1 is too gray. 1 is too gray and knotty. Both will have that awful stripey look that low cost vinyl has when installed. Move to something much warmer and classic. Like actual wood.

It looks gray in that photo, but in real life it doesn’t. I’ll try to post a better picture.

This FB group is searchable and lots of info and images https://www.facebook.com/share/g/1bXobCfHs6/

Thanks, I’ll check it out!