Stainless or white fridge?

10 years ago

We are needing to replace our 20 year old refrigerator that came with our house. The other appliances in the kitchen are newer and white. As you can see we have white cabinets and light gray countertops. I don't see us replacing the other appliances unless they break, and the only plans I have for the kitchen are to add a backsplash and maybe a few glass doors on the cabinet. Would a stainless fridge look out of place? While I am concerned about resale value (people seem to love SS) I care more about the everyday look. as we will be in our house for the foreseeable future. I would like to get a french door with a bottom freezer. The space is fairly wide and deep, but the cabinet overhead restricts the height to 68" so there are only a few models to choose from. Does anyone have a brand of refrigerator they recommend?

Featured Answer

PRO

LM Designers

10 years ago

Get a white refrigerator. Your kitchen looks beautiful with your white appliances. Stainless is on it's way out. May take awhile but it is no longer the desired material.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (30)

tlow21
10 years ago
I would go with white. SS is so hard to keep clean.
Related Professionals
Stanford Interior Designers & Decorators · Freehold Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · New Castle Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Austin Furniture & Accessories · Topeka Furniture & Accessories · West Palm Beach Furniture & Accessories · Aliso Viejo Furniture & Accessories · Van Nuys Furniture & Accessories · Banning General Contractors · Deer Park General Contractors · Great Falls General Contractors · San Bruno General Contractors · Spencer General Contractors · Uniondale General Contractors · Welleby Park General Contractors
meandbloss
10 years ago
I would go stainless in looks nicer and more modern
Denita
10 years ago
Go with a white French door refrigerator. After all, you are going to be there for the long term. It is better to have the refrigerator you want rather than getting something for an unknown buyer years into the future.
pureguava
Original Author
10 years ago
Thanks all! I think we might go white with a stainless handle. The white refrigerators these days are smooth like the other appliances- I wanted to avoid the textured look which seems dated.
PRO
Sound Painting Solutions, LLC
10 years ago
Stainless is great, but I would stick with the theme you have going. I would say go with white. Your kitchen looks great... changing the fridge out will make a huge difference. Good luck! :).
mistypix
10 years ago
Go with white. The fridge will be the focal if you do stainless, and I don't think you want it to stand out. I have stainless appliances and HATE them. Don't listen to people who say they are easy to keep clean.
PRO
Cynthia Taylor-Luce
10 years ago
Yes, the new white ones are beautiful :)
PRO
SoCal Contractor
10 years ago
I'd go with white. You can see how your toaster oven sticks out amongst the white appliances, imagine a huge fridge.
As for the brand, it really depends on your budget. If you can afford it, go with Sub Zero.
PRO
Nancy Sanford Interiors
10 years ago
White - stainless will close in the space
pureguava
Original Author
10 years ago
Thanks everyone! I'm going to go with white- can anyone recommend a reliable brand? Deciding between Samsung, KitchenAid, Whirlpool and maybe GE. Whirlpool seemed cheaper on inside with drawer pulls etc. I haven't been able to see any of the actual models in a store so will have to order sight unseen.
PRO
Julie Smart Koob, REALTOR
10 years ago
I have a GE Profile and really like it. Also French door top with freezer on the bottom.
belletriste
10 years ago
I had the same decision to make myself and went with white and am glad I did. My daughter used stainless in her all-white kitchen and the look is more choppy. Mine is KitchenAid with freezers on the bottom. However, it has had the freezer repaired several times in the past few years. My trusty repairman, who has been in the business for almost 30 years, says GE is the brand he buys based on repair records and costs.
PRO
Brio Interior Design
10 years ago
White, you won't regret it.
Dreacorator
10 years ago
Different models of each brand have their + & -. I chose a Samsung but the one I have is a bit noisy. And btw, white.
januarisun
10 years ago
SS would be a nice contrast, and bring out the grey in your countertops.
megen20
10 years ago
I would go stainless............
feeny
10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago
Keep it consistent with the white. Since you have a white glass front stove (we had that model and loved it!) consider looking at a white glass front fridge. Or the Whirlpool white ice line with stainless handles.
Amy 2407
10 years ago
stainless would
look better ...too much white makes it look pale
Sarah McColm
10 years ago
I would rip out that over fridge cabinet and get the fridge as tall as I could. It can't be really valuable storage if you've put a plant in front of it :).
saratogaswizzlestick
10 years ago
I think your decision for white is a good one. I love how the French door fridges are organized. Wish I had a recommendation. What I would suggest us google problems and the name of the fridge and see what pops up. I love that you have a real plant over your cabinets.
carolalons
10 years ago
waw
decoenthusiaste
10 years ago
My friend was convinced by a sales person to go with Samsung instead of Kitchen Aid and has regretted it. If you can find one made in USA (used to be Whirlpool) buy American, before there is no such thing.
PRO
Joanna Perry Murals
10 years ago
as a qualified mural artist and interior designer www.joannaperrymurals.co.uk, I think white or getting a built in unit would look best as s/s can mark and look to modern for a small space. good luck
helixg1
10 years ago
I agree that white would work best in your kitchen, but I love my brushed stainless. Not a problem to clean.
belletriste
10 years ago
Here's a nice photo of a kitchen around your size done with all stainless. I agree there's much to love about stainless. However, IMHO the main idea is consistency so as to give a much-used and almost always crowded space a sense of calm or Zen-like congruency. Here's a white kitchen using stainless appliances to good advantage: https://www.houzz.com/discussions/are-the-sides-of-fridge-black-or-stainless-dsvw-vd~167102
cindyguent
10 years ago
On my second GE profile with bottom freezer in 13years. Newest one has been made more cheaply than the first, with drawers having cracking problems (two broke). Both have had problems with maintaining proper temp. Everything I put on top shelf or bottom drawers freezes, in the refrigerator! My last one did that eventually, why I bought another is beyond me. Would not recommend. First one was repaired to the tune of $400 before I got rid of it. It's just my husband and me so it's not abused by constant opening and closing. Btw, mine have been stainless but I think white for you.
rocketjcat
10 years ago
I would definitely go white in your kitchen, and like the idea posted earlier of removing the upper cabinet if needed to give you more options in your search. Don't sub- optimize a fridge that you will use daily for one cabinet that appears to be dead storage. I also would recommend looking at the Profiles or counter depth fridges. They give you more floor space and it wouldn't seem to over power your cabinets like the current one does. They give a much nicer look. Good luck. Appliance shopping can be a crap shoot, knowing that these expensive purchases are not built to last anymore.
Laura Mac
5 years ago
Stainless would look good since. your counters are gray. Be careful of white right next to your white stove. The die-lots will not match and would look....bad. Or get a refrigerator that matches the brand of the stove if you want white.

There are other threads you might find feedback as far as brand.

Good luck!
Rita S
5 years ago
I recommend you go with stainless fridge since your countertop is greyish. It will look nicer than white. Just keep in mind that you need to clean it more often and you need to avoid touching its doors with dirty or greasy hands.

Stainless or white fridge?

LM Designers

Comments (30)

tlow21

Related Professionals

meandbloss

Denita

pureguava
Original Author

Sound Painting Solutions, LLC

mistypix

Cynthia Taylor-Luce

SoCal Contractor

Nancy Sanford Interiors

pureguava
Original Author

Julie Smart Koob, REALTOR

belletriste

Brio Interior Design

Dreacorator

januarisun

megen20

feeny

Amy 2407

Sarah McColm

saratogaswizzlestick

carolalons

decoenthusiaste

Joanna Perry Murals

helixg1

belletriste

cindyguent

rocketjcat

Laura Mac

Rita S

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Stainless or white fridge?

Comments (30)

Related Professionals

pureguavaOriginal Author

pureguavaOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

pureguava
Original Author

pureguava
Original Author