branches could be removed in this case as they seem to be blocking the view of the house.

    Apparently they can be pruned to give any impression you like. I found these examples just to show what can be done as an open tree or more shaped like yours.





  • last year

    Thank you. I did contact the arborist as well to question them on possibly having had more taken off the top. Maybe I will be happier with the appearance once it grows out a little and becomes a bit whisperer.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    Why would you want more 'taken off the top'?

    I hate to be 'that guy', but this is a place for me to insufferably point out we really need to educate the public better on 'how to plant a tree'. People need to realize that even a slow growing variety like 'Tricolor' beech eventually gets very large. It isn't too close to the house for me, but it seems to be for you, so in that case, it should have been planted closer to the street. Someone thought it was a Japanese maple scaled tree, when it really is a shade tree...just a slow growing one.

    https://www.treesandshrubsonline.org/articles/fagus/fagus-sylvatica/

    "Krussman’s suggestion that it ‘only occasionally [grows] to 10 m high’ would seem to be erroneous" "Jacobson (1996) refers to an individual c. 30 m tall growing at Balaine, near Villeneuve sur Allier, France"

    So you need to decide what you want from this rather valuable tree. If you (keep) trimming off the top, the assumption is you want a giant topiary look - that's what it will eventually resemble. You do see that sort of thing at French Chateaux or whatnot - huge trees in box like shapes - but it would be an unusual thing to encounter in American suburbia. The other is to accept how big it will get 'on its own', and plan accordingly for that.

  • last year

    I purchased this home 13 years ago and it is approximately 30 years old. I would suspect that this tree was planted shortly after construction. I obviously had no say in the matter regarding the selection of the tree or the placement of the tree.
    My original inclination was to have the tree taken down, but after receiving so many comments regarding the value and beauty of the tree, I opted to give trimming a try. I was just sharing the outcome for those that had commented and were interested.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    Right, right, sorry I should have clarified that you were obviously a secondary purchaser of the tree. Most of "us" knew that because it's such a slow growing variety. Note I said "it should have been planted closer to the street" not "you should have planted it closer to the street".

    I also have to add that it's disappointing but not unexpected that the 'best arborist' in town, seemingly didn't explain what the options really were. Sorry, 'best anything' in US horticulture means nothing. The field is full of idiots and dunderheads. (present company excepted!) Favorite davidrt28 anecdote incoming: it was surely the 'best landscaper in northern Delaware' who cut down a large monkey puzzle at a public garden for 'not looking English enough'! Too funny!

  • last year

    It is a beautiful lawn tree. I don't particularly like large trees near the house just because of limbs breaking or the tree falling over. I don't know if that is a problem with this species. 40 feet is big...4 stories.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I seem to have stormed into this thread and not been perfectly clear. So let me break this scenario down:

    Homeowner feels tree is out of scale and dominates front yard, blocking view of house

    Arborist called in

    Arborist should recognize the natural state of this tree is to keep getting larger...surely he should have seen gigantic purple beeches in various upstate NY gardens.

    The option presented should have been

    1) removal

    2) trying to contain its size, which will eventually lead to the box tree/giant topiary look

    3) 'thinning' of some kind, which would just cause the tree to hasten its upward growth; if done in a smart way, you could have eventually have ended up (and I mean, 20+ years eventual...) a straight bole trunk, that allowed a view from the house to the street, but with a large, high canopy above it. It isn't the natural shape of a cultivated beech, but I've seen some that were trimmed that way and looked just fine and natural. In a natural beech stand, they will eventually have 20-50' of clear trunk. To really do it the right way over years, and (in my opinion) correct the split trunk, you'd be looking at a long term investment of >> 2K$.

    4) just leave it be and enjoy it...no charge!

    It doesn't seem options were presented, per se, just homeowners discomfort with tree and not fully informed instructions (not her fault) translated into 'something to do and charge money for'. SO, the fact you're here, asking what to do, is because you weren't fully informed of what the options really were.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    Living where big trees - 60-80 feet or more - are not at all uncommon and are often restricted as to removal, even those located close to a structure. If the tree is healthy, they just don't fall over! Nor do large branches often break off. IMO, the OP has nothing to worry about.

    The trimmed tree may not look the way you hoped it would but it will assume a more natural shape given another season or two. I see absolutely no reasonable reason for its removal.

    btw, a tricolor beech will not achieve the same enormous proportions as a purple leaf beech will. It's about as large now as it is ever going to get.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    Yes thanks for stating the obvious that I overlooked as I sometimes do; in old neighborhoods, even down in hurricane and microburst prone Washington, DC, huge trees towering over small houses are a dime a dozen on any street. In upstate NY, the risk of a limb-dropping event is even lower.

    that's why I put in (during an edit) my option #4 🤣 It helps that it is a respectable, strong limbed tree. I lost several huge branches from poorly shaped red and silver maples during Hurricane Irene and other severe storms, but they were fortunately nowhere near my house. Silver maples, especially, are just junk trees.

Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!