Software
Houzz Logo Print
patrick212_gw

Nature Friendly Fertilizer

19 years ago

I planted a rather large container garden on my rooftop deck last year that performed very well. The deck gets full sun and the plants typically get watered twice a day (I live in Chicago). Last year I used the liquid Miracle Grow fertilizer for the plants and everything did extremely well. However, I would like to use a more nature friendly fertilizer this year. I have no experience with fish emulsion etc. type of liquid fertilizers. Do any of you have any recomendations on specific types and application rates for a heavily watered container garden.

Thanks for your help, Pat

Comments (2)

  • 19 years ago

    I don't know that there really is a 'nature friendly' fertilizer. I think it is more of a nature friendly fertilizing practice. In most cases a water soluble fertilizer will wash out of the container with the waterings. Some makes it to the plant, but a lot runs out.

    If you wish to be nature friendly you will have to account for that fertilizer that drains out. If it just falls onto your lawn, no biggie, but if it runs over cement into a storm drain that goes to the local water body...

    Beyond the environmental issues associated with fertilizer run off I think Miracle Grow is just fine. Miracle Grow kind of represents the 'big corporate evil conspiracy' fertilizer, I think because it is everywhere and works really well. I don't prefer to use it, but I have used it and like you, found it to work quite well.

    I do prefer organic/natural fertilizers, but that's just a quirk of mine I don't think it really makes any difference to the plants, particularly in containers.

    Fish emulsion is quite good as it is a complete fertilizer containing every plant nutrient. I use the Neptune's Harvest brand, but most places it would have to be mail ordered. I have also used store bought brands and as best I can tell they all work more or less the same (although they are not all made the same way).

    Application rates for fertilizer are kind of a personal preference thing. As long as you don't exceed the instruction rates on the package you should be fine, but many prefer to dilute the amount and use it more often rather than using full strength every week or two.

    Others prefer to add a slow release type fertilizer at planting time to ensure a more consistent supply of nutrients in between the fertilizing with the waterings. I use a product called Espoma Garden Tone which is a mostly organic, dry fertilizer that also contains some synthetic and faster acting sources of nutrients.

    I don't think my choices for fertilizers are particularly important though, it's just what I like to use at this point in time. I also don't think the schedule (weak amount every watering or high amount less often) make a huge difference in most cases. You just kind of play around and observe things and form your own preferences over time.

  • 19 years ago

    I agree with all the above as a general rule and I do think that many people are led to believe they need a different fert for every type of plant they grow or otherwise your various plants won't grow to their potential. While there is some truth to this by each plant taking up differing amounts of given nutrients is proven science and average will do for many plants just fine. But many plants do just fine for most people with just a few things kept in mind. You don't eat steak everyday and neither would you plant choose to if given a chance. This meaning that IMHO that supplying a range of nutrients in different forms will be helpful in maintaining nurtitional balance.
    Using an osmocote style slow release will guarantee overall macro-nutrient needs day in day out and will not leach excessively because of this slower release. I like to add alfalfa pellets to by container mixes for a diversity of reasons mostly to add micronutient and secondary nutrients as a slow release. I also add greensand for the same reason. I like rock phosphate for the same reason too. I supply seaweed liquid at transplanting to help ease the transition and encourage rooting. I will foliar feed with seaweed as the season progresses every 2 to 4 weeks as time or need permits. If I am growing longer than 3 months in a container I add additional alfalfa pellets to the surface and more osmocote. I will on tomato plants and other heavier feeders(I container these because of deer:( use some soluable fert such as peters or miracle gro a few times mid and late in the season.
    So in conclusion I use quite a few types of ferts but use almost all of them on every plant I grow. Most are dry and store well and are economical if using bigger bags. Most are organic and slow release by there nature. The others like osmocote are chemical but slow release as well. The only quick release is the rare feeding with the soluables. The seaweed is quick acting as well but by foliar feeding I waste very little and it keeps cost down. I get a good range of growth, not too fast to encourage aphids and other bugs and can kick up the pace if needed on any individual plant's needs through the year(s).
    Experiment and research options and work toward your own fert regime that fits you and your plants lifestyle and growing conditions. Some like apples some like pears. Some like pork others beef, what do you like?
    Happiest of Growing David