Software
Houzz Logo Print
prajnaparamita

Fear of Commitment.

12 years ago
I am trying to choose a new paint color for my living room. My home is a 1940 Spanish Mediterranean-style home in the San Francisco Bay Area and the interior walls are hand-troweled plaster with wood baseboards and no crown moulding. Please see pix but try to ignore all furniture and mess since it is all in flux right now and the furniture is about to be either replaced (ciao, giant cranberry couch) or reupholstered (blanket-covered victorian chairs), each to its own fate. The fact that there is no moulding makes it especially difficult for me to commit to a non-traditional mediterranean wall color because I don't really like a sharp contrast between ceiling and wall when there is no crown moulding. While I appreciate the natural, creamy, and yellow tones of many mediterranean designs, I may want something little different. My style overall is eclectic, but not over-the-top, although you can't see that in these photos. I would love to have a subtle blue/green color on the walls, but I either would have to deal with the sharp contrast in color, or risk a home that looks like a cave with similar color all around from walls to ceiling.

I'm looking at Farrow and Ball colors because they are GORGEOUS, so I would love to find something that works. So far my favorite choices are Mizzle and Vert de Terre on the gray-green side, and Light Blue (which is much grayer than a typical light blue). Maybe a 50% of one of these colors? As mentioned earlier, I do like the creamy colors, as long as they are both warm and cheerful (Cream?, String?), without being too yellow, and don't make my house feel like boring tract hotel decor (sorry, Archive). Maybe some sort of magical paint technique?

Two more things: After I choose my overall color, I'll choose a strong color for one or two walls in the dining room (possibly Hague Blue, Studio Green, French Gray, or Brinjal, depending on the overall color, though I'm open to any other color), so keep that in mind as you consider my dilemma; and secondly, I prefer not to use bright white for the window trim and baseboards, so I'm leaning toward White Tie, or perhaps Dimity, Clunch, or Pointing, depending on the paints I choose. I love the idea of darker trim than wall color, but my window frames are white, so I prefer to use a lighter trim color there to bring the attention away from that. Before we moved in, the original wooden window frames were replaced with new white double-panes, so it is practical, but not a very romantic or warm look.

I have been looking at colors for months now and am really torn. I even went so far as to paint poster board size samples for each, but am still having difficulty committing to a color because it is hard for me to imagine the outcome. Any advice is welcome and much needed . . . and kudos to anyone who read through to the end of this heartfelt plea. Thank you! Warm regards . . . .

Comments (15)

  • 12 years ago
    What a beautiful home with such personality! Have you chosen fabrics? That's usually the first step. With that said, how about this:
    http://houzz.com/photos/817328
    Or the Light blue Farrow & Ball?

    I think the accent wall colors are too extreme.

    Post fabrics, furniture that's staying.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    prajnaparamita, I live in the Bay Area as well. I’ve worked in many homes like yours, so I’m familiar with your situation. I don’t think you have to stick with the traditional Spanish/mission style colors. They key is to tie everything together.

    I agree with pphlelps on the ceiling. Choose a lighter color in the same family as the wall color. For example, many color fan decks have 5 different shades of the same color, lighter usually on top and darker on the bottom. After you choose your wall color, go up about 2 shades on the fan deck to get the ceiling color. If there isn’t a color light enough, you can get paint at half tint.

    In terms of no hard edges between the ceiling and wall, this can be addressed with a paint technique, but I would recommend you hire a professional who knows how to do this, or practice a lot yourself until you’re happy with the outcome. . . which is continuously blending the two colors.

    After the ceilings and walls are painted different colors and are dry, take your ceiling color and wall color and mix them together in equal proportions. Paint this color at the join between wall and ceiling. Now take a little more ceiling color and run a “stripe” along the ceiling, feathering/blending the join of the two different colors. Keep doing this until your eye can’t see the difference. Now do the same thing along the wall, adding more and more wall color until you can’t see a difference. Keep in mind that paint dries darker than it looks when wet.

    As for envisioning the end product, find a friend with PhotoShop skills. It’s very straight forward to take photos of a room and add your colors to the wall in the photo. It won’t be 100% accurate, but it helps. I offer my clients this service when they are having trouble envisioning an outcome.

    Best of luck,
    Katie
    A Fine Finish
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Do not panic when painting! It's just paint! Don't judge your decision until you get a wall finished and it has dried completely. Live with it for a few days if you are unsure. When changing colors from white to something else, the first roller stroke can make you feel like, "what have I done?" Keep painting! When choosing colors like blue or green, steer towards a shade that looks like it may have a little black in it...that will keep you from picking baby colors! Also, go to Home Depot or Lowes and look at their pamphlets the pros have prepared. The put colors together for you and tell you which colors go where. Who knows...maybe you will find exactly what you are looking for! Good Luck! YOU CAN DO IT! I do agree, it may be best to find an inspiration piece like fabric or a piece of art work. Pull your colors from them.
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks so much to those who have responded already -- such kind and helpful comments! I will reply later with more specifics since I woke up at this ungodly hour only because one of my dogs got sick :-( and after consoling him I decided to check Houzz as way to relax before climbing back in bed (Hello, 3:45 a.m.!). Until later, take care! - Judy (prajnaparamita)
  • 12 years ago
    @pphelps: Thanks so much for your suggestion -- you're definitely right, the ceiling doesn't have to be white. I'll keep that in mind moving forward! Warm regards, Judy
  • 12 years ago
    @laurakdesigns: Thank you so much for your kind comment! Thanks also for your good advice. I am beginning to learn that I probably should choose fabric first. The reason I started with the paint is two-fold: First, it's VERY hard for me to commit to paint colors, yet it seems relatively easy for me to choose fabrics. Second, I have three pieces of art in my living room that are very special to me. I want to make sure the paint color doesn't detract from these pieces, so I wanted the widest range of options - so I thought I'd do that first. What is the reasoning behind choosing the fabrics first? I haven't chosen anything yet, so it's not too late to adjust my thinking!

    Regarding the paint colors: Those are really good options you suggest. In fact I was inspired to spot by one of the paint shops in San Francisco today to pick up a decent Farrow & Ball fan deck, as well as an updated Ben Moore fan deck, and to look at the painted wood panels they have there. What incredible colors . . . .

    I am really taking to heart your advice that the colors I am considering for the accent wall in the dining room may be too extreme. I am beginning to agree, mainly because I think my space is a bit too small to manage that color. I still want something really interesting and somewhat dramatic, but now I'm thinking not so extreme.

    In terms of furniture that's staying - probably the English Art Deco sideboard that backs against the sofa (the lovely mirror has been removed, but can be reattached at any time); also the two victorian shell chairs. That's about it. I want to get one or two comfortable chairs and a fabric ottoman, in addition to a sofa that is a bit smaller than what I have currently. As I move forward in the coming months, I will post more pix as I consider fabrics, etc. I hope you will be able to offer additional suggestions at that time. Thank you again! Warm regards, Judy
  • 12 years ago
    @ Katie @afinefinish: What a fantastic idea! Thank you so very much for this suggestion. I am wondering if you have any pictures of work you may have done with this technique you describe. I would love to see how it looks and if it matches what I am imagining. Thank you also for your advice in choosing the right shade for the ceiling - I love the idea of 50% tint. As for the photoshop preview - Great idea! My son has some PhotoShop skills, so I had better take advantage of that before he heads off to college! Warm regards, Judy
  • 12 years ago
    @StaceyHudson: What a fantastic pep talk! This is just what I needed to boost my confidence in moving forward with my projects. Thanks so much for your valuable suggestions and kindest encouragement! Warm regards, Judy
  • 12 years ago
    I think I'm picking up a feminine color for your style. Artistic and flowery. You have a lot of personality and interests. Your room color should blend with your creativity. Try very pale pink....
  • 12 years ago
    What a beautiful room! Even as is it is SOOO pretty. No pink though. None. Do not do pink. How about a soft blue- grey on the walls?. Sort of to match the lovely San Francisco sky... With whatever you want on the baseboard? Also maybe do only 1 wall at first since you are not good with commitment. Do 1 wall as an accent wall to see if you like the feel. Very very pretty room. The arched doorways are so nice. Lucky you.
  • 12 years ago
    Since you are best with fabric, do choose those first. Paint is much easier after choosing the pieces you will live with longer than a paint color. I definitely agree the ceilings do not need to stay white....in fact, that's the first thing I thought when looking at your photos! Such a great opportunity to NOT have boring white ceilings. Maybe a little shine with a very subtle metallic paint element say, in the dining room?
  • 12 years ago
    prajnaparamita-- post photos of your art to help with wall colors to enhance them. Depending on the colors in the art, the blues you're thinking of may actually not be the best. The art will give you a jumping off point for everything.
  • 12 years ago
    I am a Benjamin Moore paint fan. Check out spa for the ceiling and urban nature for the wall.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    My best decorating advice, is do not fear the paint. The absolute worst case, you paint over the paint. You have a stunning canvas to work with.