or if you have any other suggestions - that would be great. and much appreciated.

I'd go with the third from the top.

What is wrong with what you have? I think that looks perfect. IMHO much better than anything greyish, like what you show.

Thank you. we would like a new paint colour for some change. Any paint colour suggestions would be helpful.

The windows are a bright white with blue undertones

I would go with warm white or off-white.

Grays are overdone and out of style now (if you care about being on-trend).

Is the roof reddish-brown? Choose a color to blend with the roof, unless you’re going to replace it right away.

I personally would choose a light tan/deep cream with lighter cream trim. These would blend well with the roof and the sophisticated looking tan block driveway.

New roof is - driftwood by certainteed. the new windows are white (with blue undertones)

Thank you! what is the warm white colour?

will warm white siding go with white windows with a blue undertone

Not gray, please. Here are colonials in other colors. Traditional hits ( o shutters) and olive green (matching shutters).

Strong statement colors.

We are getting the exact same windows in picture 1. thanks for the pictures - so pretty!

May i ask, why not gray?

White window colour match

IMO gray is dreary. It’s a personal choice but your home style screams traditional and yet, the colored colonials are as pretty as the white one.

Full disclosure: my last home was a traditional colonial and I painted the house and barn in BM River Blue with a touch of green in it. Here is a photo of the barn.

^^ Love teh barn, RedRyder!

The problem here isn't the siding color, it's the red roof. Rather than paint the house, change out the roof color to a warm-toned brown with golden tones (no red tones).

porkchop_z5b_MI The roof is new, why would they replace it? I think a creamy off-white would look good with their new roof. A dark color isn't going to look right on your house. Whatever you choose, it should be a medium shade, not really light or really dark.

Thank you. we are putting on a new roof - driftwood by Certainteed.

Have you tried the CertainTeed Colorview designer? You can upload a photo of your house or use the stock photo, specify the Driftwood roof color, and experiment with various siding colors. You can only specify Certainteed siding colors but there are several including grays and one white.

Thank you! I will try that! Much appreciated.

Here is a picture from the back of the house. The new windows will be a bright white colour.

I have always liked the combination of bright white windows with white siding.

Good roof color choice! It’s neutral.

Option 1 - puritan grey by BM

Option 2 - Sandy Hook by BM

Option 1 or option 2 which one do you like the best?

I personally would have white siding but, of your two choices, would select Sandy Hook. Think it looks better with your roof and think Puritan Grey looks dreary

Sandy Hook, 100%. Grey-on-grey is dreary, as @pkpk23 said.

I would choose Sandy Hook over the gray color. I also think the color you have already, looks great. Please dont put all those colors on your siding. Take your samples and put them on poster paper, and move those pieces of poster paper all around the house at different times of day, so you can see, just how those colors would look on your house.

Agree with all comments. which off white/white colour would you recommend with bright white windows?

You need to try different whites using @cat_ky’s suggestion. Some sides of the house will be darker and some lighter - at different times of the day. Using poster board allows you to see all the colors on each side from sunrise to sunset. See how the whites look with your windows.

"which off white/white colour would you recommend with bright white windows?"

Behr Ultra Pure White is the brightest white paint available. Behr recommends its PPU10-12 Whitened Sage as a coordinating "true white with a touch of gray-green".