countertop seam

6 days ago

Need honest thoughts and opinions on this Dekton Bromo countertop install a family member had done. Is the seam acceptable? Placement and direction of the pieces seem to be non ideal combined with possibly a bad fill. Need other opinions

Purchased through Costco who contracts with a very high end/well known countertop company.

Homeowner signed off on the CAD drawings which put the seam here in this location.

Featured Answer

AnnKH

5 days ago

My honest opinion? The "very high end/well known countertop company" dropped the ball here. The fabricator should have pointed out the distinct grain direction in the slab(s), and talked to the homeowner about the best way to deal with it.

I'll give the homeowner a pass, since we don't know what we don't know, and not everyone spends enough time on Houzz to know what to ask.

Unfortunately, I don't know that there's much to do in this case. I like shopping at Costco, but I doubt they will go to bat for the homeowner in this case.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

millworkman
5 days ago
Is it flat? Looks a little wonky, but are they 100% finished?
chispa
5 days ago
Direction of pattern is an issue, but they probably didn't want to pay for more slab material. They probably get charged by the sq.ft and didn't get an inch more of material. The fabricator will maximize the material he has in inventory to get the most profit and not the best looking job.

I hope they are tiny people or only one person lives there, because that is a tight corner to prep,wash, cook and bake.
Related Professionals
California Home Remodeling · Fort Dodge Home Remodeling · Williamsport Home Remodeling · Morgantown Kitchen Remodelers · Miami Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Houston Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Victoria Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Toledo Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Danbury Kitchen Remodelers · Queens Kitchen Remodelers · Greenville Custom Countertops · Oklahoma City Custom Countertops · Waterloo Custom Countertops · Oshkosh Custom Countertops · Bozeman Custom Countertops
teresa CL
Original Author
5 days ago
@millworkman yes they are finished. They are coming back today for backsplash measurement but countertop is “complete”
teresa CL
Original Author
5 days ago
@chispa yes I agree the grain pattern is the issue... the change in direction is HARSH
AnnKH
5 days ago
Was the homeowner involved in the process of laying out the pieces? I spent an hour with our fabricator, going back and forth between the computer (with photos of our 3 slabs, and all the shapes we required), and looking at the slabs themselves. Together the expert and I came up with a template, that I signed off on.

CAD drawings are not the same as what I did. I'd be interested to know exactly what they signed off on.
teresa CL thanked AnnKH
teresa CL
Original Author
5 days ago
@AnnKH - The homeowner was not given the opportunity to work with the fabricator on layout pieces. only the 2D Cad drawing showing where the seam would be.
just_janni
5 days ago
yeah - my fabricator showed me what the counters would look like by using the template and the actual stone pictures so I could see EXACTLY what it would look like. (I had some bookmatching so that was critical) but unless they had the pictures and could see the grain clearly - this would be a hard thing to envision.
porkchop_z5b_MI
5 days ago
I would not be happy with that. It's not so much that a seam is there -- most of us have seams -- but the seam in combination with the abrupt change in direction make it looks like the countertop was cobbled together.
chispa
5 days ago
Why wouldn't they just make a straight seam instead of that odd curved one.

Here is one of my corners. Pattern flows across the seam and they just did a simple butted straight seam.
PRO
Joseph Corlett, LLC
5 days ago
last modified: 5 days ago
A color matched Sharpie will make that seam nearly disappear.
PRO
Joseph Corlett, LLC
5 days ago
"Why wouldn't they just make a straight seam instead of that odd curved one."

It's called a French Miter.