Hi! Here are a few options for you that aren't leather, Hope this helps!

http://deciture.com/shop/furniture/7/custom-rockford-sofa/


http://deciture.com/shop/furniture/7/gordon-tufted-sofa/

Thank you for the ideas, unfortunately I am unable to spend thousands of dollars on a sofa. I would prefer some help in determining the "look" of the furniture popular during the craftsman era. I can do the upholstering myself. I just do not know what the styles of the fabric were.

Go to a site like Design TEX or Maharram (fabric) and do a search using the term ( craftsman, Morris, historic, nature ,or go to a furniture site such as Stickley and see the period designs of their fabrics on various chairs and sofas - generally the craftsman style was a return to nature and a reaction against the industrial age so most simple stylized natural inspired patterns will work.

have you done a keyword search right here on Houzz yet? This will visually show you what other homeowners, designers, architects etc have done in their craftsman bungalows. Then you can create an ideabook, and tags ones that you are drawn too, and maybe you'll see a pattern of what you like.