you have a lot of stylistic elements fighting each other on your house! the roof is a Mansard (but with a Rustic wood shake roof), the window shapes/styles/sizes are modern, the garage door is Craftsman and your front door is Colonial. another photo showing the entire house might help with the overall scale and proportions of what you can do to help the curb appeal here.

since the roof is so prominent, i would start by blending everything else to match it in color. so consider gray paints, from white smoke all the way to black (you can do black in Colorado, if you like that look). the huge garage door near the front door is not "inviting", so the garage door gets painted to match the walls.

the focal point should be the front door and the window next to it. i would go so far as to recommend painting the 1st floor part of that wall a different color from the rest of the house. include the adjacent wall up to but not including the garage door. this "Corner" is your welcoming target spot. when this stands out, the rest of the house will fade into the background.

consider this image a very rough schematic showing the entry "Corner".