Software
Houzz Logo Print
prairie_love

Function dictates form - right? (long, with pics)

20 years ago

Isn't that right, form follows function? Well, we have recently found a functional requirement for our landscaping that was not in our vision, to say the least.

This is a picture of the view from our back patio - taken summer 2005. The tall trees at the very back are at the bank of the Red River of the North.

{{gwi:23910}}

This is a picture from approximately the same location - about two weeks ago.

{{gwi:23911}}

This is taken from a high spot in the field next to us, looking back at our house.

{{gwi:23912}}

Some of you may have been aware that the Red River of the North was in major flood this spring. These pictures were actually taken a few days before the crest - the water came quite a bit closer. Although we live along the river, and rivers do flood, this was completely unexpected. There was no obvious reason for a flood of this magnitude this year. Fortunately our house did not flood. The water came to about 12 linear feet from the patio, and the house was still about 3 1/2 vertical feet above the water.

However, this served as a major wake-up call for us. While trying to avoid a discussion of the reasons, it is clear that flooding of this river is becoming worse. If you look at the top ten floods ever recorded, six of them are in the last 20 years. And, as I said, this year's flood was unexpected - we did not have such a significant snowfall that flooding was predicted. Not to this extent anyway.

So, the question that has been occupying our minds for the last two weeks is - how do we protect the house from even greater floods? Many people have clay ring dikes around their homes. This doesn't seem feasible for our house. The back yard slopes so much that it would take an enormous berm to protect to the level we would like.

Side note - the biggest flood in the area was in 1997. The flood is measured by feet above river bottom and flood stage starts at 28 feet. In 1997 the water went to 54.4 feet. This year it was 48 feet. We have measured our house at 51.5 feet. It did not flood in '97 because the then-owner put a massive sand bag dike around it and manned it for a long time (we estimate he must have kept the dike going for about two weeks). So we know it can be done, at least to 54.4 feet, but the amount of work is phenomenal. Not to say we wouldn't do it if need be, but we would rather find protection first.

Back to the problem. So, if we cannot build a protective dike, it seems that our only option is the ability to put up a temporary dike. These exist. I am putting a link to one company that sells temporary dikes if anyone wants to see it to visualize what I am talking about. The idea is that you can put up these panels that are designed to hold the water back, then remove them when not needed. They have a flap that goes along the ground, which you would place sand bags on to create a seal. I am not sure how you get the seal between panels - they are sending us a video that will hopefully answer some of our questions - including price!

Anyway, we think this is a possibility. But, in order to use it, we would need a level surface circling the house on which to set the panels. Think running track . The company claims that any surface will work - grass, concrete, etc, but we would probably use a non-grass surface. We're thinking some type of pavers. So now the idea is that we have a strip, probably 8-10 feet wide, circling the house. It would not have to be a constant width, it could have areas that pooch out or make curves, just as long as there is the 8-10 feet area within the path - does that make sense? We would have to build up in the back yard, make a terrace, to get it up to the level the rest of the yard would be at.

DH is convinced that this can look nice. I have my doubts. I am trying to visualize this, and just cannot come up with it. So, my question to you all (finally) - have you ever seen something like this? Can you envision it? Can you think of ways to make it look nice but still retain the function?

BTW, this one would NOT be a DIY. It's too much work and too important.

Oh, and as a second question - any idea what to do at the bottom of the hill? The grass is all dead due to a summer flood last year (not nearly as high, but high enough to kill the grass). It seems pointless to me to try to grown lawn there when it could get flooded at any time. These spring floods don't usually kill plants because they aren't growing yet, but summer floods will kill anything that gets compeltely covered with water.

thanks for the help....

Ann

Here is a link that might be useful: Temporary flood walls

Comments (16)

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ann: I have to admit that when I first say the pictures I thought..."ohh isn't that a pretty house over looking a pond"...then I read the text. Sorry I don't have any advice for you, but it does make some of the other landscape challenges discussed seem rather trivial. Good luck!

    - Brent

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    GIven the height of the flooding, how far away from your house do you anticipate having this "track"?

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I know FEMA is a bad word right now because of Katrina, but I would suggest popping into their website and reading all their advise on flood proofing your house. Find out what the highest historical flood was,not just the pasat 10 years. The Corps of Engineers should have have info on the Red River for your location. I would hate to see you spend lots of money and time to install a permenant flood control and then find out it is not the right height. Are you officially in the 100 year flood plain? ( if you are paying flood insurance, you are). Check with your local flood plain administrator to see what you can and cannot do in the flood plain. If you build something without a permit, they can make you take it out at your cost.

    Bottom line call your local governement and find out who is in charge of flood plain requirents and get their imput before you do anything. Good Luck.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    And invest in flood insurance...even if you AREN'T in the 100 year flood plain. (Around here the ACE is revising the FP maps...they did our neighborhood a year ago...the FP moved up quite a bit.)

    As to plants--perhaps your local botanical garden or ag agent can tell you what is native to the floodplains in your area. That is what I would suggest you plant. Native plants in flood plains are USED to the periodic flooding and receding--and have eveolved strategies for dealing with it.

    I'm thinking of you--hope all dries out soon. I wish you could send some rain our way!

    melanie

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I guess I wasn't completely clear. The data I provided IS the complete recorded history of this river. The highest flood ever recorded was in 1997, at 54.4 feet. This spring was the sixth highest flood ever recorded.

    Yes, I know about floodplains and insurance. One can hardly live in this region and not know - particularly since 1997. Our *property* is in the 100 year floodplain, our *house* is not. We are not required to carry insurance but often have, and after this year we always will do so :).

    FEMA is not a bad word around here. In 1997, they did a very good job helping the community. In fact, I happen to have a little pin and certificate from FEMA as acknowledgement for my volunteer efforts - what a deal!

    Melanie, the funny thing is that now I want rain! The river is now back where it belongs, but there is so much mud and silt everywhere, I would like a single good hard rain to wash it all off.

    You're right about the natives. I had thought of that but really wasn't sure what there might be. I will do some research into it and see if there is something(s) we like.

    The proposed track would have to be fairly close to the house because of the slope in the back. The further out, the more terracing needed.

    Thanks for the feedback.

    Ann

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ann,
    You have a monster, expensive problem. I have been thinking about it from my own personal thoughts if I were faced with rising waters. Even with temporary panels there would still be the frantic rush to install them plus filling sandbags and placing them. A lot of work!

    You point out that anything done has to be close to the house. And it is a lovely home and view. I would investigate building a solid concrete block wall around the house about 3' high and then facing it with the flat veneer stone. In selected spots stile type steps to go up and over the wall could be constructed. Then have on hand enough temporary panels to seal off the driveway and front door areas as needed.

    For instance, if the wall was 7' off your back patio you would be able to look over it when seated and have room to garden along the patio.

    Although an expensive idea you would be secure and not faced with backbreaking work each spring at flood time. Also, it would make your property more saleable and the solution would be attractive.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    How about if your "track" was disguised as a pathway around your home? Come up with a logical walking path, then landscape to the path, ex. put trees and shrubs on the river side of the path to make the house more enclosed.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Philosophy warning: you have been presented with a form (high water) that you did not choose, so in this instance it is form doing the dictating. If you can come up with a solution that appears like you have invited the water then you can claim that form has followed function and will give a very important appearance of being in control. Nandina has some experience of this problem, her water has sharp toothed amphibians in it, so she might be worth listening to on the practical side.
    We had hardly any snow and the beaver are swimming up and down the river trying to understand it all and a white heron is taking advantage of shallow water but the river bank is black with awful sludge.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    One fuction is as a flood plain. Now you are trying to design the form that will accept that function where maybe you were not considering it before.

    I had a Professor who was really into wetlands and flood plains when I was in school. He used to give us the montra that "floods don't cause damage, but people who put things in the way of them do". Another was "you can build in a flood plain, but I won't build in a flood plain".

    Anyway, he had us do a school project where we each took a section of the creek that ran through beautiful Moscow and try to do the best we could in planning how to mitigate the impacts of flooding throughout the community. We presented these to the city council and other interested parties (Yes, Moscow has a city council, it ain't Russia - it's Idaho). Anyway, it was very interesting to learn about how the actions one person takes to protect his property more often than not creates bigger problems somewhere else. The cumulative effect is huge. It is quite possible that many people around you took actions after the '97 flood which is why you might be dealing with a bigger problem with less rain now (I thought the flood was '98 in the Red).

    Be careful not to be a part of the problem. Any area you keep from flooding displaces water that has to go somewhere else. Any slowing of water movement makes it build up behind it. Slowing it also makes that silt fall out of solution leaving you with a mess.

    Just another good use for grass, I suppose.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm liking nandina's suggestion. I can't remember what your house looks like---but have vague memories that a stone wall would be appropriate...though expensive.

    Is the grass that was under the water REALLY dead? DOwn to the roots? Or is it coming up again? We vacation on a coastal island--one year there was hurricane overwash, and we thought the myrtles between the houses and the dune line were DEAD. They certainly LOOKED dead. The next summer they were as green as ever. (Evidently that species is used to dealing wiht having it's roots submerged in saltwater for long periods.) Sometimes it just takes a while for the plants to come back.

    I googled the string North Dakota native flood plain plants and found a site with this reccommendation:
    "Basin wildrye is a perennial bunchgrass native to much of the western United States. It performs best on flood plains or areas receiving additional moisture; however, basin wildrye performed well on sandy soils in western North Dakota receiving average yearly precipitation of 12 to 18 inches during the years of field evaluation. Seedlings develop slowly, and stand establishment is difficult. Basin wildrye is a tall grass that provides excellent standing forage for livestock and nesting and escape cover for wildlife. It can also be used as a grass windbreak for wind erosion protection or to control blowing snow. Basin wildrye does not do well on coarse, shallow or heavy clay soils. This grass is susceptible to leaf and stem rusts in the eastern half of North Dakota."

    I also found a great site--with a lot of lists and some contact names--from the ND DOT. (Of all places!)I've linked it below.

    Good luck.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Good native plants link!

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    laag, you are absolutely right; this is best dealt with as a riverbank-community problem and not as an individual problem. The original problem is the allowing of building on flood plains at all, which is a political problem. However, if there is no umbrella flood management campaign, then it is each homeowner to themselves, and it does make it worse for others. Here is a link to a downstream (or is it upstream?) story.

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Winnipeg Floodway

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Your three questions:
    1) In your case, with your life and house at risk, I would say flood control function is more important than landscaping form.

    2) My company has experience using these barrier walls, as cofferdams to keep water out of our riverbottom excavations. I was not the project engineer for that site, but I remember our on-site personnel were quite satisified with the system. Our barrier wall installation was as a cofferdam and not intended to be a spur of the moment seasonal flood control levee, and it was not trivial to erect.

    The pre-planned barrier wall deployment area can be
    disguised as a lawn surrounded by planting beds. Our barrier walls were installed on riverbottom sediments.

    3) At the bottom of the hill consider installing rip-rap (erosion control rocks). If the river is scouring, then these will be needed to maintain the integrity of your retaining wall and barrier wall.

    At any rate you will need civil and/or geothechnical engineer help for this proejct.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    nandina The wall sounds good, and I can assure you it would be much LESS expensive than the panels (we finally got some prices yesterday - ouch!). DH and I had talked about something similar (only hadn't thought of the steps) - we're afraid we'll end up with something that looks like a fortress! Are you able to envision this so that it would look welcoming while still providing the protective function? At the moment, regardless of look, I am leaning toward this idea...

    gottagarden Thas was basically DH's idea - I'm just having trouble envisioning it. But then, I'm having trouble envisioning nandina's too - maybe the problem is with my vision!

    Ink I had it the other way around - I thought I had been presented with a necessary function (protection from the water), so I was trying to come up with a form to make it pleasing. As for beavers, I am really unhappy with beavers. While the yard was flooded, my new larch 10 foot tall larch tree had only 1 foot showing above water. While I was watching, a beaver came along and gnawed the top off and swam away with it! Darn beaver.

    laag yup, that's what I meant by my title for this thread. Interesting project. And relevant. Yes, things have changed since '97 (yes, it was '97) and they may affect us. The city built a higher dike, providing protection to 60 feet. Although they moved some buildings further back from the river, to make the channel through downtown wider, it still of course is a narrow channel in downtown. They also build a diversion system around the city to collect water from overland flooding and from the coulee that runs through town. The diversion dumps back into the river only about one mile upstream of us. I never wanted to live along the river, but DH and I fell in love with this property. Before we purchased, I had conversations with everyone I could think of - city engineer, army corps of engineers, EERC (energy and environmental research center), etc. The people that own the farmstead immediately downstream of the diversion had commissioned a study by the EERC to find out how it would affect our river flow. Their study claims that in a flood the magnitude of '97, the diversion would raise the river at our location by a whopping four inches. In the end, we were lulled by the presumption that 1997 was truly the Flood of the Century. I no longer believe that. I also am not certain I believe the EERC's study of the effects of the diversion. IOW, I understand exactly what you are saying both about others' actions affecting our water levels, and about anything we do affecting those downstream. I can say though, that if we build something close to the house, it will only affect the river in a flood of '97 magnitude (or very close to). At that point most, if not all, of the houses around us will be flooded.

    melanie So you can envision the wall too? Hmm, I need to work on my imagination. Yes, the grass is dead - the grass that was covered in the *summer* flood last year. The grass that was covered this spring is just fine - greening up nicely. Thank you for the link. I glanced quickly at it and noticed willows and though, duh! There are willows at the back of the field next to us that flood every spring, and they are doing fine. I love that willows come in many varieties with interesting bark and winter interest, so am thinking I definitely need some willows. Also, if my larch has survived, I will put in more larch. The wildrye would be an excellent choice. I am thinking we can work on this. It gives me something to do since whatever is decided regarding a floodwall will not be hands on for me.

    karinlThe original problem is the allowing of building on flood plains at all Well, that is a rather inflammatory statement - and as you say, political. We should also not build in earthquake zones, or along tornado alley, or the entire gulf and southern Atlantic coast due to hurricanes. Nor should we allow towns in Colorado, Utah, Nevada, Arizona, and southern California because of fire hazard. Towns were originally built along rivers to meet the needs of the settlers for transportation and procurement of supplies. This land has an amazingly rich soil and is wonderfully productive. Remember that when you have pasta - the durum wheat was likely grown here, or french fries from McDonald's - the potatoes are from here, or use Crystal sugar - the sugar beets may be from here, or use canola oil or eat sunflower seeds. This land was settled for farming, but the settlers needed the rivers for transportation. Sorry if I am sounding annoyed, but I found this to be a rather "superior" sounding comment. And yes, we North Dakotans tend to have an inferiority complex and always assume people are making snide comments about us .

    As for an umbrella management plan, see my reply to laag. The city has a plan and has implemented vast improvements since 1997. However, we do not live in the city limits. The dikes and diversions can only be extended so far. You provided a link to Winnipeg's floodway, and they do indeed have good protection (which was also implemented after a devastating flood). However, the same problem exists for people who live outside Winnipeg city limits. If you drive to Winnipeg, you see farmsteads outside the city with big ring dikes. Yes, the individuals are left on their own, but I don't see how a city could be expected to protect those outside its limits (who don't pay taxes of course). And Winipeg is downstream, the river flows north.

    isabella Thank you for the comments. 1) yes, it was an attempt at a joke to title this thread the way I did, and yes the protection is most important, but I think one can try to have that be attractive as well as functional. 2) interesting. I was under the impression that these had not yet been used in the US. Can I ask the name of the company that made yours? 3) I will keep this in mind. We will be hiring help, but wanted to get some idea of our plans first, so that we know WHO to hire!

    Thank you so much for the advice and concern.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ann, use your imagination here...

    how about something like this...
    {{gwi:23913}}

    a 3 foot wall, like mentioned before, with steps going up about every 25 feet or so. Instead of just grass on top of the steps, you can make the wall into a kind of raised flower bed with some grass in places or even a patio. This would only be about 10 feet deep, and then there would be steps going down on the other side. So instead of just a wall, it would be like a raised planting area big enough to socialize on.. does this make any sense? So there would actually be two walls, running parallel about 10 feet apart around the property. They would be filled inbetween like 2 adjoining retaining walls. just an idea.

    Courtney

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ann,
    Courtney has posted an excellent picture of a concrete block wall which has been veneered. As you can see, it is not a fortress appearance. Do a search for "stone veneered walls". The sites which appear are chock full of pictures and information on their construction. Hopefully there is a nearby stoneyard where displays of different types of stone veneer can be viewed.

    Start your research with a civil engineer. This is the person to lay out the wall design, depth of block in soil, width and height of wall which would probably vary. Within the past few years several new products used for sealing and waterproofing have arrived on the market. They are excellent, long lasting and can be sprayed/painted on all types of surfaces including concrete and stone. This is a distinct advantage if you decide on a wall project. As I study your topography it may not be necessary to construct protection across the front of the house. This would be the last area to flood giving you time to sandbag from each wall end across the front if necessary. Again, this requires the skilled civil engineer design.

    Sorry to be so sketchy with these comments. I am not on site so cannot provide the answers that your local experts can. But, with their help I think you may be able to construct an attractive wall which would save you years of worry and back breaking work. Hopefully you will keep us updated. Good luck.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    courtskey Beautiful! Thank you SO much. You provided an impetus that really helped me see what nandina was suggesting. A further search as suggested by nandina has turned up several pictures that are helping me see. One of the parts I could not visualize was having a wall, then the slope down on the other side. I found some pictures that helped me visualize how this could work. And I never thought of the double wall (double expense?) with a flower bed and/or sitting area on top.

    nandina I agree that we could do a wall around the back and north side, leaving the front and the side with the driveway to be sandbagged, if necessary. I am getting excited about this idea. Now, to convince DH, who is still researching temporary floodwalls (grin). No, you were not sketchy, you were extremely helpful and I very, very much appreciate it.

    Thank you all for the helpful comments. I am feeling a bit more hopeful that we may be able to do something to help the situation. I'm sure it will take a bit of time to get things going (although we hope to install protection over this summer), but I will post as we go. Thank you again.

    Ann