Software
Houzz Logo Print
kristimama

Growing Sandy loam vs. 100% compost

17 years ago

OK, so here's another question for y'all. :-)

I'm building raised beds because I don't want to grow directly in my native soil.

I'm wondering if you could share some of the merits, pros or cons of growing in sandy loam vs direct into compost?

I was thinking the sandy loam would have better water retention ability, but the compost might stay more fluffy.

I know Mel/SFG basically advocates a mix with compost and vermiculite, I have read and experimented with SFG in raised planter boxes. But I am also attracted to the "french intensive" approach, too... and I have heard that there are just some plants that do better when they're planted in actual "soil." (i.e. sandy loam).

I'm bringing in about 6 cu yards later this week... I can make it 100% compost, or a richly amended sany loam that's certified organic for veggies.... now I just need to understand the best choice for me.

Any of you more seasoned gardeners willing to share what you all do?

Thanks!

-k

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    I have done the compost filled bed thing and while it works fine for growing things, there is a massive volume reduction over the season. You will be replacing a lot of compost each year.

    That's where the actual soil is handy. It doesn't shrink in volume. It doesn't have to be an either/or situation. If you go say... 75% soil 25% compost you will still have one of the richest soils around, but won't have to replace so much lost volume each year.

  • 17 years ago

    I know it's now what you asked, but I would use the sandy loam amended yearly with modest amounts of compost.

  • 17 years ago

    I grow in nearly 100% compost, because I am lazy and want to make quick beds over the turf that I have all over the place (newish property with lots of lawn), so I lay down newspaper and frame in the bed, then fill up with compost, adding a few shovelfuls of dirt I may have access too from other plantings going on at the time (always have leftover soil from planing bushes and stuff). I agree with above post that it shrinks over the season. To deal with this I pile it high in the fall with leaves, grass clippings, and more finished compost, and it is ready to plant in spring.

  • 17 years ago

    I had a wonderful raised bed several years ago that I filled with finished compost, or rather, nearly finished compost. It really was great stuff. I planted a couple of English roses and they grew like wildfire and you never saw such huge blooms. They were so heavy that the rose bushes couldn't support their wieght and they drooped over to the ground.

    I also planted cosmos seed that I had saved from a flower bed in back. The plants in back had been 28" tall but the ones in the compost reached up to the rain gutters on the house and completely blocked the sun from our picture window.

    The biggest surprise that we got from the compost was that there were some uncomposted cucumber seeds in it that germinated and grew into the most delicious gigantic cukes we ever tasted. Course when I found the first one, it was a complete surprise because I didn't know they were in there. SO there I was, pulling some weeds out of the planter, and I put my hand on a huge, cool green mass and I jumped about three feet in the air. When I figured out what it was I went looking in the masses of growth and found 27 cukes the smallest of which was about 15" long, and 6" circumference.

    You can certainly use 100% compost, but just don't expect everything to be... 'normal.' Mwahahahaha!!!!!!

    Cheryl

  • 17 years ago

    Sandy loam would be my choice....

  • 17 years ago

    I did the sandy loam and then amend with compost every year. Works pretty well but sometimes it tends to repel water at first. A good mulch and a drip system solved that problem.

  • 17 years ago

    Sandy loam sucks compost in like a sponge. Prepare to amend with one foot of compost over the years. Short term, unfinished compost may bother some of the more delicate veggies, such as greens and lettuce. Long term, Compost is better than sand for almost everything except perhaps pole beans, asparagus, watermelon, carrots, and garlic/onions.

  • 17 years ago

    What you have to remember though is not all compost is created equally, and it is very, very difficult to create well balanced, nutrient heavy compost. The reason is this: compost does not create nutrients where none existed in the first place. Sure, most commercial compost operations do a pretty good job, but if your region has certain defficiencies (such as a lack of phosphorus, or boron, or zinc, or whatever), then any compost produced from that local soil is going to have a similar deficiency. This includes manure, because manure is really just hay passed through a digestive tract.

    It may not be a problem, but I would hesitate to ever use just compost for growing. A sandy loam ammended with a modest 1/2" - 1" of compost will supply a great deal more minerals and nutrients than either on their own.