Hello rlevchets,

This question certainty comes often and it's always valid because it involves personal taste and budget constraints. Like you stated there are cons and pros to each of the materials that you are thinking about. Out of all three the best material to go with is Ipe but it will come at a price.

Cedar Decks are very common throughout the Eastern United States but it is a softwood that requires sealing, power washing, and staining every year, and with proper maintenance you'll be getting 8-10 years at best before it begins showing it's signs of wear and tear. The great thing about them is that it's relatively cheap and easily attainable at any lumber yard.

Timbertech is a composite and they do have different lines to suit each budget, with regular composite, capped composite and all PVC decking. Having said that, the best alternative for any of them is to do either capped or PVC decking (which comes at a steeper price). the downside to composites is two fold. One has to do with the look of it. It's plastic, and it looks, feels, and heats up like plastic. It still requires maintenance and sometimes special products to clean. Any small gouge or scratch can't be sanded off like wood can and replacing each board can be quite difficult because of the color variations that manufacturing has.during the heat it can bend and feel very hot under your feet and as time progresses it will fade in color, even with the fade warranty.

Ipe is the best choice out of all three because it requires little maintenance. Brushing and washing down for regular maintenance and a smooth sanding on stubborn stains. A coat of Ipe Oil is needed every year or so to keep the rich color but if you prefer it to gray out, no oil is required. Ipe does have a 75 year lifetime and won't splinter or crack even while it grays out. The biggest downside is the price. There are alternative woods that do just as great as Ipe like Cumaru and Tigerwood but are more budget friendly.

Attached are a few images of all three products for you to see.

I hope all the information helps you out in your decision. If you have other questions that we can help you answer, feel free to send uis a message or give us a call!