Have had Shiloh beaded-inset kitchen cabinets for 12 years now. Mine are a painted white finish, which has held up wonderfully as have the cabinets in general. I live in an 1894 pier-and-beam house in Houston, with epic humidity and alternating cycles of flood and drought. Given the climate, the dealer warned me that beaded inset might mean more movement (& issues with corners) but that hasn't been an issue.

I'd buy Shiloh again.

They are both boxes with doors. IMO the difference in price will be the finish you select for the cabinets.

I have Eclipse cabinets, which are Shiloh's european frameless line. Admittedly they're only two years old and we have no kids who abuse them, but they look as great now as they did when they were installed.

The kitchen designer for either is more important than the line. The two are equivalent quality, but you will not be getting similar detailing in the design to have that large of a price difference. The actual details will be different.

My eclipse have chipped terribly. I realize there is normal wear and tear but it’s Far more than friends cabinets of the same age.