I have read the numerous posts on how to pick the chandelier size for your kitchen island but would still like some opinions. My new home features an island that is 54 x 96, ceilings 10' and I am wanting just a single fixture above. There will also be can lights in the room.

Cabinets will be off white with white springs granite and my 3 barstools are the same bronze scrolled iron as in this light fixture. 12 light fixture is 36H x 35.5W, 6 light is 33.75H x 32.5W.

Which size works the best? Thanks for your help.