Pics

I'd look for something in a natural woven shade. or even a simple cone shape.

I like this one

https://www.onekingslane.com/p-kezia-rattan-pendant-natural-P112166328?sku=112166328&epik=dj0yJnU9TjFVajg5Z3JXcHpXRE82VkhWU0VfRXpiazBQNkl5U1AmcD0wJm49QV8waU9sUWxwdi1jVmRSYnE1bTdfZyZ0PUFBQUFBR2o3MnlJ

THIS would be nice for the dining table.

https://www.lighting-forest.com/products/coastal-home-lighting-kitchen-island-rattan-pendant-light-natural-retro-luxurious-chandelier-wabi-sabi-style?sku=18064286520825893368330845&utm_source=google&utm_medium=shopline-feed&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=19965337090&gbraid=0AAAAAojwCYH8D0fsEtfK50F_EvouSMxIW&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIvqGZztG9kAMVph9ECB1yCjdMEAQYCiABEgLn-_D_BwE

Do I then need to change all of the hardware on the cabinets?

I agree the black does not work and I think you could do a lot better style wise. First the chandelier needs to light the table not the ceiling. How about a linear one above the table and then some really simple drops for the island Just a nice steel color or maybe brass

Your cabinet hardware doesn't make a large enough statement to affect the general appearance of the room. The light fixtures don't have to be brass, bronze will work also, but something softer than harsh black.

Your cabinets and counters need to be a functional backdrop to the wow moments of your chairs and light fixtures. You have great dining room chairs and bar stools. Your lights lack character, and the black isn't working either.

I like these two lights for your table and I guess other designers do too because they show them with your same chairs. Even if these lights are not your taste, see how you need something with character here to equal the character of your chairs? It doesn't have to match your chairs, it just needs a special kick to it.

I agree with two larger lights instead of three at the island. And I would switch your hardware. You want to lighten up the space. Not make the cabinets the focus. Chrome or brass would work well.

I'd consider an updated backsplash, or if that is not in the budget, paint yours. I have seen this done to great effect and last for years.

Beverly, I love the Roxy linear lighting you suggested (first one in pic) but I am having a hard time finding lighting for the island. Do you think semi flush lighting would work?