I would try to match the siding colour and paint the garage doors that colour. The front door could be white with a pretty wreath on it to add colour. That would be a very fresh look. I like the white shutters because they make the windows look larger. They are actually too narrow for the windows so if you paint them in a contrasting colour the mismatch of sizing will jump out at you. In white, you won't have that problem.

Thanks for the feedback. Would you also repaint the large white section under the peak the siding color when I repaint the garage doors. What about natural wood for the front door with the trim left white.

I think the white triangle looks light and airy and lifts the peak of that part of the house. I love natural wood doors but I think they suit brick or stone houses, and not painted/siding houses. If you're changing the door, why not get a french style door with mostly glass and white muntin bars to give it some style. I love the doors with glass and wrought iron, but again, I don't think that style would be suitable for this house. Does this help? Best wishes.

We are painting a lot of garage doors/frames the body color because are not wanting to call them out or highlight them. So that would drive the decision on the white peak, it is highlighted now and if you want it to blend then paint it the body color, which is what I would do. I agree not to use a stained door especially if you face the sun most of the day. You would have to clear coat the door every 6 to 12 months to prevent damage to the stain. With a gray body color we are painting a lot of doors black especially since you have a large surround on the front door that is white already, if door was white this might make that to much white. If you decided to not paint garage doors body color I would not have them match the front door, let that be the accent color, so other choice is white for garage doors. If you need a painting quote visit www.certapro.com to find a local painting professional.