Have the 6" backsplash removed so you can install your new backsplash properly.

I don't think your glass tile is busy at all. It looks like it's just different solid colors, and it appears to match you granite quite well from what I can see. It should look very nice when you get it up.

I would agree & remove the granite backsplash. It would look choppy otherwise...

Remove the 6" backsplash. It's not hard, I did mine, although it won't come off in one piece :)

Will I leave big holes in the wall board?

Go with the white subway tiles and keep the granite the way it is.

Wait I didn't see the picture! I'm sorry go for a CREAM/BEIGE COLOUR! Wow a picture is always worth a million words...

Or leave it the way it is...

I honestly don't like either of the choices of tile

Agree with Alison ,neither one with your granite

Remove backsplash and I agree with others I don't like either of the tile choices

I would try paint or bead board first. The bead board can be painted to match a color from the granite. Taking out the backsplash will probably damage the walls and require repair.

I'd leave the 6" granite backsplash and just paint.

I'd remove the tile and use a creamy/bone or light taupe subway tile. If cost isn't a problem, I'd use a crackle milk glass type of tile with softer edges (rather than a sharp edge). I think my granite is the same as yours and I still haven't taken the plunge, as I'm trying to decide if i want to paint over my medium stained maple cabinets. Best wishes!

Depends on your budget. I had to make the same decision (with the same or similar granite). I left the backsplash and went with a cream marble tile. If money were not an object, I would have taken down the backsplash, repaired walls (which will be necessary and gone with a glass tile. Either will look nice. Just depends on how much $$ (and time) you want to invest in the job.

Take off the 6". The multi color looks better with your stone. Otherwise go warmer colors on the subway.

take off the 6", but I wouldn't add anything yet. It appears from the picture that your granite is either yellow-based or green-based. Your top tile choice has too much red in it. That's why it appears off. The granite color is "muddier" than the white tile, which is why that looks off. I would work with the beadboard suggestion/just paint first, as you can easily match a paint to a color in your granite. Then, if you're just not feeling it, continue with the search for a tile. You want the granite to be the star/focal point and the other parts the supporting players.

I would remove the granite backsplash, otherwise it wouldn't look right. Also, I don't think the glass tiles are busy, in fact, with that color granite countertops I would choose the glass tile over the subway tile.

That's just based on the counter though. What does the rest of the kitchen look like?

Ditch the 6 inch backsplash. The tiles you selected don't match your granite. I don't know what the rest of the kitchen is like, but I'd use standard size subway tile. The granite is busy as is, with lots of speck and color. You want one color for the backsplash that blends overall with your granite. Tan, taupe or maybe cream. You'll have to stand back and look at the overall effect. I think subway tile is the way to go. The tiles shouldn't be too small and the grout should match the tile, IMHO. Good luck!

take out the 6" splash and use beige travertine, keep the materials all natural or all man made, don't mix them.

Yes ...otherwise it will look like a home-maker's nightmare!

Can you add a wider angle pic of your kitchen? I think it would help to visualize more of the space.

So, I've decided to leave as is and just paint. If I'm going to do tile, I'd rather do it right, but I don't want to spend the $$ to repair the walls. So, I've decided to leave it as it is. Thanks for all the advice! It really helped.

Actually you could leave the granite and add your glass tiles all the way up. I did it and I liked the result.

I love that mini subway mosaic! I also think it looks pretty darn good with your granite. The standard white subway is too white, too contrasting. Mixing the two would be a disaster. I think you could get away with leaving the 6" granite piece and dressing it up with the glass (at least I think it's glass?) mosaic. The added benefit is that you won't need quite as much either! I'm also worried that the "free" piece may have been added to hide a mistake along the wall when the granite was measured or installed! This can happen when walls are not straight. That mistake may not be covered by the tile as it won't be as thick. (p.s. before I retired I was a kitchen designer)

1)Remove the 6" piece, there is a reason it was free mostly to hide the gap along the wall
2) take whatever material you choose to use and run it along the wall to check and make sure the gap between the drywall and granite will be covered up
3) if the gap is not covered you can float the wall out using mastic don't worry about messing up the drywall you can cover it up with the material you choose
4) the hardest part about doing backslashes are the cuts around receptacles, faucets, and/or corners

Here are better views of the kitchen. The granite was from Home Depot, if I remember correctly.

Professional opinion have the granite backsplash removed. It will look better just tile.

Julie Smart- love your tile choice. Do you know the manufacturer, style, color and where you bought it?

Kcarty1--good ol' HomeDepot for the tile. The colored ones are called honey gold, I think.

We got them from Lowes, but just barely, LOL! They had decided to discontinue them and we had to go to seven different Lowes to get enough! I think they are by Orleans and is the Sand color. We went with the small pencil edge granite because I had not picked out my tile... Took about a year before I decided what I wanted. And as a previous poster said, it was to help with the gap between the countertop and the wall, especially behind the sink. I decided to keep mine , since it was so small, but the one you have is pretty big and I think I would have it removed prior to installing the backsplash. Good luck!

Thanks Julie:) Bummer they are discontinued.

ITs a much cleaner look if you remove the backsplash. Do keep in mind, depending on the granite company they may have left a little more spacing then what you normally would with a tile backsplash install. It is a possibility you could have gaps up to 3/8" that your current backsplash is covering. If that is the case, you may need a little float work performed before tile install. Its a strong possibility you will have an amount of drywall repair after removal anyways. No Mosaic. Simple glass or ceramic subway would be a better fit.

Kcarty, I did a quick search online and you can get something very similar! http://www.tilestoreonline.com/2_X_4_Brick_Subway_Glass_Tile_s/258.htm

I always say use tile from countertops to top cabinets. It is just more modern and is very nice.

I would remove the 6" backsplash and install a copper tile backsplash. Check out Homedepot.com They have a beautiful alloy copper 3 x 6 subway tile. It's a polished copper stainless steel mounted over porcelain, and the tiles need to be grouted. They are NOT the stick-on type! A copper tile backsplash all the way up to your cabinets would look stunning with your granite which appears to be a Ste. Cecelia type.

I agree with Lazarus. Copper would be awesome. Paint your cupboards.

Original post over a year ago

Great question! Leaving the 6" granite would work just fine when using our Aspect Peel and stick tiles whether it be the 3x6 size tile or the Aspect matted size. The tiles are offered in a variety of styles and colors that can match pretty much any look you are going for! http://www.houzz.com/projects/1338183//aspect-glass

People,.... remove the back splash.... the product you use will repair the wall. Anything else will look like you don't know what your doing. Always tile from counter top to top cabinet, use whatever you like. You live there, don't be afraid to mix it up with a combo of glass, porcelain, metal.... we are in 2017 it not the 1990's you will add interest on your investment later. Its ok to use subway but..... use one that brings color and interest, that won't lock you into one color scheme. Buyer want modern not grandma kitchen, if your doing farm house, buyers want farm houses kitchen thats are using modern ideas but look dated. I've seen your granite on model homes many, many times, its beautiful i know they used a combo of small one inch tiles or they used the long 1" in tiles out of porcelain and glass and metal. I also know they use 4x4 porcelain or travertine stone placed on a diamond pattern with dropping in something in the middle every so offen. But .... your kitchen says to me its farmhouse especially with the color of your cabinets. They are warm. Subway white tile will look fine but not exciting, it will be expecting. You should step out of that and go with modern farmhouse and use 1" strips mixed combo set with glass, metal and porcelain. Give it color! It will warm up the kitchen even more. Use a nice trim on the walls that aren't covered with a cabinet. Lastly consider using a stain on the cabinet to further warm it up.

Post what you've done

Update those appliances, don't rebuy everyhing but choose one color pick black or white but not both, lastly if you can change them to metal when you can will be 100% better then you have a kitchen everone would want.

Hire someone to install glass pendants over your island. There im finish.

Keep your 6" granite back splash and tile on top. When you take out the granite back splash you will never get a line you are happy with between the backspash and the counter.

I know you posted your question and picture a while ago, but I still want to thank you for posting it. We have almost identical granite and cabinets and I have been looking for tile for several weeks. For some reason I didn't think about that 4" granite backsplash until today. That's when I started searching the Internet for solutions. I am so glad I ran across your post.

In my opinion the 4-6" granite backsplash always makes the kitchen look lower grade. If you can remove it.

Remove the 6 inch granite. The glass tile is super busy. I have the same granite and I am in the process of removing the glass tile!! I like the idea of a larger off white- cream- milky white subway tile. Good luck!

Old post...