What material are you using or currently there for the siding?

I would go with a composite materials for all your window trim.........it can be painted whatever color you want, holds up to all weather conditions and is as easy as working with wood. Slightly more expensive than wood, but I'm betting less than the trim from Andersen Windows..........you're paying for that name.

For composite - do you mean like PVC or PU? As for the siding - we will be replacing it after we get the trims.