Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_758826892

What to do about fireplace?

last year

Hello, I was wondering if I could get some input on this. I have a very problematic, small, narrow living room. We have a family of 6 and needed a large sectional for comfortable seating for all. My husband wants to keep it where it is as it faces tv and is on the longest wall, even though there is a fireplace there. My question is this, is it so terrible to block an unused gas fireplace like this? Or should we look into removing it in the future to create empty wall space for the sectional? I don't worry about resale value with the fireplace as we don't plan to move. And we really never use it for heat. Thank you for any comments.

Comments (23)

  • last year






  • last year

    Thank you. Yes, I know it is humongous. It is just enough of a seating space for all of us to lounge on. 2 are teens and other 2 kids are quickly approaching teen years! I can get a floor plan later, but I have to say, I have divided it up several times, and there is not much else that can be done and still meet our needs. Really, I think the solution is new house, but hubby does not want to move! I tried a corner sofa and loveseat type arrangement but it really didn't provide us with enough seating since I had to move one piece of sectional to another room to do that.

  • last year

    Sounds like your husband isn't up for any changes.

    He's fine with the Fireplace and sectional arrangement.

    6+ years from now you may get to rearrange the room, until then, this is what you have.


    Cecilia thanked Lyn Nielson
  • last year

    Well, yes, he doesn't care, but I don't like it. Just wondered what you all thought about it and if you think removing the fireplace might be a good solution. (If I can convince him)

  • last year

    The pilot light is off for safety since you have combustibles close? Since you don't plan to move, you could have the gas disconnected, fireplace/mantel removed, then sheetrock over the space including that high enclosure.

  • last year

    Yeah, that's what I'm thinking I would like to do.

  • last year

    I will show y'all another arrangement next week and get your thoughts.

  • last year

    Is there another space for watching tv as a family? This one is too small for your family to lounge on a sectional. But it’s great that you all are so close.
    , especially with teens!

  • PRO
    last year

    I agree get some new seating that does not take all the space in the LR. A to scale floor plan is a must if you want help here. You have small space and all huge furniture it does not work. With room measurements we maybe could help. Is this the only seating space in the house ?

  • last year

    Yes, it is unfortunately. And it is a priority for us to have space to really snuggle and lounge when we are watching movies and things. This is why we opted for oversized furniture even though it is not optimal aesthetically for the size of the space. We just bought this about 6 months ago so it is what we are going to try to make work. It can be reconfigured 1 other way to where we still have all pieces in the room and therefore can fit the whole family. Nonetheless, I will attach a floorplan with measurements soon and also show the other arrangement of the sectional some time next week to get input. Thank you!

  • last year

    It is cheaper to remove a fireplace than to move house. Get what fits your family. After all, you would not have added a fireplace in that location if the house had been designed for you in the first place. Consider adding a window in the former fireplace location to match the existing window.

    Cecilia thanked apple_pie_order
  • last year

    Very good point! Thank you.

  • last year

    Please post an update when you are ready.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I would want to keep the fireplace for use down the road - if it were me, I would want to hide it and the cabinet above and would probably diy a printed mural (wallpaper also works) on a large frame for the area (with enough depth to account for the mantle and sit flush against the wall) - then would push back the sectional so the hearth could not be seen

  • last year

    Not a great look but very common would be to flip your room. Put the TV over the fireplace. Your sectional could be farther from the TV (which it appears would be a good thing) and your room would not scream weird covering the fireplace. That sectional could seat 10...hopefully at least two of the middle 'seats' can be removed so you look like you have more home and less sectional.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    Ok, so I know this is still really crowded looking but is it any better? I have removed one piece and placed in a separate room and separated the pieces into a corner sofa and loveseat. We still mostly have enough seating with this setup.







  • PRO
    last year

    I love those big comfy looking sectionals but had to get rid of mine when I moved to a smaller house. I would not get rid of the fireplace, because your family will move away and then you can remove either the loveseat or other parts.

  • last year

    Yes, that's true. I hate to think about it, but yes, the kids are growing up very fast. So, I may not need all the pieces for very long. :(

  • last year

    That looks better.

  • PRO
    last year
    last modified: last year

    Yes, the sectional separated looks better, and doesn't completely block the fireplace.

    I'd move the side table near the floor lamp slightly further from the sofa, and would the one in front of the fireplace fit at the end of the sofa as shown below?



  • last year

    OK, thank you very much for letting me know. I don't want to block the fireplace, it just always seems to get in the way...

  • last year

    Yes, I will try that lisedv. Thank you!

Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz