Software
Houzz Logo Print
jefe12234

Ca/Mg supplementation in gritty mix

17 years ago

I currently use a 1:1:1 mix of uncomposted pine bark, Turface, and calcined DE. I may swap the Turface for granite grit if I can find some locally. All I've found so far is cherry stone which works, but has a gaudy purple color. I use FP 9-3-6 in RO water, but have read that I should still add an additional Ca/Mg source because some is bound by the soil itself? I have a few questions about this.

1) Is this sequestration a one-time occurrence, or does the soil continually bind additional Ca/Mg?

2) Will powdered gypsum be washed/leached out of the soil over time? And if so, will this lead to a Ca/Mg imbalance if Mg is added consistently via epsom salt at every watering?

3) Would something like a liquid Cal-Mag fertilizer added to the FP + water have any advantages over gypsum and epsom salt?

Comments (11)

  • 17 years ago

    Acidic peat or pine bark based soils are usually deficient in Ca, Mg, and S. When we add Ca/Mg, we replace the hydrogen atoms at exchange sites with Ca or Mg. These atoms will be tightly held until pH rises to around 5.5. The Ca you add to acid soils can be divided into 2 fractions. The first fraction is involved in the reactive phase. During this phase, the atoms are replacing H atoms and are largely unavailable for uptake. Once the equilibrium pH is reached, the second, residual fraction becomes more available for uptake. With application of acidic fertilizer solutions or irrigation water, the process can be reversed and you may need to supplement the residual fraction. That's where your FP fertilizer comes in - it will continually replace the residual fraction of Ca/Mg. If you used it in a soil with low pH, it would need to satisfy the reactive phase before it could offer residual nutrition.

    Gypsum is only moderately soluble in soils and increases in solubility as pH drops, so it is possible that you would have to top-dress with gypsum at some point. I have never run into a problem because it's extremely rare for me to keep a plant in the same soil for longer than 3 years. 1-2 years is the norm, except for a very few slow growers.

    The advantage of the Cal/Mag is that it comes pre-mixed in a 2.67:1, Ca:Mg ratio, which takes the guesswork out of things. Remember though that once the media pH is above 5.5, the Ca/Mg in your FP will be available.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    Al, thank you so much. That helps a lot. I think I may pick up some Cal-Mag 2-0-0 and match my FP dose (1/8-1/4 tsp of each per gallon). I also dose Pro-Tekt 0-0-3, so altogether that makes 11-3-9 with increased Ca and Mg (still trying to find a site that lists the percentages of Ca/Mg in Cal-Mag). I think those will be good numbers and they will remain constant at every watering.

  • 17 years ago

    Ok, I just found the percentages for Cal-Mag (3.2% Ca, 1.2% Mg). That would put me at 11-3-9-5.2(Ca)-1.7(Mg). That sounds like a lot of Ca/Mg, but you think the FP will still benefit from this addition after the soil chemistry has its way?

  • 17 years ago

    You don't have to apply it at the recommended dosage, you know? ;o)

    Aside from pH issues, there is really no such thing as a Ca or Mg toxicity; so as long as you're cautious You can't go too far wrong. Your biggest concern would be possible antagonistic deficiencies of some micronutrients if Ca/Mg levels get too high. Remember that their addition does increas EC and TDS of the soil solution, so it's best to keep them at or slightly above adequacy levels.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    After looking more I found that FP is quite low in sulfur which you mentioned can be deficient in pine bark soils. Maybe this is a good reason to go with the gypsum + epsom salt for Ca/Mg supplementation. Either way it's good to have a better understanding of these things. Thanks again, Al.

  • 17 years ago

    I don't know if I ever mentioned ...
    Conifer bark as it relates to N delivery is generally:
    High in P and has sufficient K
    Deficient in Ca, Mg, and S
    Sufficient in micro-nutrients, except for B and Zn
    Potentially high Fe:Mn ratio

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    Acidic peat or pine bark based soils are usually deficient in Ca, Mg, and S. When we add Ca/Mg, we replace the hydrogen atoms at exchange sites with Ca or Mg.

    Despite the way we started n another topic, this guy with a hort degree and extensive experience across multiple fields finds almost all of what Al says solid as a rock and backed by the literature.

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you, Dan.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    Al,

    How much gypsum do I add to one gallon worth of gritty soil mix and what frequently/amount of Epsom salt is added to the irrigation water?

    I know you've covered this before but I couldn't find it in the thread.

    Thanks!

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    I have read that he adds 1 TBSP gypsum per gallon of gritty mix and 1/8-1/4 tsp of epsom salts when he fertilizes.

  • 17 years ago

    That's correct.

    Al