We had a master bathroom with a walk-in closet done by Acclaim Renovation, then known as One Man and a Hammer, December 2014-February 2015. We chose One Man and a Hammer based on their years in business, reviews we read online, and the fact that they offered design services.
We were very pleased with the design phase. Mark and Bob were extremely pleasant to work with. We appreciated their passion for their work, and both of them had very helpful ideas and input on how to use the space. We picked out the cabinetry and tile at the One Man and a Hammer showroom, where there was a nice selection to choose from.
Our problems started the first week work began at our home in early December. We came home on Monday, the first day, to find the screen door from the garage into the house locked. This door can only be locked from the inside – it is impossible to lock it, close the door, and have it remain locked. The door from the garage into the house was not the one they had a key to so we are not sure why the workers were using it.
Wednesday morning when we took a shower in the main bathroom we found that the master shower drain, which was connected to the main bathtub’s drain, had not been capped. Water was coming out of the kitchen ceiling below the master bathroom. The workers capped the drain and did repair the damage to the kitchen ceiling.
Thursday afternoon we came home to find the front door standing open and the key box used to store the front door key had also been left open. The workers had left for the day.
We called One Man and a Hammer and they assured us that leaving the house open would not happen again. Monday of the second week we found that the master bathroom window had been left open. Again the workers had left for the day.
Fortunately the serious issues stopped, but as the project progressed we had other issues. We found damage to the front door casing and several dings in the drywall in the front entry. We indicated prior to the work beginning that we had just finished painting the front entry, stairway, and second floor hallway and would like care to be taken as the work progressed. We had 4 doors and 13 windows replaced, air conditioning, and hardwood installed in 3 rooms prior to this project. We did not have any of this kind of damage as a result of any of those projects.
We had some issues with the quality of the work that was performed. We had One Man and a Hammer correct some of the issues, other we chose not to have corrected. We consider these to be a difference of opinion. We discussed with the owner Bob during the final walk-through we think greater attention to detail would have produced much better results.
We discovered our most significant issue this year. Because of our experience with One Man and a Hammer we chose another company to remodel our kitchen. During this project we found that one of the floor joists was cut through to make room for the shower drain. 3 ½ inches of the joist was completely removed from a joist, from the floor above it to the kitchen ceiling drywall below it. The drain pipe was in the middle of the gap in the joist.
Unfortunately we approached One Man and a Hammer with anger, which was inappropriate and uncalled for. We regret our reaction and we apologized for our behavior. One Man and a Hammer did offer to repair the damage. We chose to have our new contractor perform the repair as we believe the solution One Man and a Hammer proposed was not sufficient. We also did not have confidence in One Man and a Hammer’s ability to perform the repair properly because structural damage was done to our home when they worked on it 3 years ago. One Man and a Hammer did offer to pay for ¼ of the cost of the repair, which we accepted. We had to email One Man and a Hammer twice before they sent us a check 5 weeks after we requested it.
We have seen the many excellent reviews for One Man and a Hammer. We have also noticed that One Man and a Hammer at times asks for suggestions on what they can do better. In the spirit of helping One Man and a Hammer improve, we offer the following suggestions:
1.Supervise work that is being done. As stated above this is something we discussed at the final walkthrough.
2.Perform all work according to building code. Ohio code, section 502.8, concerning floor joists can be found here - http://codes.ohio.gov/oac/4101:8-5-01v1.
3.Respect your clients and their property. This will prevent both the issues we experienced in the first 2 weeks of our project and the more serious issue of damaging your client’s property.
We wish One Man and a Hammer well, and we are sorry to say that we cannot give them a better review. We very much would have liked to have been able to do so.
6 Comments