I have thought about that. I am worried that the brick underneath is a brighter color because it has not been exposed. May try it though as the have always bugged me.

You might try a different color as your brick is red - a glossy navy or grey green might really pop. Also if you are worried about removing shutters maybe paint them the white trim color so they don't compete with newly painted dooe

Have you ever considered not having a storm door?

lizakirk, if you read this short excellent article, with photos, it will show you why the shutters always bugged you :) I find it interesting to know the 'why' too. I agree, remove the shutters.
http://www.lifeofanarchitect.com/residential-architecture-101-shutters/

Mfwolf - the interior hallway can be dark so we need up with the front door open all the time. Also the dog likes to look outside:).

Thinking a wooden storm would look better.

I agree with removing the shutters on either side of the door. I would also remove the upstairs window shutters. I would keep the trim white and paint the hand railings white, also. Consider painting both doors black or a dark green so your entryway looks consistent and larger. Think about adding a larger size hanging porch lantern. Your home has some lovely architectural features and the red brick is beautifully traditional! Add spring flowers in your urns and you are set to enjoy warmer weather.