Software
Houzz Logo Print
kjosh

Need urgent help with Kitchen Cabinets - Paint or Refinish? Help!

11 years ago
Hi, My kitchen cabinets (and cabinets elsewhere) are in need of an urgent facelift. Have been procrastinating because I don't know which is better - 1) Paint or 2) Refinish.
I got a paint quote for $900 and a refinishing quote for $4000 for all cabinets in the house including the kitchen.
These are around 20 year old cabinets and we plan to leave the house in about 4 years. So thinking also from a reselling standpoint. My counter top is white with a grey and silver grain.
I am leaning towards painting since I am not in the house for too long and don't want to invest so much money.

If painting is the way to go, what colors will suit the cabinets? Can I do white? My backsplash has white, grey and navy blue.

Please let me your comments - would be much appreciated!

Comments (33)

  • 11 years ago
    white would work well
    kjosh thanked jennyrf
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    You can paint them to great effect! I suggest looking at a palette of colors for your entire kitchen before deciding on what color to paint the cabinets. White is bright and safe, however it shows a lot!
    kjosh thanked Archi/Build Group, Inc.
  • 11 years ago
    I'd do some checking into a DIY project. We own town homes and used a product from rusteolum and they looked great. I think a white, gray or something in between.
    kjosh thanked Sharon Manley
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago
    Paint or reface- either one would work. How much money do you want to spend and do you like the current style of the doors or looking for a different style?
    kjosh thanked cabingirl13
  • 11 years ago
    Paint white, but make sure it's a good color of white & a good process.
    kjosh thanked Carol Johnson
  • 11 years ago
    White or gray would be great. One word of caution. Look at the painter's other cabinet work in person and ask how they will prepare and paint the cabinets. I had a real estate agent recommend someone as a pro and he turned out to be a complete amateur. If your cabinets are oak and show grain paint alone won't hide the grain (which is fine, I painted twice leaving the grain to show and it worked well.) If you want your cabinets to not show any grain they will need to use a wood filler and sand first. Find out how many coats of primer and final coats the price includes. You want them to spray the cabinets but not the hardware. Hardware should be removed then reinstalled. I'm not certain for the price if they will be doing that. It is possible to brush on paint and get a good finish if you sand between coats. If they say the are using sponge brushes because that is what the big box store recommends, find another painter. Good luck.
    kjosh thanked jh77
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    Paint since you wont be staying in the home. White is an ok choice but considering the layout of the kitchen you might want to consider a grey color tone.
    kjosh thanked Interior Affairs -- Vickie Daeley
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago
    Love your vent hood and your floors look great! I would take the tile all the way to the ceiling next to the vent stack and up under the cabinets for a wow effect. I think painting your cabinets in a gray would really set them off from your lighter counter top and floors. Then, add some nice modern drawer and cabinet pulls.
    kjosh thanked Debbie Rugen Designs
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    Look at the Exterior of your home - is it a cool or warm palette? Did you carry that same feeling into the interior? if the exterior compliments the interior it will be pleasing to all buyers. Based on the Kitchen alone, I agree with Vickie Daeley with Interior Affairs. However, If your home leans towards the warmer tones...choose the creamy off white color: Elephant Tusk from Benjamin Moore. If the Grey is needed, try Benjamin Moore's, Silver Bells.
    kjosh thanked A'LLURE INTERIOR DESIGN BY RENE
  • 11 years ago
    Yes, white paint is the way to go. Just make sure your whites don't compete and compare them before to get just the right white.
    kjosh thanked denicekatija
  • 11 years ago
    Thank you all for your input - I highly appreciate it! All great advice.
    If I were to do a white - what whites would you recommend? I read on other reviews on houzz that Benjamin Moore Dove White was not too stark and a safe bet. Agree/Disagree?
  • 11 years ago
    Yeah, light grey sounds like a good color too. But I think one needs to be careful picking the color here else it can dull the area.
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    Hi, i would suggest painting them white. For more inspirational ideas, please feel free to read by blog about white kitchens: http://bit.ly/1uzFOUk.
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago
    Hi---Definitely paint... I recommend a deeper gray to add interest and contrast to the floor and counter hues. Check BM's Cos Cob Stonewall and Squirrel Tail
    Hope you find this helpful. Good Luck!
    [houzz=
    Traditional Kitchen · More Info
    ][houzz=
    Soft Modern Cabin in Mammoth · More Info
    ][houzz=
    Chevy Chase Home Makeover · More Info
    ]
    kjosh thanked Natalie
  • 11 years ago
    Paint all a soft gray, make sure to use paint made for cabinets. Lowes sells. use long brush nickel pulls. For a updated look.
    kjosh thanked Nancy Travisinteriors
  • 11 years ago
    With the light counter and tile, a dark color would look amazing with that backsplash. Try the rustoleum cabinet transformations!!
    kjosh thanked Andrea Smith
  • 11 years ago
    Awesome, thank you all!
  • 11 years ago
    So what is your view on how to paint?

    a) Show wood grain - sounds like an easier and less expensive process
    OR
    b) Do not show wood grain

    The latter requires light sanding and wood filling so more expensive. Thanks jh77 for your input on the kind of paint job. Pros or cons? Which way to go there? Please weigh in!!!
  • 11 years ago
    If having them done professionally, they should be sprayed. CheerS!
  • 11 years ago
    Yes, the person who is doing the painting will spray the paint. But my question was if one chooses not to show the wood grain, an additional process of wood filling and light sanding is required. Is it worth it go this route? What is better showing wood grain or not?
  • 11 years ago
    What shade of white would you recommend? Overwhelmed by the choices in the market! Please share your inputs....
  • 11 years ago
    Just take a sample of your backsplash tile and the floor tile to the paint store. Colors on monitors are not true.
    kjosh thanked apple_pie_order
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    I suggest that you have some fun with this. Go to your local paint store and collect all of the color chips for every shade of white that they have. If there are multiple shades of white per chip, then take a pair of scissors and cut them up so that there is only one shade of white per chip. Gather all of the color chips into your hands and throw them up into the air and let them fall to the floor. Any chips that land with the color showing, pick only those chips up and throw them into the air again. Repeat until there is only one color chip showing! Tape that chip onto a cabinet and look at it for 3 days. If after that time you simply can't live with that color, then repeat the process until you can. Let us know how it goes!
    kjosh thanked Archi/Build Group, Inc.
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    Painting is definitely a better way to go. We suggest an Grizzle Gray (SW 7068) or Iron Ore (SW 7069) from Sherwin-Williams. The contrast would look great with the beautiful backsplash.
    kjosh thanked Signature Design Group
  • 11 years ago
    We just purchased our home with the same pickled oak (pink) cabinets. I am in the middle of having them refinished in an Antique White Linen with Van Dyke brown glaze over them. The island will be Van Dyke brown. I am going with granite countertops and stainless steel appliances.
    kjosh thanked kentbonnie
  • 11 years ago
    Definitely darker. I like the colors Signature Design Group suggest too. Your floor and counter is light---contrast would look better than white on light. Hope this is helpful. Good Luck!
    kjosh thanked Natalie
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    this is a panda white finishing and reinstalled them...I personally wouldn't go for the cheapest...but for 4000...it depends on the size of your kitchen...it's a very easy process and only took me a few days to have it just right...I've done plenty of kitchen...different types of colors and stains...but white can be a good idea. but know that you have plenty shades of white to choose from. ...
    kjosh thanked Furniture Society
  • 11 years ago
    i recommend having the uppers not match the lowers. you could have the best of both! i would stay far away from honey oak or cherry stains. Go with greyish or a clear coat. wood is beautiful on its own, especially if you have some nice grain patterns.
    kjosh thanked Dave Conrad
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    The jazzy tiling does dictate what you do. Grey cabinets will tone them down and look more cohesive. White will make them pop even more. If you use grey choose a color as close as possible to the tile. So bringing paint chips home is an excellent idea. One more suggestion - find out if it is possible to stain the cabinets instead of painting them. If they are varnished the varnish will have to be stripped first of course.
    kjosh thanked TheFurnitureCollection
  • 11 years ago
    Hi, you have been given many opinions. I don't want to add to your decision making. :) I also think grey or white will work. I think kitchens with uppers and lowers of different colors look nice too. A grey stain may look nice also. I don't think grain showing when it's painted is bad at all. Just preference. What you have so far looks good. I don't think anything that you choose going forward will look bad at all. Good luck! Very nice kitchen. When you move, send me the kitchen, I'll take it. lol :)
    kjosh thanked zazfuzzroc
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    Black cabinets! Or top cabinets a pure gray and the lower cabinets a much darker gray. You can see an example on my page of what painted cabinets should look like when finished. That gray would work nice on the top cabinets I think.
  • 11 years ago
    Any updates or current pics on what was done?