I held my hand over three, so I could envision the whole floor in that one remaining color. I think the ones on each end are too dark and between the middle two, wondering if second to left is too grey and "they" are saying grey only has another another 2-3 years before it starts to become less popular. So I would go with the beige and let the countertop and backsplash take centre stage.

I would choose whichever shade is closest to the dark pattern in your marble. I also like the two on the left, but it's hard to say which, because colors of everything to the left of the stove look different from those of everything to the right of it! Maybe it's the lighting in the photo?

I would go with the beige tile as well. Dark is great, but won't blend as well with your cabinetry and countertops, and it's much easier to tell when its dirty. You'll be cleaning twice as much with the dark tile as the beige, and nobody likes to clean more than they have too. Hope this helps!!

Yes it's the lighting :/ y'all really think grey is going out soon? Thought grey is a neutral? I favor the lightest on the left but do love the idea of matching to the dark veining ;)

I really like the beige!

I like the darkest on the right. A touch of dark will help to ground the space. I could only find examples with a deep wood finish, but I think your charcoal option will look just as classic and sharp.
[houzz=] [houzz=] [houzz=] [houzz=] [houzz=] [houzz=]

I'm favoring the two middle tiles. Do you have a piece of carrara you could lean against the splash? That would most helpful...

The one in front of the dishwasher looks perfect in your space.

Does this help at all these are the 3 you all think are looking best

Seriously thanks so much for all your help ;;)))!!!

I'm thinking the second (gray) tile could be the best option. I like the third one too, but am concerned that it will make the cabs look yellow and emphasize the blue veins in the marble.
oops, you switched the pics. OK, I think the tile I mentioned, is the only one you omitted from the updated pics.

I'm worried the lighter will look very south beach or 90s ?

It's the first one on the far left---the one just barely in third photo

Okay yes that washed looking tile I just moved and adjusted it into the picture

Do you think style is matching or not so much :/

BINGO!
That's it!

You know, wasn't that the tile you were thinking of going with from the very beginning? Trust your instinct. Perfect! :)

;;)) wait the darkest? That was my original lol sorry lol

Oh, I know you mentioned 2 the 2 on the left side photo 1... Those 2 are the best of the 4, BUT the lighter tile is the better of the 2. LOL!!! Oh Goodness... :)

Second from the left pulls out the gray veining in the counter top, is light enough not to compete with the other colors and is dark enough to hide dirt on the floor.

If your cabinets and countertops are light I would pick one of the darker tiles. You don't want the floor to merge with the cabinets. The dark grey is the accent color in the marble, So go for that, if you haven't already picked that is :) good luck.
Are you keeping the blinds or changing those out?

The ceiling will look like this and the blinds gone of course :) lol

Good grief, now in the new pics none of them look gray, lol! Because of the marble, I vote for the second from the left in the original photo. I think that means I agree with Natalie. :) I like the dark gray at the far left, too, but I'd worry about it showing every speck of dust.

Btw y'all are soon appreciated for your help when going into this i originally had white shaker cabinets but my husband thought thy looked cheap and I allowed him to join in and pick the cabinet as long as I got the marble now all my white shaker marble ideas have me stuck since the hubs got his choice of cabinet

Lol sooooo appreciated not soon :)