Software
Houzz Logo Print
jds912

hard water for containers

16 years ago

i am going to be starting vegetable seeds in about two weeks under lights. we have hard water. about 400 ppm of calcium. i have started from seed indoors for a few years now. not until last year did i notice something going on with my starts. i have done a process of elimination and the only thing i can come up with is the water quality. the plants will be in the containers for about 1.5 -2 months. any ideas on how to fix the hard water issue without spending a fortune?

Comments (23)

  • 16 years ago

    How about one of those simple, in-line filters - white pvc - purchased at a Hardware store?
    That should eliminate the majority of the problem, and quite cheaply, too.

    Josh

  • 16 years ago

    I'm pretty sure those filters don't remove dissolved solids - only organic molecules or suspended particles, Josh.

    You can neutralize the high alkalinity by simply adding a source of acid, like white vinegar. Consider the alkalinity neutralized when the water's pH is 5.8.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    i guess the vinegar would not harm plants? how much vinegar per gallon? our water ph range is 7.8-8.2. my wife works for a pool company and they have good water tester.The only stuff they have to change water ph is for pools, not plants. thanks.

  • 16 years ago

    I use a cap-full of vinegar per gallon.

    Thanks for the correction, Al! I haven't looked too closely into it, I admit; and I assumed that the white precipitate collected in the filter was calcium....

    Josh

  • 16 years ago

    Just keep adding by the tsp (to a gallon) until you reach a pH of 5.8 & note how much vinegar it took so you know how much to use next time.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    To completely remove the pH raising effect of alkalinity you actually need to reduce water pH to around 4.2 rather than 5.8, but if you reduce it to 5.8 the alkalinity is reduced enough it's not likely to ever be an issue for the month or two plants spend indoors as seedlings.

    You don't need fancy test equipment to do this either. If you add 1/2 ounce of vinegar (normal, white distilled) to 1 gallon of water the ph and alkalinity will not be an issue and yet you won't have a solution that can kill plants either. If you do have equipment to measure then do so, but lacking this, 1/2 ounce of vinegar per gallon of water will right nearly all wrongs.

  • 16 years ago

    sounds easy enough justaguy2, how much is half an ounce if i were using teaspoon/tablespoon to measure? is this what you would do considering you had the same water ph i do, adding the vinegar to reduce ph? thanks.

  • 16 years ago

    You guys really think ph is the culprit? What is your set-up and what do you think is going on?

  • 16 years ago

    sounds easy enough justaguy2, how much is half an ounce if i were using teaspoon/tablespoon to measure?

    It's a shot glass (1 ounce) filled half way... LOL

    Otherwise it's 3 teaspoons (1 tablespoon) per half ounce for most liquids. is this what you would do considering you had the same water ph i do, adding the vinegar to reduce ph? thanks.

    pH doesn't concern me much, alkalinity does. It's the alkalinity from hard water that can drive the pH out of whack and buffer it there. I would rather have water with a pH of 8.5 and no alkalinity than water with a pH of 7.1 with high alkalinity. Unfortunately my water is pH 7.5 with a TDS of 440 or so, most of that calcium from a limestone well.

    Yes, I counter this with vinegar (any acid will work, vinegar is weak enough to be safe to handle and common enough to be very inexpensive). Works like a charm.

  • 16 years ago

    i am under two flourescent tubes in one fixture. i have two fixtures. gro-lux bulbs and plant and aquarium bulbs. the plants looked great until about 3-4 weeks into it. then started having burnt leaf tips and the leaves started becoming spotty. i kept the bulbs within 1-2 inches of plants. i fertilized, weakly, once, between sprouting and time i started seeing problems. it was a week before i started seeing problems after i fertilized at least. temperature ranged from 65-77 degrees. i used metro mix and jungle growth. watered seedlings by soaking styrofoam cups in bucket of water. foliage never had water contact. i used to start them in south facing window. too hard now because of daughter and dog. worked there great. i am not sure what the problem was. i am just trying to eliminate all problems. plants were under lights for about 5 weeks. the tomatoes were the only ones that showed problems. they were under the gro lux bulbs, the peppers were under the plant/aquarium bulbs and started to have lower leaves die because they were getting to big for light penetration. i will be using 1 cool and one warm bulb this year per fixture. our water is very hard. leaves a white film on anything it touches. it also is inconsistent in calcium ppm. it fluctuates between 200 and 600 ppm. i have aqcuired a 400 watt metal halide with digital ballast and a huge reflector last month. bought it from a friend who used it one time. i paid $200.00 for everything. i will be using this to grow one of my tomato starts inside for a while. if this tomato plant is in the container a while under hid light, i figured water ph would have to be adjusted so it wouldnt raise my soil ph to unsatisfactory level. what do ya'll think?

  • 16 years ago

    justaguy2,
    obviously i dont do to much measuring. i should have asked the wife. she does all the cooking and measuring. i dont drink much either so i did not think of shot glass. appreciate the info. i will now fiddle with vinegar in water and have my wife test it at pool company to see what i get. i guess i should shoot for 5-6 ph? thanks.

  • 16 years ago

    i have aqcuired a 400 watt metal halide with digital ballast and a huge reflector last month. bought it from a friend who used it one time. i paid $200.00 for everything.

    Score! HID lighting opens a while word of indoor possibilities not possible with florescent lighting. i will be using this to grow one of my tomato starts inside for a while. if this tomato plant is in the container a while under hid light, i figured water ph would have to be adjusted so it wouldnt raise my soil ph to unsatisfactory level. what do ya'll think

    I think the problems you describe earlier in your post could be from pH induced problems, but before assuming that, check water levels in your containers. Over watering is far more common a problem, even among those who insist they never do it than pH related issues are. Over watering can lead to symptoms that look like under watering because over watering rots roots that limit a plant's ability to take up water.

    All commercial seed starting mixes are made up up finely ground particles that hold tons of water and support perched water tables. It's difficult to not over water in such a case. IF you were willing to spend $200 on a better light, please save some money by purchasing your own, more coarse (large particled) ingredients and make a fast draining seed starting media to rule out over watering before thinking you have a hard water/pH/alkalinity issue going on.

    No matter how much experience we have or how much technical know how we have acquired or how much money we spend on our set ups, never overlook the most common problem - over watering- as the source of all evil. When you are absolutely convinced it isn't over watering, but haven't actually checked, it's probably over watering.

  • 16 years ago

    maybe i was overwatering. the peppers got the same watering schedule and they didnt have problems. thats why i like new years. trying different things. i am still going to use the ph adjusted water on almost all the seedlings. i will use regular water on a few. can i start seed under the hid light?
    i got directions from this forum on how to improve store bought mixes with pine bark and perlite.

  • 16 years ago

    can i start seed under the hid light?

    Yes. HID light seems very intense to our eyes, but compared to outside it's weak. There is no harm (and lots of advantages) to starting seeds under HID lighting.

  • 16 years ago

    justaguy "pH doesn't concern me much, alkalinity does "
    thats what ph measures acid ity or alkalinity
    "Alkalis are best known for being bases that dissolve in water.Bases are compounds with a pH greater than 7."(Wikipedia)

  • 16 years ago

    You need a much better understanding of soil chemistry before you start correcting someone who knows what he's talking about. FWIW - I agree with what he said.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    dickiefickle, I would have said the same thing not too long ago. My guess is that very few people, unless they've read about it in detail or come from a scientific background, understand that alkalinity and pH are not the same thing. I didn't know it for many years and thought I knew at least something about pH. It may not be the best thing to do, but I'm sure I've stated something as fact because of my ignorance only to find out I was completely wrong! Again, not saying it's the best to do on a forum like this, but being human is part of this experience.

    Here are some references regarding the difference that may or may not be easy to understand based on a person's prior knowledge:

    http://safewater.custhelp.com/cgi-bin/safewater.cfg/php/enduser/std_adp.php?p_faqid=1471&p_created=1099199025

    http://corporateportal.ppg.com/NA/CalHypo/AskJoePool/Questions/090_difference.htm

    http://www.umass.edu/umext/floriculture/fact_sheets/greenhouse_management/waterph.html

  • 16 years ago

    Forgive me for not being as gentle in my reply, but DF has a long history of terse replies and snappish corrections - usually one-liners.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    got another, maybe debated question. i will be starting my seeds in parks bio dome with their brand of soil inserts. works the best on a heatmat compared to other styles of tried, i.e. peat pellets, jiffy mix. once the seedlings start to develop their first true leaves, i plant into 12 oz. styrofoam cup swith metro mix. this tear i will be using pro-mix. i will doctor the mix up a little with some of al's components. so here is my question, should i add a little compost to the pro mix to start getting the seedling used to soil? are the roots grown in soiless mix different than roots grown in soil mix? never had a problem transitioning from cup to garden as long as i harden off well. will it help with transplant shock if i add a little soil to mix? thanks?

  • 16 years ago

    Adding actual soil to the seedlings growing medium will not help the roots transition at all. In fact the soil/compost will make the media hold more water, likely too much water, and this will result in less well developed roots.

  • 16 years ago

    Al, I completely understand prior history with people here influencing how we post...my thought was to give a benefit of the doubt (since I don't have any history with df), and to help any other readers who might not be directly participating.

  • 16 years ago

    Wouldn't compost also bring with it the possibility of pathogens that could harm the tiny, fragile seedlings?

  • 16 years ago

    Compost is problematic in many ways for seedlings and cuttings.

    Al