I think that Todd is going for this look. I want the wood to go all the way up to the ceiling, not stop at the mantle.
I don't like white shiplap. It looks dated.
I prefer the mitered corners of this fireplace and the frame-less firebox
I do not like the look of framing. I don't like the corners. I don't like such a rustic, unfinished look.
I love the way the pattern lines up exactly with the distance between firebox and mantle.
Q