I think the brown that it got painted is more warm and looks nice!

How about a picture of the house, so you can get a correct answer. The brown is pretty and is warmer than the grayish, but, whether it goes with you house is hard to say. edited to add, I did find a picture of your house on previous post. Its still hard to tell though, if that brown goes with the brick at all, and what color is your roof? Please post a picture with the new color.

Triple post. You received comments on the first one. Stay with one post, please.

Sent pictures. The other color is dark brown

The color that it got painted is a better color than the one you had picked out shown on the board. It looks nice. I also like the color of your door.