The decision might be based on whether you want a cool, warm, or warmer look in your kitchen. They can all look great. Based on the bottom photo, you've got the (left) cool choice, the (middle) warm choice and at the end, the very warm, rich choice. I like the middle option, but it's not my kitchen!

I like the two closest to the front of the picture. The one in the fron will look nice with the white, but will also look nice when you go darker. The middle one is also very pretty (my favorite), but will be very high contrast with a dark cabinet (which I like, but it's a personal preference). The farthest one away I think may be too dark, will make your kitchen look dark with dark cabinets.... unless you have lighter flooring or a lot of natural light.

Thanks guys -- The cabinets will remain white -- the floor is the cherry endevor in the future-- Im leaning towards the middle one too but the hubs thinks it might me too light :)

I agree- the middle one would look best with your cabinetry. Very elegant and classic!

good luck!
Anna