Software
Houzz Logo Print
skypotato

Add a second floor or move?

12 years ago
My wife and I are starting to think about moving vs. adding a second story to our quaint 850 sqft 1940s bungalow. We love the area and I love the idea of having a unique home. What are the pro's and con's? If we completed this project our house might be "priced out" of our street.

Comments (15)

  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    It will cost as much as buying the house again and it prices you out of the neighborhood. What's to think about? It would take 20 years to pay you back. If you are going to live there for 30 years, then maybe.
    http://www.remodeling.hw.net/cost-vs-value/2014/
    skypotato thanked User
  • 12 years ago
    Talk to an architect and get a real handle on what it's going to cost you to do, it might be less, or it might be more than you think. Remember, moving is another option, but it isn't cheap either. Realtors get payed by the seller typically, but if you sell yours they get a chunk of the proceeds, plus there are bundles of closing costs, moving services, and let's face it, there's a good chance you may want to make small changes to the new place and that all adds up too...
    skypotato thanked Katie Gooding
  • 12 years ago
    Is there room to go out rather than up?
    skypotato thanked pcmom1
  • 12 years ago
    Move! Unless you are in an area where an 850 sf house is @ $1000/sq ft, move!
    skypotato thanked dog3mom
  • 12 years ago
    I would move if u find a house that seem perfect to u and is cheaper than adding a second floor. But if ur content with the house u have and the location it's in I would add a second floor
    skypotato thanked chewey123
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    You like the house, you like the location. I suggest looking around at alternatives--how much would you need to spend to secure another house that you like, in the location you like, and suitable to your needs for a larger place. now you have a budget for your reno. Can you achieve what you want for less (bearing in mind your opportunity to create something truly yours)? Or, do the numbers advise against a reno--and you feel that numbers are the primary issue.

    In one case, I designed a place for a couple intending to stay for decades in the location they love, an area sure to increase in value--but that was a minor consideration as there is no intent to sell. The 450k reno increased the house value well beyond the neighbourhood...but...their project inspired several others and in the last property tax assessment, the house which had reached the top position in the area has now been tied for the second spot. That is, the neighbourhood rose to the occasion and everyone has benefited.

    This project proceeded against the advice of real estate agents and assessors (with nervous bankers) and became a catalyst for improvements that have, in turn, increased the basic land value for every house in the neighbourhood (with pleased bankers).

    Of course one should bear in mind the market--you don't want to throw away value. At the same time, it's your life to enjoy, your home to create. What criteria would YOU identify in making this decision?
    skypotato thanked John James O'Brien | Inspired Living, by design
  • 12 years ago
    Thank you all for your generous and insightful comments. I have decided to reach out to several architects to open a dialogue on my options. this will be weighed against purchasing a house of similar character.

    There are many considerations, financially and non-financially that we will need to weigh. I keep returning to notion that if I do not focus on my house as a financial investment but rather a 'place to live' then I shouldn't weigh the financials as heavily. yet, life is uncertain and say in 5-10 years moving does become an intention, then our hands might be forced to sell at an under-cost point.
  • 12 years ago
    Am curious... Any update?
    skypotato thanked sgalatz
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Quote: " If we completed this project our house might be "priced out" of our street" ---> If that is the case then move because this equates to bad investment (won't make money upon resell)
    skypotato thanked Curt D'Onofrio
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Resale often drives how we live now...but it may be a philosophical question as much as an economic one. Shouldn't we live now as we might want, rather than always putting off to tomorrow, constraining ourselves in the hope that "one day" ... ? Can't advise against Curt's view—again, I always bear that consideration in mind. But, it may not be so simple. And, in a recent project, we spent almost as much as the home was worth—well over it's street value. The result was pulling up the property values in adjacent properties some of which we own, thereby increasing equity) and inspiration for the neighbours...across the street, a new hand beveled basalt wall is going up at around 30k. Context is everything!
  • 12 years ago
    Hi all, we haven't made a decision as of yet! I've canvassed so many "experts", including architects and investment analysts, but as John correctly observes, this is really a philosophical question.

    Do we love the location enough to tear it down and build it up?
    Do we love the house enough to leave it alone? (it is a 1940's bungalow in fantastic condition, including original hardwood and plaster ceilings)
    Do we allow the financial aspects to drive our decision - such as the "issue" of pricing ourselves out of a location?

    Personally, I don't care to allow the concern about 'resale value' to overwhelm my perspective, which is ironic because I work in that field (finance/economics). A big part of me is excited by the opportunity to invest not just money, but personality and creativity into a project - that, to me, is a big part of the value. on the flip-side, though, is a growing desire to leave the house alone as it is really quite a wonderful place as it is (its just too small for our growing family).

    we wont be making a decision for at least 12 more months, at which point I can fill you all in.
  • 12 years ago
    Also, I will say that there are quite a few places around ours starting to add second floors, and generally undergo large renovations. So while we may be at (if not the) high-end, I don't think it will be a complete anomaly.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Skypotato, thanks for the acknowledgement - your place sounds wonderful. It is possible to take a 1940s places (what great bones!) and update / enlarge it without losing that essential character. that's a reno that may cost more (a question of the skills of your trades and oversight by yourself or your rep) and most importantly, attention to the right design aesthetic. If you go ahead, I hope you'll post photos. Good luck!
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Here are a couple of photos showing a second story addition to previously single story bungalows:
    Craftsman Bungalow · More Info

    Queen Anne Bungalow Resurrection · More Info