Software
Houzz Logo Print
ykerzner

A few questions for tapla

16 years ago

I have a few questions after reading part of the book on Growing Media.

1. When using fresh pine bark fines, how does the gritty mix deal with the toxicity produced during decomposition, or is it not a problem? Presumably, that's why you prefer slightly aged pine bark.

2. How would someone go about testing the pH of the gritty mix after 1 year, 2 years, and 3 years? In this vein, assuming good water, by how much will the pH of the mix fluctuate over 3 (or more) years?

3. Using the measurement of texture, how would you classify the gritty mix? Sandy (large particles, etc)?

4. Does gypsum raise the pH by providing Calcium?

Thanks in advance.

Comments (4)

  • 16 years ago

    1) By looking at the pictures posted and listening to the testimony of others, you can see it's never been an issue. What book and what specific toxicity are you referring to?

    2) The link below is quite interesting in that it illustrates the difference between 'ideal' pH ranges of container media vs mineral soils, but I'll mention again that the pH of the media solution is more important than the pH of the media itself. I never concern myself with the pH o0f the media. I try to use a urea-based fertilizer on the acid lovers, and if I see any signs of yellowing that doesn't straighten out with an application of fertilizer, I'll add an ounce or so of vinegar to a gallon of water and water by hand, OR add a little Sprint 138 Fe chelate to the fertilizer solution to correct the problem of a pH induced Fe immobilization.

    There are lots of tutorials on the net that describe how to measure media pH, but you're going to get wide ranging readings after plants are in the media because pH changes by the hour in containers based on temperature, moisture levels, fertility levels, and other factors. Even the type of plant material in the container and what time of day it is has an affect on media solution pH. As a hobbyist, you'll drive yourself nutts trying to 'maintain' any specific pH.

    The tendency is for container media pH to rise as it ages as a result of the contributions from tap water that is usually alkaline. You can stop this upward creep by adding enough vinegar or citric acid to bring your irrigation water down to 6.0.

    3) Coarse.

    4) It has some very small effect on pH, either up or down, but it is so slight we consider it as nonaffective.

    Al

    Here is a link that might be useful: More info

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for the comprehensive answer. So what is used to combat the acidifying effect of the pine fines? The book is "Growing Media for Ornamental Plants and Turf" by Handreck and Black. The toxicity referred to is on pages 33 to 36, especially bottome of page 34. I mean the toxicity produced by rotting roots or plant material (falls under phytotoxicity).
    Also, is the ideal CEC zero?

  • 16 years ago

    Bark doesn't break down the same as sap-wood or root-wood. In fact, that's why UNcomposted
    bark is favored for the Gritty Mix.

    Ideally, the particles range between 1/8 - 1/4 of an inch.

    Realistically, the particles are about 1/16 - 3/8 of an inch.

    Josh

  • 16 years ago

    The toxicity referred to is on pages 33 to 36, especially bottom of page 34. I mean the toxicity produced by rotting roots or plant material (falls under phytotoxicity), which is a good reason to avoid reusing container soils. They're talking about decomposing roots of plants known to be phytotoxic/allelopathic, like sunflowers and black walnut.

    Pine bark stored in anaerobic conditions (saturated) and w/o turning can become toxic, so avoid saturated bags of bark or let it air dry after you leach it - better to avoid it altogether. I use a LOT of pine bark, and I've never encountered what I suspected to be a problem, even in the very wet bags I sometimes get in the spring that have wintered over outdoors.

    Dolomitic lime (garden lime) is used to supply Ca & Mg, as well as raise pH of acidic media.

    Again, CEC isn't as important in containers because we're always replenishing the nutrient reserves when we fertilize at short intervals. In mineral soils, higher CEC values only indicate that a soil has a greater capacity to hold cations. Therefore, it requires higher rates of fertilizer or lime to change a high CEC soil. When a high CEC soil has good test levels, it offers a large nutrient reserve. However, when it is poor, it can take a large amount of fertilizer or lime to correct that soil test. A high CEC soil requires a higher soil cation level, or soil test, to provide adequate nutrition. Low CEC soils hold fewer nutrients, and will likely be subject to leaching of mobile anions. Technically speaking, the particular CEC of a soil is neither good nor bad, but knowing it can be a valuable management tool.

    Al