Software
Houzz Logo Print
arrazolab

Need help placing light fixture in foyer

12 years ago
We added a foyer to our home. From the exterior, the door will be at the center of the addition. From the interior, it will not be centered because there is a closet on one side of the door taking up the full wall. Our architect is suggesting we center the light fixture on the room which means it will be 8" off center from the door. Our contractor is very hesitant to do this. He's telling us that in 21 years of building he has never put a light fixture off center from the door. Our door will have 8 lights and 2 16" side-lights and a transom. We have 8 foot ceilings so the light fixture will definitely be visible from the outside. Anyone have a suggestion on how to position this light fixture. We haven't picked one out yet but I'm envisioning some kind of pendant. Sorry I don't have a better picture.

Comments (24)

  • 12 years ago
    Agree with contractor. Want that light centered with entrance, first thing many see on entering home. Could also get help from lighting company.
  • 12 years ago
    This is the floor plan for the foyer.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Your builder is right! Center fixture on door. Architect's assistant probably did the lighting plan and wasn't paying enough attention.
  • 12 years ago
    A pendant will emphasise the off center problem. Your ceiling is only 8'. A flush mount would be best for diminishing the off center problem. A semi-flush fixture could work if it is under 12" tall. I think your architect messed up. One method of fixing the problem would be to change the ceiling of the foyer if it is not too late. If you barrel it like the outside, the high point would be in the center of the door and make the light look like it is supposed to be there. It also gives you more height for the light.
    Otherwise, center the light on the front door and the closet door.
  • 12 years ago
    Given the issues, I think I'd skip the interior pendant idea, and do recessed interior lights, as symmetrically as you can, and with the ability to shine light in a directed way. Could you do a standout ceiling finish in the entry area in lieu of using a hanging light as a focal point?
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Also, add a little more wall on the left of the stairs to center everything up.
  • 12 years ago
    It's not too late to do something with the ceiling. Not sure if barreling is an option though. Wouldn't one side of the barrel be in the closet and still look a bit off? Our contractor suggested putting in a 3' x 3' coffer centered on the door and hanging the fixture in the center of the coffer. Not sure if this would emphasize the off center problem even more.
  • 12 years ago
    nwduck, when you say recessed interior lights, are you referring to cans or are you suggesting coffers in the ceiling? I like the idea of doing something with the ceiling.
  • 12 years ago
    Without seeing the space itself, can't tell, honestly. If you can make coffers symmetrical inside the foyer space, I think I'd do that, probably in combo with a few can lights. Then the door being rather offset might not be so obvious. Otherwise, just simple recessed can lights, and a standout ceiling treatment (with any trim on the lights painted out to match), and a lit art piece straight across from the front door opening. Envisioning something with a metallic sort of shine on the ceiling, but depends on your style on the interior. No one would miss a pendant light, given that. :)
  • 12 years ago
    If you match the outside, it should come back down to 8' just outside the closet. Unless you want crown molding, it should not be a problem visually, at least from what I see. construction could be a bit more of a problem. I thought of a coffer, but a barrel seems like it would flow better. If you do a coffer, I would not go very deep. Personally I would center the stair opening on the front and either stay flat or something more like a barrel. A SQUARE coffered ceiling doesn't seem like it would help much.
  • 12 years ago
    If a coffered ceiling started 3" off the front door wall, closet wall, and what would be the stair wall, and centered on the door, then it might look good with only about a 3" recess.
  • 12 years ago
    OK, I thought about this some more. No coffer, given the ceiling height. I think you would be better off doing a "frame" with molding on the ceiling, with the left side of the frame where the dashed line is on your plan (the front wall jog). Recessed lights inside that frame with a ceiling treatment. There are so many openings in this area, keeping it simple will minimize the fact it is not all symmetrical.
  • 12 years ago
    Recessed lights would work only because they DON'T draw attention to the off center problem. Framing recessed lights in any way would be completely contradictory to the problem.
  • 12 years ago
    Fred: If you wanted to do recessed lights and a ceiling treatment what would you do? Am a little stumped myself! :) Thought if it was a relatively simple molding with staggered lights, it might not be super obvious.
  • 12 years ago
    This is the first thought on recessed lights with a standard flat ceiling. It doesn't emphasise the problem as much as say 4 cans would.
  • 12 years ago
    The interior style is traditional with white trim, crown molding, and baseboards throughout. Kitchen is white, inset cabinets, exposed hinges, white quartzite countertops, chrome fixtures. Kitchen pendants are chrome barn lights. We're doing a shallow coffer in the living room just to the right of the entry. Thanks for all the great ideas. I just checked the plans and our architect called out an 8' 6" ceiling height in the foyer with a 5 1/4" crown. This would frame the space and then we can just put in 2 cans. I still feel like I want a nice light in there. Would 2 pendants instead of cans look off?
  • 12 years ago
    At 8'-6" ceiling height, I think anything sticking down more than about 12" will look off.18" would be max anyway. Remember that the transom goes almost to the ceiling, so it will be easier to notice anything off. Did you look at the white glass trim for recessed? If you use 2 recessed lights with a decorative trim, maybe you could put a sconce on the wall to the left of the door. This would visually give the off-center area a purpose, making it seem correct.
    Another option is a short soffit in the left corner with a separate recessed can in it and a table under it. This tiny soffit would even out or center the ceiling on the door and allow for a soft night-light effect by the door highlighting a decorative table ensemble.
  • 12 years ago
    Like this, with a light in the center of the door openings. The 5 1/4" crown (in yellow) would go around a 6" deep soffit with a recessed light in it to highlight decor.
  • 12 years ago
    Fred I think we're close to a solution. Thank you for all of your great suggestions! We stopped by the house today and came up with the following. Center a light on the door. I am still thinking pendant. Frame a 72" square in the ceiling recessed 6" if possible and use painted bead board in the center (our door with side lights is 72" wide). So the pendant would hang in the middle of this ceiling and the door. Add 1 can to the left of the door in the corner which will shine on a table and another on the wall opposite the corner between the foyer and eat in kitchen area. We'll put some artwork on this wall. Not sure about the soffit in the corner if we're creating a large coffer in front of the door although it may be a necessity since it doesn't look like they will be able to fit a can in the ceiling with the beams all connecting in that corner. I would prefer to put recessed lighting there but may end up with a sconce. I think this will put the room in balance.
  • 12 years ago
    Sure, I think that I would actually have to be there to get you any more detailed ideas :) It certainly sounds like you have a good vision and backup plans to make it look great now. Just ask if you run into any more snags, and don't forget to bring your camera ;)
  • 12 years ago
    One more thing. Make absolutely sure the recessed light housing is AIR-TIGHT and IC (insulation contact) rated. In this configuration of the addition, when the wind blows, it builds up a bit more pressure than normal and pushes cold air out the can and into the house.
  • 12 years ago
    Will do. Thanks again and happy Thanksgiving!