Software
Houzz Logo Print
prairie_love

How do I learn to *see*?

20 years ago

Partially in response to laag's lament, and at risk of this not fulfilling an interest for all of you out there, I will ask this question that I have been puzzling with for awhile.

How do I learn to "see"? In the books I read about landscaping, there are discussions and references to "focal points". There are pictures of gardens that are supposed to illustrate the idea of focal points. In some cases the picture is presented as if it is supposed to be very clear to me what the focal point is or why it is not a good one. But, often I do not see why "this" or "that" is considered the focal point. When I look at the picture, my eyes do not necessarily jump to that object, be it plant or structure or whatever. In fact, sometimes my eyes jump to something completely different. Or else they wander.

So then I go out to my yard or look through a window and ask myself "currently, what is the focal point in this view?" The idea, of course, is that if the focal point is undesirable, I should try to find a way to alter it. An example would be the view out and over my sloping back yard. There is a field, and trees at the back of the field, and across the river there are two radio towers. Sometimes all I see are the radio towers. But then I wonder if that's because I know they are there, not because one's eyes would automatically be drawn to them. Most of the time I don't notice the towers, but is this simply because I am used to them?

Similarly, I can look at pictures and say "I like this garden" or "I don't like this", but then I have difficulty visualizing a bed that I am planning. Will Plant A and Plant B really look nice together or will they be too far apart in size or some other not so great function.

So, my long-winded question is this - how do I learn to "see" when I look? Is this a natural ability that some, probably more artistic, people have, similar to innate musical talent? Or is there a way to train my eye and also to train my imagination?

Ann, who still reads here but also has found little of interest recently

Comments (29)

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sketch

    No one draws worse than me, but drawing does more for your ability to see than just about anything else. Don't doodle, but look at whatever the subject matter that you want to "learn to see". It is not the drawing, it is the degree of complexity in which you have to take it in that does this. Try to draw it exactly how it is. You'll have to look at texture to reproduce it. Shadows, light, and shade. Glossy vs. dull. Structure. Form. How to make neighboring items have the same look on paper as they do when you look at them.

    That all forces you to understand it, no matter how bad your drawings are - which they won't be, if you are persistant.

    After a while you start to recognize a wide array of those things that are sometimes used as artsy buzz words. You will find them to be real. You will recognize them. That is what empowers you. It gives you the ability to look at something and break down these qualities. That in turn let's you understand how they are interacting in a given subject matter (Japanese Garden, as example). When you understand it, it gives you the opportunity to recreate it.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Funny, I was going to mirror laag's response. Drawing is the process of recording careful observation. It is a learned skill that forces the participant to really 'see'.

    Sometimes in gardening, we get so involved with the details that we can't see the larger picture. Albrecht Durer developed what he called a drawing machine that helped him visually understand and organize what he was seeing and to enable him to record it accurately. In many drawing classes, a simplified version, called a view finder is used for the same purpose. These are simple tools force the participant to carefully observe what they are really seeing.

    There's no simple answer to your question and you are brave to ask it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Drawing with a viewfinder

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well ... not to confuse you even more ... but I would try to "feel" the landscape and give your eyes a rest LOL. The eyes are only one part of the body and by no means the only and not even a reliable means to experience a landscape.

    The brain is also a culprit here .... I suspect it is working overtime.

    Try this ...

    Lock up every book you have on landscape design ... for several weeks go and sit in a landscape that is meaningful to you .. ask no one about how to do landscape design during this time ... sit for several weeks or more .. use a blidfold if you must ... don't use the eyes .. try to feel the humm of what's around you and your own humm... let it all blend into one great humm.

    Then the locked up books will serve you and not you who will serve them ... be free .. be alive.

    Good Day ....

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I was going to suggest sketching as well. I also find looking at black and white photographs helpful--it forces one to look at shapes, textures, and scale--without all that distracting COLOR.

    melanie

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sketching is a great suggestion. If drawing is something you need/want to learn, I highly recommend one of the Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain books by Betty Edwards. I went through the original book 15 years ago and remember the basic premise being, if you can write your name you can drawwhatÂs standing in the way is what you "think" you see and whatÂs really there. And itÂs true, drawing something really makes you know it in a way simply looking at it never will.

    As for seeing, this book is about architecture specifically, but the guiding principles are still applicableÂ.The Old Way of Seeing by Jonathan Hale. I recall the premise of this book being that current design ignores the basic elements of proportion and balance, pattern and play.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    When I took a drawing class in college, the first project was to draw a white sheet that was draped over a peg in sunlight. The goal was to learn to "see" the light and shadow and thus draw the object. The next project was to draw an overturned stool by drawing the "negative space" (to draw the voids that the stool created, as opposed to drawing the seat, legs and so forth), we continued to draw still life as a whole or in small portions. Once you learn to see the light and shadow, positive and negative space, we added texture then later on color. We were urged to go and observe simple natural things. The structure of a leaf close up, the reflection of trees in a still lake, a dogwood twig with flowers. You learn to discern/discover what you are looking at, verses what you "know" you are looking at. As you learn to observe the differences in color, texture, shade and shadow, you learn to "see".

    When you find a landscape that appeals to you, stop and ask yourself questions. What is it that appeals to me, the symmetry, textures, colors, balance between objects, a path that disappears and pulls you into the garden, how are the plants grouped? Think overall and then consider the details.

    A focal point is an object that draws you attention and is star of the show. You speak about your yard and the images beyond you yard (field, trees, river), that would be the "view from the window". But is there nothing IN your yard that gains your attention? A pond, gazebo, trellis, bird bath, bench? A landscape need not have just one focal point, but several to pull you and move you around the landscape. A focal point can create a destination. They human mind is curious and continues to strive to fill in the unknowns (what is around the corner and once at the corner, what is here? A new focal point to move you to the next destination)

    There is a difficulty in determining what plants will look good together. I think it is often a matter of experience and trial/error. That I will gladly hand off to the LDs to explain.

    What I am trying to figure out is how to determine the conceptual selection/composition of plants for a new garden bed. How do you determine the size, shape, texture & placement of plants and their relationship to each other? Example: If you have a 50 undulating bed ranging in depth between 4-15, how you determine where to plant tall items (tree/shrub) verse flowering beds?

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "If you have a 50 undulating bed ranging in depth between 4-15, how you determine where to plant tall items (tree/shrub) verse flowering beds? "

    I just finished lunch .. my stomach is calling for some attention to digest ... the stomach likes to rule the head sometimes and why not the head always pushes the stomach around ... our heads are too big.

    There are ... ofcourse ... biological or ecological aspects involved in this situation .. like : Will tall plants cast a shadow and how will this determine lets say flower or plant selection below ? What is the mature size of a plant ? It makes little sense to plant small shrubs behind massive shrubs ??? These aspects along with perspective as mentioned above by others .. although important .. are mechanical aspects of design ... they could be grouped into the same skill catergory as sharpening ones pencil. It must be done but should not take all your creative energy.

    I often would listen to music when sitting at a drafting table ... but sitting in the yard is my favorite technique .. when designing my on home I sat for several nights in the yard .. it was cold and windy .. the yard was all dirt ... a blank slate .. my mind was not blank ... my father came to mind .. he is getting older .. he will be gone someday .. ... in my wife's womb was my first child ... my child's father as well would some day be gone ... the baby would be alone ... I broke into tears ... the tears dried in the cold wind ... all sadness left me ... I and the wind became one .. it was not cold anymore .. it just was.

    Create what is yours .. NOT what is in your neighbors yard or a magazine or what some nut tells you looks good ... to create what is yours you must be alive ... really alive. To be alive you must here your own hum ...

    Work on that ... that's the hard part. That is what's stopping you from getting what you want in the landscape.

    Good Day ...

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Another way is to take photos of many aspects of your own property. You really do "see" them differently in a photo and see new perspectives. You can see some things jump out and others not, and not always what you thought.

    I swear I'm not getting a royalty from Hayward's "Intimate Garden", but I did seem to learn more from the combination of his photos and his discussions of focal points than from some others. It also helped me think more about why (and whether) to have focal points and not just, let's go buy some gewgaws and make focal points. For example, I have a couple of areas where a path takes a turn, or some steps lead to a sitting area. So I am trying now to "see" how an object or plant form or contrast in color could say, here's the turn or entry point, and then what area/how far beyond that might I want something else catch the eye and lead one forward to the next logical place. I'm also having fun using temporary, moveable focal points--a large potted plant or something--just to experiment with whether "focalizing" is a good thing there, and if so, then I can think more about what actual object or artifice would do the best job.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think that "seeing" is not the best term. Although we are using our eyes, the excercise is much more like listening. Listening to what you are seeing, if you will. The reason that I say this is that listening is an intake which has a complement that is speaking. The whole process is about language (both seeing and my metaphor of listening). "Seeing" does not have such a clear complement.

    In order to speak the language you must know the words. You must also listen to how they are used. You will hear lots of dialects, accents, voices, and manners of speaking. Some will sound beautiful to you, others will sound harsh. Most will fall within a range between beauty and harshness. Some words can have different meanings.

    Landscape design is no different. Looking at a landscape you like is like listening to a beautiful voice expressing lovely thoughts in a song. You are hearing it, yet that does not instantly empower you to sing the same way.

    How would you go about trying to duplicate such a singer? Well you would have to learn about music with all of its bits and pieces and also the limitations of your own voice. Or, you could just try winging it. Some wing it very well, most are alright, and then there are those (can you say "American Idol?) that think they are doing well, but are not. The truth is that the deeper these people go with training, critique, and practice, the more they improve. Not everyone is going to be a star, but certainly they will improve.

    The concept of "seeing" is listening with your eyes. The more you listen, the more you understand. The more you break up what you are listening to, the more you understand. If you listen to a piece of music it may be one compiled sound. But, if you listen closely, you here a particular instrument and enter its little world and follow what it is doing. You can do that for each instrument that you hear in the piece. Once you are familiar with those, you start to hear how they play off of each other. You hear things that you like more than others. It keeps growing in complication the more you study it.

    To compose music is not the same as listening to it. Yet anyone can do it. It depends how simplistic the music is to be. You can make music of your own by tapping a pencil to a glass. Mozart might not be impressed, but it is composition. But, clearly the more you understand about the elements of music, the more you understand and can work with.

    Breaking down a landscape into its most basic pieces is the key to being able to understand what it is doing visually. Some people say that they feel what is right on a higher artistic plane. I think that the "gifted artist" thing is a shakey concept. That would preclude people who are not so gifted from developing ability. I don't buy it unless the gift is a higher ability to understand and reason - the "feel" thing is BS as far as I am concerned.

    I honestly believe that design is a process of reasoning. Reasoning is applying what you understand. The more you understand, the more you can apply.

    Observe and dwell on the simplist element and understand what it is doing. Then do the same for another, then another. Then, and only then, try to understand how they are working with each other. Look to see if they work the same way in other circumstances, or not. You'll find that it is much like DNA, a few simple things will have entirely different results with only the slightest change in composition. Lists that say "when x is with y then z happens" will soon be in the trash can and a whole new world opens up.

    You can't command until you understand (Johnny Cochoran?).

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yeah ... he also said "if the glove don't fit you must equit. " ...

    I think it is Elton John that can't read music ... but he plays .. does he not ?

    Splendid job Laag ... for the most part .. but I do not believe that all of human experience is available via reasoning ... certainly if you go out to the country away from city lights on a clear night the splendor of the starscape above is enough to awe a young child as well as an astrophysicist ... neither child nor scientist can claim to know or be able to reason all that they see ... both are more then capable of feeling the awe in what lies before them in the night sky.

    On a hot dry day I can drink a cold lemonade in the garden .. I do not have to know the action of every atom in the cold drink and my body and in my garden to know the experience.

    Certainly you can eat at a resturaunt and enjoy the meal and not know the cooks secret recipe ??

    A logical understanding and the connections amongst what we are working with is only a means to the end ... if reason says the jet plane will fly but it indeed crashes in a ball of fire even a young child can say it did not fly right... no engineer required.

    Logic is just a way to get their .. but we know we have arrived when it "feels right" ... a machine can process logic or reaon x goes with y ect as you say .. don't get lost in the logic .. otherwise your just a mechanical machine .. spitting out lots of perspectives and designs ect and not knowing why none of it makes you content ... you process but don't feel.

    When you experience a landscape that touches you it is what is in you as much or more then what is outside of you that makes the experience. Do not give all the credit to the designer ... this is nonsense... sold by those that need to justify their pay check.

    You create the landscape. You are the vital part of any landscape design. It's all about you ... indeed you.

    Feel what is inside of you ... let it be your designer and build what is to be around you ... then your designs will feel right for you and they should feel right for you not the guy next door or the designer at the local university.

    Create your world from "your" thoughts ... and you will be amazed to find all will fall into it's place.

    Good Day ....

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Wow. Thank you.

    I'm not sure where to start, so I'll start at the top. The suggestions to sketch are wonderful - and I should have known. I am an amateur birder, and we are always told to sketch our birds, for similar reasons - that is how we will really *see* the bird. So, it makes sense, sketch the landscape to see it.

    So, we got the first, and most simple, answer in sketching. Then you went into the deeper answers. And laag, as well as Mohave Kid, is right, that it really is more than "seeing". I think that's why I had it in quotes to start with, I knew that it wasn't right but couldn't put into words what I was trying to ask.

    Mohave Kid tells me to go sit in a landscape that is meaningful to me. Well, the most readily accessible one that does that is also in my back yard. It is beyond the grass and it is a more-or-less native woods. There is no "landscaping". But it is the most beautiful and meaningful place I know.

    To compose music is not the same as listening to it. This may be the best metaphor for landscape design that I've seen on this forum. This "speaks" to me very strongly and makes me wonder how I could possibly think I can do any landscaping myself. But then, Feel what is inside of you ... let it be your designer and build what is to be around you I regain a little confidence.

    It's interesting because you (laag and Mohave) are saying similar but not identical things, yet between you are making me feel more confident. I think you are helping me hear what I already knew - that I need to take my cues from the woods around me that I love, that I need to listen with my eyes, and that I need to observe and think and learn and understand each element that is already there and determine why I like or do not like it.

    Laag, did you know that I am a molecular biologist? I think I mentioned it once, if you remembered I'm impressed, if not, great analogy with the DNA anyway.

    Bettertobe - you asked about other focal points in my back yard. We live in the country and have a broad expanse of lawn sloping down to the woods, with a cultivated field on one side. The major views are the field (which actually is quite beautiful in growing season) and the natural entrance to the woods. Oh, and a split rail fence between the lawn and field that we put in for that very purpose. Bottom line, at the moment it is so wide open that there are not other focal points. That's not to say there won't be in the future. On the other hand, we do like to be able to look into the distance.

    Thank you for your thoughts. I will find a sketch pad and pencils and go sit in my woods or, more likely this weekend since its very cold and snowy, look out my window, and draw what I see and hear with my eyes.

    Ann

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Surprisingly I have a different point of view. While I think sketching is an excellent way to study detail this question is more to do with the 'broad strokes'and concentrating on detail may not be the best approach, dare I say it might even be the wrong approach. If you take yourself to a garden that demonstrates a strong focal point open up your set of finger paints and make a 'blob study' by what makes it work. Gardens with one very strong focal point will be symmetrically arranged around an axis, your blobs will clearly show this. For a classic example of how this works look at "The Last Supper" by Leonardo . For another example at the opposite end of the artistic spectrum look at the archetypal foundation planting with the tall junipers at the corners sloping down through trimmed yew to the front door with an arrow straight path leading to it. Most likely the 'blobs' will already be in place for this example. Most of what is known as landscape modeling uses this blob technique.
    Modern, or organic gardens, cannot rely on focal points in this way because they are designed to be looked at from various viewpoints. In fact I don't think they carry so much weight in a garden that you are meant to be part of rather than a viewer of. What will provide movement here, and now we are talking about physical movement,is more likely to be a series of events. A series of 3D blobs in space. A drawing board is not the only place to design a garden and with the aid of a few tall pot plants from the house a dustbin and a TV box you can do you 'blob study' in situ. If you can first see the form then you can look at more subtle ways of attracting attention with colour and texture etc.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have to agree with the big picture approach as the place to start. Going back to the music analogy, you start by listening to the beat and work toward the tiny details. Don't substitute tiny details for simple details. Bigger things are the simplist.

    I learned the way that Ink is talking about. We had to start by using several shapes - the big picture. They were 2 or three rectangles, a couple of squares, circles, and triangles (form). We had to make a pleasing composition by placing these shapes along a line to make something like a skyline. Later, we built in texture by using angled hatching - the closer the lines the finer the texture (texture). We used the same composition and added the texture lines to each shape to again make it a pleasing composition. Later, we added color (light green, yellow gree, etc.). Everything done earlier could not be altered. Eventually we had to find plants that matched the criteria for each shape and draw our composition as a border planting. Abstract toward detail, just like Ink is saying. This excercise was in the "speaking phase", while sketching these abstracts was done in the "listening phase" first.

    Inks post jarred some memories.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This is a splendid thread. I enjoyed it very much.

    Janie

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ah, good thing I didn't draw the detailed picture this weekend as I now find I am to draw blobs .

    Not to be difficult but, I still have difficulties. Let's take "The Last Supper". OK, glance at it and you see a bunch of men (we assume 12) seated with Jesus for the last supper. But look at it more carefully, and now you see that one of the men may in fact be a woman (sorry, I just read The DaVinci Code) and that one is making a sign of slashing the throat across her neck, and that there are actually wine glasses for everyone not a single goblet for all to share, etc. So the problem now is that every time I look at the painting, I will see these details. Now I know they are there so I will see them.

    I will relate that back to my yard. I am certain the first time I looked out the back I didn't notice the radio towers. But now I know they are there so I notice them (side note, I am not horribly bothered by them I am just using this as an example). So, if I draw now, I will draw the towers. If I had drawn three years ago, I might have missed them. Maybe I used "focal point" incorrectly. What I really mean to ask, in this case, is how do I determine whether the towers are really a distraction that I should actively try to divert attention away from, or whether I only notice them because I know they are there?

    Next I am told to look at the archetypal foundation planting with the tall junipers at the corners sloping down through trimmed yew to the front door with an arrow straight path leading to it.. I can imagine exactly the scene. however, this scene only exists from one exact viewpoint. If you are a few steps down the sidewalk, the arrow straight path is now at an angle, the front door may not be visible, and perhaps another "undesirable" object is in sight.

    So, Ink addressed this by saying that in many modern landscaoes we are meant to be a part of it rather than a viewer and there are many views. So, perhaps I should not even think of focal points? Or not so heavily as some books may stress? If we return again to my back yard (the view I know the best) I can say that I look south-east and see the cultivated field, if I raise my eyes I see those radio towers. But, if I turn my eyes a bit north, I see an enticing entrance to the woods. Perhaps I just accept that it might take a visitor's eyes a few moments to settle on the most enjoyable view?

    Listening and speaking. Who would have known that I had to apply these to thinking about what to do with my yard? And yet, it makes sense to me.

    Ann

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hmm, in the few minutes since I posted last I believe I have had a revelation. I think the analogies to art and music are very helpful.

    Let's take music. I can listen to classical music (say Beethoven's Seventh just for fun) as background music and enjoy it as beautiful, relaxing, enjoyable music. I can sit in careful silence and listen to the same piece and really *listen* and I can hear the clarinets "here" and the oboes "there" and, although I am certainly no pro, I can appreciate the way the conductors brings in the violins "just so". I can hear, really *hear* both as a big picture and as small details.

    Now for art, I'm not so good at art, but I can look at a painting and appreciate it. If someone helps me out, I can see the details and appreciate those. I can understand that this artist is using a novel technique or medium and that makes his or her art special. Here I can see the big picture (no pun intended), but have difficulty with the details.

    In the landscape, it's the opposite. I can see the details but have difficulty with the big picture. I can look at that combination of Dame's rocket and orange poppies and say "that is spectacular", but fail to notice the rest of the garden. I can appreciate an individual iris bloom even if the rest of the yard is in disarray. So, I guess my real issue is this, how do I see the big picture of my landscape? And I think the "blob" technique you all are talking about may be the first approach. I need to learn to blur my eyes a bit and see the blobs rather than the individuals that make up the blobs.

    Ann

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ann,

    You are on your way. All of the excercises are to get you to explore what you are looking at. We all have our own habits of how we look at things. These excercises force you to look at things differently. After a while of looking at the "big picture" you get more and more revelations. Drawing the blobs is and excercise that forces you to take the time to emerse yourself in the subject long enough to reproduce it on paper. Drawing it on paper burns it deeper into your memory. The same holds true to drawing textures, or forms, or color, ...

    You and the rest of us have looked at pictures and pictures and pictures. You say that you can not "see". That should tell you that you are not getting far by just looking at pictures. Try some more of these sketching excercises and look at some of those pictures again and perhaps you will "see" more in them.

    We all do feel what we like and dislike, I do not question that. What I also believe is that it takes understanding and reasoning to create something to recreate those feelings.

    No one likes a good funk tune as much as I do. I feel that music. Trust me, you don't want me near a musical instrument trying to play that funky music. My 9 year old daughter is studying music far deeper than I ever did. The other day while the stereo was on, she was in the kitchen doing something that looks like she is flashing me gang signs or something. I asked her what she was doing. She told me she was figuring out how many beats per measure the music had.

    When I hear music, I feel it. If I analyze it, it is only the superficial that I know of it. I'm like a person who might have a glaring landscape design problem that has to do with the "big picture", yet can only understand how two plants relate to each other.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I learned to see , in no wa other than plant photography. Mainly concentrating on flowers. You learn all about the Focal point, how to make things capture the eye,even if they are not centered. How singles, and massess work. In fact I learned more about design in my Hort photography courses than just about anywhere else. Oh that may be a stretch, perhaps it would be more accurate to say, that I learned "how to see".

    Perhaps, there may even be a community class on photography in your area that you may be able to take.

    Of course if this doesnt sound interesting, perhaps taking about any graphical imaging course that a commmunity cneter offersmay help you see the focal point. After all it is learning to understand what looks good. And there is a pattern, you see it every day, in just about everything.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It is possible that 'perimeter' gardens as a style gained popularity when it became evident that smaller gardens, that were not meant only as a 'picture', needed more than a focal point to provide movement. It is interesting that the 'Beaux arts' style was still being taught in Universities until Rose, Kiley, Eckbo came along to change it. Tommy Church designed gardens that did not rely on symmetry. If you are taught, as I was, that a garden "should be open in the middle because this is where you will be" (Eckbo said this) it is one of those rules that is so easily misinterpreted. In fact, what it leads to, if followed blindly, is a lawn with a necklace of flower beds.
    Getting back to the question: I think the Da vinci code is a good example of what happens if you concentrate too much on the details, you see things that aren't there.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We started with the "blob" method in my LD classes. A line drawing of the house, in the case of a front planting, with squares and rectangles of different sizes representing the "masses" of plants or hardscape. The sizes and shapes of the blobs suggested visual weight, vertical or horizontal lines, etc. Weight is further adjusted later by using textures. A boxwood (fine texture, dense-looking) looks "heavier" than a large-leaved Rhododendron of similar size (coarse texture, more open).

    Once you've determined that you want a dense plant of a certain size and shape, you then select a plant that fits the bill, as laag stated above.

    The same method can be used in a flower border. I'm tweaking my perennial borders by observing them at different times of the year and making notes: need something spiky here, more winter interest there, something for early season color there. Trial and error, though you won't be able to do this for client!

    I've also taken digital photos and changed them to black and white with Photoshop to eliminate the distraction of color. This is where you'll be able to see form, texture, and value.

    As far as your radio towers, if they don't bother you, don't worry about them. Maybe someone who's never been to your property before can give you some feedback on how noticeable they are? I walk by the little piles of empty pots and upended half-barrel pond in my yard, and don't notice them anymore, tho I'm sure they look like heck.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We all have eyes ... a brain. Do we all see the same sunrise ? Even when we are all standing in the same place at the same time ? We do not all live in the same world.

    We all can drink wine if we so choose ... and can experience it for ourselves the first time ... but we take a wine tasting class and taste the wine a second time and now we start sounding like a magazine on fine wine. Right ?? So .. this makes us content and we conclude we have accomplished something great. Have we really ? ... or have we been sold on someone elses idea of wine ? Perhaps .. we should taste the wine a third time after uneducating ourselves ?

    I could invite many gardeners over to my garden ... they would all have their ideas on the good .. bad ..and ugly ... few of them would agree ... more so if I served wine LOL .. if I took all their ideas to bed with me I would wake up a mad man with a hangover and tear the place up the and be completely lost.

    I would be off my center.

    Nothing could be right for me .. you see.

    If you invite people to your house each week and ask for their "ideas" you may find yourself changing your landscape each week ... that could get very expensive ! LOL

    You need to be on your center first.

    Make friends with the tower you see from the backyard or declare war on it or ignore it. Which to choose ? I don't know ... I am not you !! Reason can help you plan your friendship .. your attack or help you ignore but ... still ... which to choose ? That comes from your center.

    One can not reason an entire landscape all at once .. and get anything from it but a headache .. we are not super computers .. just like one does not reason the look of their new born child.

    In other words .. GIVE BIRTH !!! If the landscape is your true child it will be right for you ... after all who does not love their own child ??

    Good Day ...

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It comes from your center based on what you know. What does anyone want when posing any question on this forum? Do they seek creativity? No. They seek a better understanding in order to apply it using their creativity.

    Is understanding anything but reason. I sure don't think so.

    Can you teach creativity? If not, then it follows that you can not learn creativity. The only thing we have left to teach or learn is reason.

    Any creative endeavor is limited by what you know. Garbage in = garbage out. Expanding your understanding of all of these design elements has nothing to do with following someone else's style or way of doing things.

    This thread is the farthest thing from following anyone. It does speak of different ways people have learned to become more deeply aware of design elements, but it does nothing to dictate what you do with that understanding. It is totally left to you to follow your own likes and dislikes or interpret them. It is about the only thread you will find that does not tell you someones idea on what you should do with that information - a rare thing indeed.

    The tower? I would be happier to understand more about the landscape and all of its elements so that I could combine them with the other powerful set of understanding that is seldom spoken of here - psychology. A deeper knowledge of the two might just allow you to have other choices besides accepting the tower or ignoring the tower. You could have the tower in plain view and make it insignificant when you know what tools you have and how to use them.

    That is reasoning.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    For me, it's not so much how to see what's there. I can do that. I have trouble seeing what's NOT there. Of all the millions of things I could do to create a pleasing landscape in my space, I can't seem to imagine more than a few bits and pieces here and there. Should I put a wall here? Or a raised bed? And how to create a united garden that flows as a functional unit rather than a conglomeration of pretty scenes? I agree with the concept expressed earlier. That you need to train your perception. In my case (and I think that Ann has expressed this as well) there are few designed landscapes in my area. So there's little for me to look at to make my brain SEE how these things look in a real situation. That's why I like the exercises and before/after case studies that we have here. Because it helps train my brain how to get from "here" to "there".

    Hey Ann, I'm a molecular biologist too! Well, I was before I quit to raise kids. Interesting how many science types are into plants.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Laag ...

    If you jump from a high place with a bungi cord attached or free fall with a parachute on your back ... Is it reason that makes your stomach get queezy ? Can you reason all will be well and stop the stomach from sending you .. the message that something is not right.

    Not all of human experience is through the brain. In fact if I whack your finger with a hammer .. you pull your hand away before the brain gets a chance to reason you should move your hand. Likewise .. I would suggest ... one can wander into a landscape and say "WOW" long before one knows why the landscape made them say "WOW"..

    Logic and reason are not king.

    "Can you teach creativity?"

    Sure you can .. as much as one can teach golf .. tennis .. no one is guaranteed to become Tiger Woods if they take golf lessons but in part it still can be taught... and one can gain more insight into golf.

    Should one play golf for a living ? ....

    ... here we are talking about "self discovery" .. the clarity and ability to "see" or feel what is right for oneself. One can buy an inexpensive book at the local art store and practice one point perspective and use it rather quickly in a landscape or drawing ... this can help one in making their landscape but what to be created using this tool is still wide open ... for beginners more tools often means more confusion ... jumping from tool to tool is not the answer.

    That is why I suggest ... go sit in the landscape. Give up all the tools .. like a photographer that walks around without a camera .. feeling what is there before grabbing the tools of his craft.

    Let go of the technocrat inside ... and use the rest of the human.

    Just my view ...

    Good Day ...

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm a very visual person, and extremely sensitive to spaces that make me feel "good". It's an actual physical sensation for me, as well as mentally calming. I react quite strongly to unattractive and downright ugly places, too, even those that everyone else is quite comfortable with. A badly proportioned room or tacky accessories are enough to have an strong effect on me.

    So, while I'm able to identify what makes my boat float, without the knowledge of design principles and how to apply them to get the effect I'm after, I'm reduced to a long series of trial-and-error experiments. *Not* very satisfying.

    Since I started studying design, I now have an idea of how to achieve that feeling of enclosure, instead of just being able to recognize that I like it. I'm aware of how perspective can be altered with plant choices and line, and have learned what has to be considered to create unity.

    Just knowing what feels right for you doesn't necessarily mean you can pull it off yourself.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We can all feel. It is stimulation. It is one of the things we strive to affect in others when we design.

    Feeling is not what creates a landscape. Understanding what generates those feelings is the first step. The second step is to use that understanding to evoke those feelings in others. That is my point. It is not to ignore feeling. It is to understand what causes it and to follow through by recreating it.

    Smelling a rose does not make a fragrance.

    It is far from being a technocrat.

    The golf analogy is a good one. But, if you think about it, what are they teaching? How to hold the club, don't lift your head up, how to read a green, different ways to compensate, ... no teaching of creativity.

    Using creativity to apply what is learned is unquestionably what we all do. The more you know, the more you have to work with, but the creativity is not what is learned. It improves only by understanding more.

    Giving to the idea that everything is feeling is closing a lot more creativity than it is opening it.

    Mohave, we might not be meaning different things. But we certainly are disecting them differently.

    In a free fall bungee jump with the wrong sized rope, what I'm feeling is not going to effect what is to happen.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I know this thread is somewhat out of date, but it raises some interesting points and I have a thing or two to add. Be warned: my response is long.

    First, I've been a professional artist for almost 20 years and I can tell you with certainty that, whether in a painting or a landscape, what is a focal point for one person is not necessarily the focal point for another. The idea that we all instantly grasp something -- the same thing -- as a focal point is aesthetic nonsense bordering on mysticism. The concept that you can "lead the eye" around is just as faulty. Unfortunately, it's a concept that has stubbornly survived all evidence to the contrary and is still being written into well-meaning books and spoken by well-meaning artists. Naturally, when you have variety in shapes, sizes, texture and color, the eye will move around, but if you line up 10 people and tell them to write down the first 5 things that they notice in a particular landscape, I guarantee you you'll get 10 completely different lists.

    Second, drawing may or may not help you "see". The best way I've found to see is to look uncritically (called "innocent eyes" or "with the eyes of a child") at something and take note of the first thoughts that pop into your head. Take note of where YOU look, and what YOU notice. In the books you mentioned, whatever YOUR eyes did when looking at the images defined the focal point(s) FOR YOU and that's all that matters. Some things appeal to you, some don't. Some draw your eye, some never will.

    Third, I find that having difficulty visualizing an end result is sometimes dependent on someone's skill level at whatever they're attempting, but (not implying that this is you) some people simply don't visualize well, and it's a very individual, grey-matter related issue that training may not "fix". Some people can do difficult number crunching in their heads, some can mentally replay music they've heard only briefly, some can visualize whatever they want -- the vast majority of us have some minor skills in each of those areas, but the experience is highly personal so don't get down on yourself if you don't visualize well: it might just not be your thing.

    If you see a landscape you really like, your best bet is to try to figure out why exactly you like it, and it might not end up being for the reason that you think. Give it some time. You may have to study something many times before you can begin to break down the elements well enough to consider their impact on you. I've had a lot of experience analyzing old masters' paintings, and sometimes it's surprising to realize in the end what drew me to a piece.

    Some people look at a landscape in awe, the most superficial layer of their thought registers "pretty flowers!", they run out and get a bunch of flowers in appealing colors, throw them together and hate the result. Another person might look at the same landscape, peel back their first layer of thought and then notice that the foliage is highly varied in texture and color and that the flowers are singing back-up, and they'll run out and get a bunch of perennials with interesting foliage, throw them together and hate the result. A third person gets past the flowers and foliage and sees the natural and appealing layering of heights and sizes, as well as the ... well, anyway, you get the point. Maybe it isn't the varied shades of pink flowers that I like so much in the picture but the way they all drape loosely and languidly into the flagstone path. If I try to build a garden around tall, statuesque plants with pink flowers, I'll be disappointed because I duplicated the wrong element. Maybe it's not the pink flowers or their uncontrolled exuberance but the repetition of contrasting blue and yellow foliage plants that captures my heart. In other words, know thyself!

    You need to be patient and analyze. Analyze, analyze, analyze. Pick out the half-dozen or so garden images that leave you absolutely breathless and look at them again and again until you can reason through what it is that really works for you in those images. Feel first, then reason, but you need both. You have to come to some understanding about your own aesthetics before you can possibly hope to design something that appeals to you.

    Good luck!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Juliaws" response is very good imo. I stated in a previous thread some ideas about conceptual vision and ill paste it here.

    I have had clients with good conceptual skills and many without good conceptual skills. If you have trouble imagining what your living room would look like if you rearranged the funiture then you will have trouble designing a landscape.

    Some peoples skills are in areas other than conceptual vision. If you have trouble picturing and imagining your final product you need to get help from someone who has the ability to conceptualize.

    The ability to conceptualize can be improved by simply trying things and seeing how it works out. Over time you can fine tune your garden to what appeals to you most. Along the way your conceptual skills will improve.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    What a great thread! I have really enjoyed this, thank you all.

    Just a thought, Prairielove, but I was wondering what it was about your existing landscape which attracted you to it in the first place? If I read your description accurately, you have quite a bit of borrowed scenery which you are interested in integrating and amplifying from your own property. (This is always given that you have not "bought the view" as well a la George Vanderbilt, in which case...hooray!). Ruminating on this might be the thing which brings out the "blobs" in your creative senses.

    I keep hearing about these radio towers and it reminds me of the billboard with the eyeglasses in the Great Gatsby. Is this something that, subconsciously, you want to replicate in your own landscape? Repetition (formal and informal) can both focus the mind and downplay the details. A good way to either hide or play up an element in the landscape. Whether it be five or seventeen triangles, the mind will not differentiate the towers from the conifers but will still acknowledge their existence.

    Finally, it might be fun for you to check out some books on tuscan villa landscape designs. They were masters of the borrowed view.

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert