We are down to two choices for a backspash - both porcelain tile that have the look of natural stone. With either, we would do the subway 3 by 6 everywhere except over the range, where we would do a square of 1 by 1's on either a diagonal or straight pattern outlined with pencil molding. The first few photos are of the island, cabinets, and granite. The range hood is not yet up, but is a burnished copper. Granite is ice brown, cabinets are canvas and the island cabinets are cognac. The 3rd and 4th photos show the backslash choices. I am leaning toward the tile in photo 3 because it has both gray and brown tones, both of which are in the granite, as well as in our hood. The 4th choice is mostly brown. Thanks in advance for your help!