Someone has to have an opinion here yas? Has anyone grown both? Or some positive words for either would be fantastic and appreciated. Thank you!

Sunny, I have baby Colette only, planted last Spring. Can confirm so far that it's good growing rose with absolutely no black spots!

Bathsheba seems to have more yellow tones in it:

I'm glad to have both. I think you'd like both, Sunny....they are quite different.

Oh gosh I wouldn’t be without either . They are definitely on my top ten list and if I had to start a new garden they’d be among the first I order !

My Bathsheba’s can bloom almost the whole season . In fact if I went out now I’m sure I’d find blooms even now tucked in . It’s very healthy and a pleasure to work with . Not too thorny , vigorous, and just a wonderful rose ! Color varies between a honey color and warm gold and sometimes a pinkish cast as well .

Colette I adore the color and form of the blooms . Mine does takes break in the heat but blooms well otherwise. My only complaint is it’s so thorny . Not wonderful for an arch although i used it on mine in Tennessee. Here it’s on my wall and I can see my sons nerf football buried in it and no way of getting it back lol

These are bathssheba

now ill find colette

Both are lovely roses, but they are quite different. Both need full sun to do well. If you have great location for both, I suggest give both a try.

Here are pictures of Colette:

Here are Bethsheba: