Great.

Tall enough so the table top is even with the top of the arm and large enough to fill the corner between the two pieces of furniture.

https://www.wayfair.com/furniture/pdp/gracie-oaks-laron-square-wood-end-table-with-storage-shelf-and-tapered-legs-w007989413.html?auctionId=2a67610b-f71c-4f3c-9a11-ee6b62876b3a&trackingId=%7B%22adType%22%3A%22WSP%22%2C%22auctionId%22%3A%222a67610b-f71c-4f3c-9a11-ee6b62876b3a%22%7D&adTypeId=1

@Lyn Nielson thank you! For clarity, do you believe one of the options listed in my pictures will work (and if so, best one/size?), or are you saying these are not a great fit and the wayfair option may be better?

How about round one in a lighter tone of the recliners? Pottery Barn.

Add a rug to anchor all the furniture...similar to this photo. Texture is important in your room.

Can you get a bit more bold/unique with your table choices?

The ones you show are quite generic in their style and too matchy-matchy.

@chispa We will have metal round cocktail tables between the two chairs facing the fireplace, and next to the chair in the corner for a bit of variation. However I do tend to be more hesitant than I should be with bold lol. I will take another look at options.

@oncape we will have a rug (light/neutral) as well so that may help a bit. I will look at round end table options as well. The same furniture company offers various options/shapes that can have the same finish.

Your new furniture is deep. I would look for something that is no less than 24x24 wide. I think 26 or 28 would be even better. Minimum height should be 24" and maximum of 25.5".

I agree something interesting and for sure not dark

Maybe all your pictures didn't post? There are no pictures of chairs.

If not bold, at least not so matchy matchy.

Maybe a bit more information on the plan-two chairs facing fireplace, another in a corner and couch facing TV?