Software
Houzz Logo Print
cinsay_gw

photo falsehoods

18 years ago

I recall an earlier post where a picture showed people picking a type of pepper from the wrong type of plant - or something to that effect. The poster vented that the advertisement basically duped people into a false belief with respect to gardening. I don't recall which forum I read it in but if someone does, please remind me and I'll try to add my two cents there as well.

At any rate, just the other day, while reading a popular magazine I saw two pictures that really through me for a loop. One was an advertisement that showed people picking potatoes from full, leafy, flowering potato plants on a farm. I lived behind a potato field at one time, and I don't ever recall the plants being full leafy green when the potatoes were harvested. Nor do I recall anyone ever going out into the field with bushel baskets and picking them individually.

The other picture was a lovely photo of acorns in moss. The acorn in the center was sprouting. A root was growing out of it and a seedling tree. The only problem was that the tree was a sasafrass (spelling?) tree, not an oak.

The part I really found surprising was that the pictures were included in magazine that also had articles on gardening!

I think we do those who do not garden a disservice when inaccuracies such as these are shown. Like commercials that show people picking ripe fruit from a tree in full leaf with blooming flowers. It just doesn't seem right.

Not that I'm actually upset about this - I just wanted to vent to a group that might share my angst.

Thanks,

Cindy

Comments (5)

  • 18 years ago

    Actually, I posted that original rant -- guess it was one of my grouchy days. I was complaining about a tv commercial for a national brand of picante sauce. The commercial carried on about how they bred and grew their own special strain of jalapeno pepper. Except in the commercial, they didn't show jalapenos, they showed some of the larger, longer, and paler-green Anaheim type chiles. I was just cranky because it seems like the media doesn't know or care if they ID plants right. I've seen all kinds of misidentified things over the years, in magazines, newspapers, you name it. Sometimes even in places like gardening magazines when they really should know better, or at least do a better job of proofreading. But, no one is perfect, and people do make mistakes.

    I saw the same ad for a VERY prominent potato chip/snack food company. Yes, the happy little farmers were frolicking in the fields with their quaint baskets. Perhaps we shouldn't be complaining about all of the things they got wrong, maybe we should commend them for having the farmers at least standing in a potato field, God knows, it probably could have just as easily been a field of soybeans with some potato flowers photoshopped in. And no, you definitely aren't harvesting potatoes to make potato chips at that stage in the crop cycle. You MIGHT, if you're really desperate and it's a good year, find a few marble- to golf-ball sized new potatoes at the stage when the plants are just starting to bloom, but even so, they wouldn't be starchy enough at that stage to fry up well into a chip. I usually start looking for "new" potatoes about 4 weeks after the plants have stopped blooming.

  • 18 years ago

    I share your concerns. The photos that really "get my goat" are all the ones of the fancy seed germination trays that show the plastic dome cover still on while the plants inside are already 6" tall and flowering.

    It's no wonder that many new to growing from seed think you are supposed to keep the dome on right up to transplant time. ;)

    I won't go into all the Miracle Grow pics of the perfect garden while the 1/2 NOT sprayed with their product is wilting, stunted, and half dead. What a misleading comparison!! ;)

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    The photo falsehoods extend to seed sales as well. I have seen Armenian cucumber misrepresented on the seed packet by not just one, but several vendors. They depicted it as a very long spiny cucumber - not as the long, smooth, fuzzy _melon_ that it really is. This cost me a seed crop many years ago, when I was growing a rare melon (which will cross with Armenian "cukes").

    Photos of seed or fruit, from on-line seed vendors, are often used for more than one selection. Just last week, I found two different limas carried by the same company - both using the identical photo. Did they think no one would notice???

    Then there is the popular practice of retouching photos, such as the use of filters to make the colors appear more vibrant than they really are. And those that use illustrations exaggerate to an almost laughable degree.

    Yes, those MG "comparisons" really stretch the truth. I have seen similar unbelievable photos in support of other garden products, such as foliar sprays, or various soil treatments (such as gypsum).

    But of course, these misleading ads & photos are in the minority. Most garden companies - those who wish to stay in business - don't resort to such tactics.

  • 18 years ago

    I've gone and checked IDs quit a few times after disagreeing with captions on photos. Sometimes I'm right, sometimes I'm wrong and sometimes I find out there are other things with the same common name so that probably means I am wrong to say the caption is wrong :) All in all, it's a good learning experience for me....but what about the person who doesn't recognize the error and perhaps learns the wrong thing?

    I remembered the post awhile back about an ad with peppers and salsa. Funny part is that I remembered they planted seeds wrong and recalled nothing about the wrong variety of plant. When I found the old post both errors were mentioned. Interesting how different things stick with different people. Could be that I know more about planting peppers and less about identifying various varieties.

    BTW, were the "farmers" picking potatoes off the plants like one would harvest tomatoes or were they individually digging them from underground?

    And maybe this is the time to admit to some educational fraud on my part. We had a demonstation potato plot that was to be available to visitors to dig up potatoes during a two day festival. We left a volunteer in charge the first day with directions that visitors could dig up half the rows and she should limit each person to one shovelful. Well, half way through the day she reported that ALL the potatoes were harvested. She said everyone loved digging them and she did not want to tell them to stop. Hmmm, maybe she missed something in the directions. Oh, well, what to do? After visitors left that day a couple of us went and staked out several rows and BURIED the already dug potatoes and pulled some of the dead top growth off the compost pile and spread it over the rows. The next day visitors were able to dig pototoes...again...with a law-and-order type volunteer in charge. The plot lasted for the whole day :)

    Here is a link that might be useful: link to original discussion

  • 18 years ago

    As a person deeply involved in garden media, I say please make lots of noise about this! Some ad people don't know a grape from a potato, and inexperienced editors and photographers simply make mistakes. Seeds and plants are sometimes mislabeled, in stores and in public gardens, which leads to further confusion. The better magazines and book publishers run the finished articles by a half dozen people in hopes of catching mistakes, while others that just want to throw content out there don't bother.

    What brand of potato chips is the offender here? I want to see that commercial and rattle some cages.

    Here is a link that might be useful: my website