Software
Houzz Logo Print
swanoir

First Principles...

19 years ago

Since many people visit here in the Spring who are new to landscape design (like myself), I thought it would be useful to create a thread where we could share design principles that have been helpful. I continue to find designing a garden, learning and choosing plants, as well as knowing how to place them correctly an overwhelming task. Many of the design books I have looked at are either "how to" books without much helpful design information or esoteric tomes beyond the understanding of a novice. Hopefully, by each of us sharing what has worked, we can all benefit.

One principle I have found to be helpful is what Ann Lovejoy calls, "The Rule of Thirds." She writes: "An informal rule of thirds makes for pleasing combinations. This means that when about a third of the garden's plants are evergreen, with another third structural deciduous plants, the final third can consist of seasonal color plants... I use the rule of thirds for framing the entire garden and defining its perimeters, and for framing and defining each part of the garden. I use the evergreen third to integrate the garden with its setting and to create patterns that hold the garden together during winter."

While it isn't a principle, there is an excellent thread within the Landscape Forum that I enjoyed so much I bookmarked it. I have included it below.

Here is a link that might be useful: How to See

Comments (29)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    P. Allan Smith has a principle in his list named "Abundance". I do think that this is an important element...at least in the style of garden that I like. It is also an easy one to understand. A bed that is stuffed full of plants can hide a lot of other design flaws. I grow a lot of perennials from seed these days. That sure makes it easier to plant in drifts of 5 or more plants.

    - Brent

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Many first time DIYers forget about "scale", and make their beds, borders, and other elements too small. I guess it's hard to think big when you're not sure what you're doing, I've done the same thing.

    I once compared dinky beds to an adult woman wearing those little earrings meant for tiny girls. Too-small plantings and bunches of tiny "ornaments" look tentative, disorganized, and disjointed. One BIG border or sculpture or birdbath or whatever would have so much more impact than a lot of little ones.

    Same goes for interior decoration. One good sized, good quality "focal point" piece can make a room, whether an antique piece of furniture, good painting, or other artwork, or good oriental rug. Save up for that really special item, and you probably won't spend any more than you would if you collected 20 or 30 $20 ornaments over time.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    #1. Work from general toward detail rather than starting with detail.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    After focusing for a few years on learning the "how-to" garden, I am finally starting to learn more about design.
    Here are some important basics I have been focusing on in my garden. They all seam so simple but it isnt as easy to put them into practice. I can tell I am learning because I recognize things like scale and repitition in other gardens now.
    Scale - as saypointe mentioned, taking risks with size is challenging, especially for a beginner on a budget who isnt a natural risk taker. I dont have a lot to spend on shrubs or large perennials so feel I need to be absolutely sure it is right before I buy. I have gotten some great suggestions by posting photos on this site. For example, some azaeleas in my yard when I bought my house were way too big for the location. Without some prodding here I never would have had the guts to prune them as hard as I did. Now the scale is much more appropriate.
    I dont know if the idea of having taller plants behind shorter plants is scale but I have noticed that I tend to err on the too rigid here. Without thinking about it I can start to make my bed look like stadium seating. I didnt even realize that I was doing it until I read an old Christopher Lloyd article pointing out that variation of scale creates a more natural feel.
    Repitition - this is another one I have to be careful with. I love the cottage garden look but my natrual tendency is to repeat so symetrically that my garden looks like it is painted with stripes. I tend to repeat color more than texture because it is more obvious to me but I am starting to notice other ways to create repitition and unity in my garden.
    Odd numbers - I have read that when grouping plants or repeating, it is better to group or repeat in an odd number becasue the eye naturally divides evenly numbered groups. Of course by the time I read this I had proudly planted groupings of 2 or 4 on either side of my bed, thinking I was so cool for planting groups instead of singles and remembering repetition...oh well, I am learning.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Start at the beginning. The first rule comes before the first principle.

    For every project built on, or a part of, terra firma:

    Rule #1
    The first thing to consider in design, and the first thing to do in construction, is to take positive control of the water.

    IMO, the first principle has to be scale, porportion, and balance.

    I see the same mistakes here, time and again. Someone buys a lot to build their dream home. There is 60 to 100 trees on the lot and the owner tells the builder to save every one of them. A forest is a forest, not a garden, and there will never be anything noteworthy about it as a landscape.

    It is possible to have a great landscape with an over abundance of trees, but it takes extensive hardscape to achive the balance. Only the very best of designers can pull it off. Homeowners shouldn't try.

    The reverse of the forest is the all lawn property. I drive by one of these and think "this guy owns a lawn tractor, ... and he's in love with that machine."

    Scale, proportion, balance

    Homeowners would do well to draw a scale plan of their property. If 80% of it is forest, lawn, or any other uniform substance, they are probably in trouble.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I wonder if detachment shouldn't be one of the principles in order to create design that is objectively good. Because so often things like single plants (including trees) are barriers to good design, and removing them is key to achieving a good result. It is also necessary to get rid of clutter, kitsch, and other sentimentalities.

    Having said that, it is ATTACHMENT that enables the design of a subjectively good landscape, one that works for the people living in the place. Only by placing yourself and your activities in the landscape do you know where shade, pathways, activity spaces, and access are needed. Only by applying your own taste and interest in gardening/plant maintenance does it become YOUR landscape.

    KarinL

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here's something that I figured out about the "3" in a group thing.

    We learn that two points make a line. Right?

    Not to the human eye. It needs at least 3 to make a line.

    If two of a kind are planted, and a connecting line is intended, the human eye will tend to want to look "between them".

    So, three tends to unify.

    Two can be used to divide, such as two columns in front of a door.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    A good thread here (I'll save reading the other thread on the link to peruse when I have more time, it looks good...). I've got lots of books and magazines on gardening and gardening designs,etc. I am very impressed with the principles in P. Allen Smith's "Garden Home" book.

    One principle I've read recently everywhere it seems, is to sit back first and just look at your area as it currently is, maybe for even a year. Find out what the sun and shade pattern at different times of the days and over the seasons.

    I think of this looking at a garden area likened to being a blank slate to start with, what I call the "imagining" part of creating a garden. We had our front lawn tore up and out for over a year before we had it redone. Three years ago we created a CAD plan of the front yard, with ideas drawn in. Doing these things gave us lots of time to evaluate and "imagine" the space. By the time we started the actual work on it, we already knew just what we wanted and how it would look. This saved us time and money that would be spent if something ended up with our wanting to change it and redo it after the work started.

    We did the same for the back patio and pergola area in the back yard. We waited three years until we could afford to replace the interim pea gravel with stone after we took out our falling-apart wood deck. I have recently removed five very old and way overgrown and suckered rose bushes (canes as big as your fist) in the back around the back fenceline. DH and I are actually enjoying sitting out on the back patio looking at this fenced area anew as a blank slate, discussing and "imagining" together what it can become. One thing we found was some Euonymus hedge plants on trellises. We are placing 8 of these along the back corners to create evergreen walls to cover up the ugly fenceline. These will be a backdrop to the large scale garden train layout DH will be creating in this space in the back. There has been a CAD plan for that too, but we are creating more and new ideas to better enjoy this space and view the trainscape.

    Repeated over and over again in my English Garden magazines is the principle of overplanting to crowd out weeds from possibly come up. THIS I wanna try... I like the look of the English gardens overflowing with plants, a look of "exuberance" they call it. Here you see alot of a plant plunked here, another plant plunked over there... after a while it all starts to look the same.

    Various readings mention working with large objects added to make a small garden appear larger. This is new idea to me. We put two large urns with fuschias in the back end of our small children's Secret Garden, I like the look! We've added a large hardscape feature at the front entry; two brick columns flank where the future keyed gate will go, with large concrete ball finials atop the columns.

    BTW, DH (a computer engineer) draws up the garden on a home CAD program, I use pencil and graph paper and tracing paper!

    To see pics of our Secret Garden in progress and other recent landscaping projects, ck out my Picture Trail:

    careytearose

    Here is a link that might be useful: look at Landscaping Projects, Favourite ROSES We Grow albums

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    So far no one has mentioned what I consider to be the very first landscape principle... don't buy into costly or difficult to solve problems! There are times on this Forum when I look at a posted query, shake my head and wonder what possessed the questioner to willingly purchase such a situation? Usually, once the problem is outlined/photographed/posted we are told that there is no or limited budget.

    When building or buying property study the outside grounds carefully. With new construction work carefully with the builder before he brings in a backhoe, destroys the land and trees leaving you with possibly the need for expensive retaining walls, dealing with poorly placed sidewalks, a fly-by-night sod job, etc. An hour or so spent in designer consultation before construction dealing with hardscape and possible construction problems as they affect the land will set up the basis for your all over design. When building one consults with electrical experts, heating experts, kitchen design experts...but why is the exterior design of the property and building scars ignored until after the house is occupied?

    Purchasing an existing structure demands careful study of the outside. Do you have the money and know-how... to screen your outdoor living space from the neighbors...to repair the crumbling retaining wall...to understand why a section of the property is not draining well...to realize that trees will not screen out heavy traffic noise...to recognize that not all communities will allow the fencing you would like to install...that home owner associations have very fussy (and sometimes stupid) rules...that the steep hill in front will need mowing...ad infinitum?

    Landscape principle #1 is...Buyer beware! Beware of yourself and your capability to recognize potential costly outdoor landscape problems when considering a house purchase. Walk the property. Do you feel comfortable? What would it take to make you comfortable? Is it possible? Is it affordable?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Bravo Anne.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Place plants based on the color and shape of their leaves. Color of bloom is secondary."

    I never really got this until I read about it in context. See the link below...

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Secret to a Beautiful Garden

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    swanoir: That really is a good article and it has influenced they way that I approach planting perennials. I have learned that you cannot ignore flower color, but I mostly think about how I can solve issues with foliage.

    At various times I have tried to put my "evolution of a gardener" theory into words. It seems like there is a progression that gardeners go through...maybe have to go through. We start with a few pretty flowers. At some point we move on toward creating multi-seasons of interest and creating pretty arrangements of plants. We move on to realize that maybe it is the shape of the bed that is more important than the actual plants and that shrubs, trees and evergreens should be used to create structure and interest. Maybe the next step is to realize that plants (including trees and shrubs) are just one element of a garden and that it is the overall design and hardscape that makes a garden successful.

    Ideally we would all start off at the "big picture" level, but I question if that is really possible. Do we need to know how to garden before we can learn how to design a garden? To me it sure seems like one needs to know how to prepare a bed and grow a plant before designing a successful mixed border.

    So maybe the first principle is "just do something!"

    - Brent

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Good article. As the writer notes, you can read about a principle or technique all day long, and still not get it until you either see them in some kind of context, or are required to "use" them successfully. My design courses forced me to use various principles as part of a project or exercise to demonstrate that I understood them and had some idea of how to apply them. Just reading about it didn't supply the hockey puck.

    It's understandable why new homeowners and hobby gardeners have so much trouble using the information and advice they get on the forum. It's almost like another language sometimes.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It seems like there is a progression that gardeners go through...maybe have to go through.

    Very perceptive Brent, I agree completely. It might also have to do with relative costs at each stage. It is no big deal to blow $1.69 on a four-pak of pretty annuals or two. Perennials are pushing $5 each, trees and shrubs multiply that cost a bit (as well as the added permanence - much more intimidating than a few annuals). Then there is a huge step up to bringing in a crane and boulders (or paying a good LA) for the hardscape.

    -VW

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    BTW, below is a direct link to the "The Secret to a Beautiful Garden" article.

    "Well I remember the summer I learned the secret to creating a beautiful garden. Not just a pretty garden, but a breathtaking, heart-stopping, sensationally gorgeous garden. The secret is simple. Any gardener can put it to use. Results are assured..."

    I picked myself up a Cornus alba 'Baihalo' (Ivory Halo) on the way into work today hoping it would get me one step closer to having a beautiful garden!

    - Brent

    Here is a link that might be useful: The Secret to a Beautiful Garden

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks Brent for the link to The Secret to a Beautiful Garden. I have been trying to figure out plant groupings to give my garden that breathtaking feeling, and now I am going to start concentrating on the foliage color, size and texture.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    That is nicely done, like most of his work. The guy is gifted; I should really get over the fact that his books are geographically targeted and buy them.

    Not that my gardening is so wonderful, but foliage has always been my primary focus (had to be, as I was mostly shade gardening). (My other tic has been that I've been besotted with the idea of things that bloom at odd times rather than in spring, and so by default I seem to have action going on from January to October). But even in seeking out foliage interest, I found that I had favourites that tended to repeat themselves. I didn't have a lot of simple oval leaves as in Rhodos, for example, but an excess of maple-shaped ones, not to mention hostas and ferns. The trick is, I think, to push your comfort zone no matter how "right" it seems or how much you love it. I remember Judith Jones, Fern lady extraordinaire, saying in a presentation that waves upon waves of hostas were enough to make you nauseated if not improved by the addition of ferns :-)

    But it's funny, it is a very simple guideline that one could always offer to people who are asking how to put a shrub border together, for example, but I've always been stuck for words, and he does supply them.

    Maybe we can all retire and just refer people to his site :-)

    KarinL

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Karinl, you said, "I should really get over the fact that his books are geographically targeted and buy them."

    I live in Don's area and have read three of his books... and I have to say, you probably want to stick to reading his web site and watching for a speaking engagement held near you (he does get around the country regularly).

    I can't speak to the Landscaping with Stone book, but each of the plant books is very much a basic encyclopedia; they read like any other garden reference book. And they're very specific to zones 3-4. I don't know that someone outside of the Upper Midwest would have any use for them.

    Of course, many plants that grow in zone 3 will grow in zones 7 & 8 as well, but his focus is very strictly on those things which will do well in our Frozen Tundra winters and short summers.

    I really wish that Don would take more time during the off-season (up here, we HAVE one!) to write more about design concepts and principles. I'd be the first in line to buy a book of his with that theme.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Deeje, thank you. I think you've more correctly identified what really slowed down my "buy now" impulse. It is indeed the design concepts I'd like more of, and my "pay for what you use" ethic gets in the way of enjoying his website with a clear conscience when I do nothing to support his work. I'll watch for speaking engagements, good idea, and the stone book might do the trick for me too.

    KarinL

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Brent - Lots of good points in there. I think you are right - it takes time to put everything together. And you need to learn the gardening stuff, not just the design stuff, or you end up with a beautifully designed hardscape and dead plants. Which, I suppose, is another benefit of doing the hardscape first (at least then you have the hardscape!) - but as View West points out, it is a lot more intimidating to spend a lot of money on hardscape than a little bit of money on a few annuals.

    I know I was guilty myself of ignoring foliage for a long time. A friend of mine (architecture degree, but worked in a nursery for a long time) was the one who really pointed it out to me - I wish I could remember how he phrased it. The next year, I combined some ladysmantle with some chives, and loved the foliage contrast. Not all of my attempts have been as successful - and I'm often frustrated by catalog photos that don't show enough foliage - but I'm trying!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It is too bad that there is not just one secret and that we cannot all be master designers by reading one web page! BTW, the only Don E. book that I do own is "Stone Landscaping" and I am not real impressed. There were books at the store that looked better but I figured I would give this one a try.

    I have been thinking about the "Rule of Thirds" and maybe that I should read some of Ann Lovejoy's books. I do know that I have been happier with my garden once I started adding shrubs. I am still trying to figure out the best way to use evergreens. Do I use a background of evergreens with deciduous in front? Do I even spread out evergreen in a planting? Should I use more evergreen by my front door and more deciduous stuff on the sides?

    - Brent

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Stone Landscaping" is a fine book, but nothing spectacular. There was an interesting note on creating 'ruins' and I had not seen USDA hardiness zones applied to maps of the UK and Australia before. It does not have the wit and wisdom of the Renegade Gardener - guess BHG made him play it straight.

    I too would like to see a real guide to Renegade Gardening.

    -VW

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have had clients with good conceptual skills and many without good conceptual skills. If you have trouble imagining what your living room would look like if you rearranged the funiture then you will have trouble designing a landscape. Some peoples skills are in areas other than conceptual vision. If you have trouble picturing and imagining your final product you need to get help from someone who has the ability to conceptualize. With that said.
    Taking control of the water, as someone has stated, is first. This means establishing the grade of the final garden so that water drains where you want it.
    Along with the grading comes basic soil preparation in accordance with what will be planted where. Trees and shrubs dont require the quality of soil a perrenial garden does. Saving money by using or ammending poor soil in a perrenial or annual bed is a big mistake.
    Next would be irrigation and electrical service. Putting in your irrigation and or electrical system requires some knowledge of what the gardens final scope will be. For example, shrubs and trees are best drip irrigated and perennial beds are best over sprayed, while lawns are pop up sprayed. Once you know what basic types of plants you will place you can establish your irrigation zones and install the system.
    Lighting and electrical outlets for pond pumps etc. comes at the same time. Care needs to be taken to put lines deep where beds will be dug in.
    As someone has stated, small beds are big trouble. Skinny little beds will often end up with tall things growing in them that throw your whole garden out of perspective. When you are imagining your finished garden, imagine what it will look like at different stages in its life.
    When first planted that blue spruce is so cute and wonderfully proportioned. When this spruce is 20 feet tall it will be squished up under the eaves of your home and the side against the house is dead and you cant paint behind it. All the cute little things you planted with it have been choked out or shaded to death you will want to cut your spruce tree down. But you wont cut it down untill it has annoyed you for several years.
    As you drive around, look at all things people planted 20 years ago and see how many of them no longer belong where they are. You will be amazed.
    Another way to think of the "thirds" concept is to imagine the depth of your beds in thirds. The back third will have the tallest plants and they will get progressively shorter toward the front. In perennial beds a good rule of thumb is to avoid planting things that will be taller than one third the depth of the bed. There are always exceptions to any rule but it is a good idea to start out with the "thirds" concept in mind.
    Avoid planting in rows if you can. Stagger your plants, especially if they are repeated in great numbers. A row of a particular shrub 10 feet appart with staggered smaller plants in between can do wonders to add uniformity without seeming to be redudndant. I enjoy a foundation of repeat plantings with controlled chaos in between. Typed out for now, hope this is useful.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've enjoyed this thread.

    We are presently building a garage and the destruction required to site it has made me blanche more than a few times. The grove of trees and understory plants that shielded us from a very popular tourist drive is now gone completely. And will never be again. Poof! gone.

    Nandina has pointed out something I feel is critically important... the cost of the "solution". Had we acted on a garage 5 yrs. ago we could have sited it much closer to the road and avoided the drainage (water control! Pls8xx!) issues that have only added to the cost of the project. Set-backs, ordinances, and zoning change in all communities... wish we'd been less involved with "life" and paid more attention to it!

    "Shoestring" budgets constain people. It did us, when we built. We needed shelter and that's about all we got. ;) But it was easily affordable shelter and we were patient and able to sit back and study/"inventory" what we had available. We didn't try to save every tree, neither did we level every one of them. In the ensuing years, we've taken more down as it's suited us.

    The very first garden was "built" around native ferns and spring ephemerals, and then some Hosta. Moist, shady locations do rather underscore the importance of leaves, Karinl! :) The "spine" of large rocks behind that bed was a way to use something that was excavated from the foundation hole and would have cost money to truck away.

    And the first thing we did to "add some color" was put windowboxes on the house. They are "high maintenance", but they're a lot of fun, too. And everyone knows which house is our's when we say, "windowboxes".

    I've nodded my head repeatedly reading the replies above. Thanks for a good read.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I found link below interesting, in terms of basic landscape design principles. I was curious, though, if there are some general rules of thumb in terms of how form, line, or texture work together.

    For example, do columnar and weeping forms work well together? And in terms of foliage, which textures and shapes work well with, say, the needlike silver foliage of blue oat grass or the smooth texture of a succulent?

    To put it another way, in terms of the foliage and texture thing, it is all green to me. :-)

    Here is a link that might be useful: Basic Principles

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    swanoir: If there are general rules, then I don't know them. I wanted to point out a very good book that the "lady formally known as mich_in_zonal_denial" recommended:

    Architectural Foliage: Shape, Form and Texture of Foliage Plants in Garden Design by Jill Billington

    The book might be out of print, but I got a used copy for $8 including delivery. It is a short book but it does touch on the idea of combining foliage shapes together to create pleasing combinations. It would be a great book if it covered the topic in more depth and devoted less time recommending specific plants that grow in England.

    - Brent

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've decided to add my 2 cents to this thread since no one has mentioned an important principle when designing a garden and that is...don't bite off more than you can chew!!! And I say that because that's what I did and I'm working so hard to maintain the areas that I've landscaped that I haven't really had time to enjoy them. Every area or bed that you landscape requires weeding, mulching, mowing, trimming, protection from critters and pests, etc. Make sure you take the proper steps in preparing your garden to minimize the maintenance so you can sit back and enjoy the beautiful flowers, trees and foliage you have worked so hard to create.

    And Tyhawk has made a very good point, that before you start planting, make sure you have amended the soil and have proper irrigation to sustain what you're planting, otherwise you will be taking one step forward and two steps backward to attain the look and feel that you set out to achieve.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I great book that has helped me is The Well-Designed Mixed Garden-by Tracy Disabato-Aust. It talks about color, texture and form. Design principles, winter interest and a ton of other info. It takes you step by step in creating a garden with trees, shrubs, perennials, annuals and bulbs. One of the best design books I have read.

    This is a great topic, thanks for the Renegade Gardener site, i have never heard of him before.

    Brat

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    So much good reading, so many good links, so little time.. this needs to be bumped up where I can find it to continue. There are very useful ideas/concepts that others new to this forum also may enjoy.

    Crystal

Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County