Software
Houzz Logo Print
lilyny621

help fix this mess

20 years ago

From the photo you can't really get a full view, but the front of our house is a mess. Since it is a new construction, our landscaping is nonexistent. Our house is set in a bank on a hill and there is a huge retaining wall which you can see in the picture. We are trying to figure out what to put on this hill so that it looks nicer. We are thinking of adding a little more fill but it is so costly that we are leaning against it. Comments, suggestions?{{gwi:30888}}

Comments (38)

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Just found a better photo from a distance...don't mind my little one..
    {{gwi:30890}}

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well, I'd get some grass or something planted while you figure out what else to do, at least to prevent erosion.

    If you read through some of the other threads on this forum, you'll see that your question is not a simple one.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Do you mean the concrete retaining wall to the left of the house, and the slope above it, or the stone retaining wall in front of the house?

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am talking about the whole picture, pretty much. We were talking about getting some fill to level out and moving the retaining wall further up to border the driveway and then curve around the front again. This is getting to be such an eyesore that DH and I can't stand looking at it anymore.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My uncle had a parcial of land much like this one and he ended up moving the retaining wall to border the drive and raised the retaining wall a little to level the land some to make mowing and planting easier. He also widened the front porch and added stairs leading down from the front porch through the retaining wall to add curb appeal. Obvioulsy this is a very expensive option. I suggest to lay sod down to help and probably purchase a few evergreen bushes to help soften the look of the house. You can also plant a groundcover to drape over the retaining wall.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    There have discussions about "foundation planting" on this forum with some agreement that not all houses need a blanket of shrubs to ground the house to the lot, HOWEVER, your home is certainly an instance where foundation planting would be highly desirable.

    Did you tell us where you live or what direction the house faces?

    My first instinct, because your house seems like it is in the woods, is to include some laurel and rhodendrons. You are in the lucky position of not having to get dwarf hybrids but can go for the ones that will get large and lovely.

    Also, I think some creeping juniper, or juniper blue star would be helpful and interesting looking. (I recently fell in love with the combination of pink rhodies and blue star juniper, so they are on my mind.)

    Obviously sheared hedges would like very odd and also, I don't think you want too much in the way of flowering trees either. Meadowy type flowers in the sunny spots and woodland types in the shady spots would be nice.

    Patty

    Here is a link that might be useful: website with some possibly appropriate plants

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Oh my goodness! You have my fantasy property! I would love to have that house and land! I'm not sure where you are from but, if that house was in Canada, it could easily be in the east coast where I am originally from and it would be considered Loyalist style (colonial Georgian style that came with refugees from the American Revolution - loyal to the British 'Crown', hence Loyalist....

    I'm totally non-pro but the image that immediately came into my head includes the folowing for house and grounds:
    - dark shutters - black or a darker gray than the house;
    - use masonary paint to paint that exposed foundation wall in as close a color gray as you can find to the siding color;
    - the red door is perfect but porch needs a gray floor and white railings
    - the woods along the driveway chock full of things like ferns of various sorts, Solomon's Seal, wild ginger, tiarella, trilliums, trout lilies, wild rhododendrons(Rhododendron canadense), serviceberries, redbuds, dogwood
    - bluets (Houstonia caerulea) in those rocks along with small ferns, bunchberries and mosses and lichens that will, no doubt, appear on their own
    - grass on the lawn - if you can grow it - looks like it's going to be very shady when those trees leaf out...
    - some big, old fashioned shrubs near the house - lilacs, mockorange, bridalwreath spireas
    - bluberries on the edge of the lawn/border of the woods
    - something to drape over the edge of the retaining wall - maybe Virginia Creeper or a honeysuckle vine allowed to trail rather than climb

    I've included a link to the Loyalist House in my home town so you can see why I called your house that style .

    Here is a link that might be useful: Loyalist House, Saint John, NB

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    OK so I think you're talking more about the front than the side when you say "eyesore." Seems to me you have two choices, basically: redo the rock wall to match the roadway and then plant above it, or leave the wall as it is and plant on top, beside, and below it.

    Obviously, if you can afford it or enjoy back breaking work - and who doesn't? - you could certainly redo the wall, moving/extending it as you say. That would look lovely. But if you want quicker results, then try the easier option: just plant around it as it is.

    A little creeping/spreading stuff beside and below the wall, with some upright and some draping stuff above it, should look great.

    The nice thing about doing that is that you get quick relief from the eyesore, and yet don't eliminate the option of redoing the whole thing at a later date. You could even select plants now with an expectation that the wall will eventually be moved/redone, and plant in such a way that bigger shrubs, for example, won't have to be moved to do that work.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You are unable to improve this situation without an investment of energy and money.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My amateur opinion--

    I see an immense (7 foot plus?) wall in the back of the photos and it certainly looks like it needs attention. Is this the concrete wall you mention? Also, there is the stone wall in front of the home and photo. The main thing that strikes me about the stone wall is that its height appears insufficient because there seems to be additional steep slope even above the height of the wall. This situation might be improved with terracing so you can really contain the entire slope.

    The wall in the back--maybe creepers and hangers planted on top the wall and backed by shorter shrubs and a row of taller screening plants located in front of the wall--if you have enough space.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Not sure if this is "proper" and I am just a homeowner that does not know a think about landscaping, but a home near us with similar property has a row of arborviate on a raised mound bed on that wall in the background.
    Then another home very near to us has lots of differen flowers creeping down over that stone wall in the front. It looks pretty charming. I'd definately get some grass or sod in though and that might make it feel like less of an eyesore. ??? Like I said. I know not a thing. Just what I see around.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Does anyone else see the house itself as a bigger immediate "eyesore" than the walls? By eyesore, I don't mean the house is ugly or a problem, but that it looks like you haven't finished it , what with of the unfinished deck combined with your siding and trim (unless you had hoped that a weathered natural gray deck will in the future look better, which it might), and the concrete foundation. rodgersia mentioned some of these things and also the sod ideas noted are related.

    I guess that it's possible that foundation planting around house might be dependent on some of the other slope and wall issues, but if not, then it would seem that you would focus on the deck, the foundation plantings and maybe just turf for now on the slope, unless you are ready to hire out a complete package doing everything at once. Then you could expand outward from the house and tackle wall(s), backdrop plantings, ornamental stuff.

    The entry deck itself seems wrong for the house but obviously put there to quickly solve the entry problem. That's something you might budget for tackling later. On the other hand, if planted and painted it might end up going pretty well.

    (I do sometimes focus on houses when the question was landscaping).

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks for the comments and suggestions. This is a new construction, and no, the house is definitely not a finished product. We are planning to build a front porch, add Fypon trim, possibly shutters, and add a garage. I know the house needs work. But right now we are focused on the lawn and landscaping. The decks are temporary since we ran out of money. I need a quick, cheap fix that can at least improve the appearance somewhat so we can save some money for the bigger projects.
    The wall in the back is a huge undertaking and we have already had estimates of up to $20,000 just for a retaining wall and plantings. I would love to do something about it but we just can't hack it right now.
    Our taxes just went up by $2,000 so we are trying to crunch some numbers right now. We just found this out over the weekend so we are NOT happy at all.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Another possibility besides grass for erosion protection would be mulch. The cheapest source for this in my area is the local municipal landfill. They take everyones yard waste and do heavy duty composting. This material is available free to residents. If that isn't an option in your area, try pricing various mulches from different sources. With a layer of this in place - you can interplant shrubs or perennials etc in pockets and let these spread out. It looks like you've already got some good-sized trees around you - so I would refrain from planting anything that gets too big right around your home. Try going grass free - it is more ecological - just create paths. Make a sandbox for your child to play in.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Back again for more suggestions! We did spend $3,000 on some soil to fill in a huge area on the side yard so we could plant grass. Now I am looking for some other things I can do with a limited budget.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Maybe you can say where you live, what zone, sun exposure?

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You have gotten some pretty good responses so far, especially considering the scale of your project and the limited information you have provided. To me it looks like your problems started a long time ago and they will not be fixed by free advice from a forum. If your lot needed $50k in site improvements, then that should have been determined early in the project and included into the overall budget. Did you consult with a landscape architect during the design phase?

    - Brent

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I think Brent hits the nail on the head here. I have been speechless since I saw your renewed request as I cannot think of anything to say that has not already been said in the thread. Why not just act on some of the suggestions already made? Or do something entirely different (which you did), and then present the forum with a new set of variables to work with? Could you at least post a photo of the property with the new soil and lawn in place?

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If Brent had not already said it, I would. Your best investment would be to have at minimum a consultation with a landscape architect or landscape designer who has experience with grading, drainage and retaining/stone wall design. At this point anything more you do without the benefit of some on site expertise and experience may cost you much more later.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I and the other posters here are not trying to be rude, just honest. A search of the forums shows that you have asked similar questions on a couple threads. Below is a link to one of them where you note that your house is adjacent to wetlands. I notice that the two responses to that thread were the same general theme...consult a professional (and I will add that they should not have a title like "Jim and Bob's Excavating").

    BTW, I sure hope that $3,000 worth of fill is not going to smother any of your trees and I also hope that you added a layer of quality topsoil.

    - Brent

    Here is a link that might be useful: I need serious help w/landscaping!

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lylyny: I feel you took an unecessary pounding by some of the posters on this forum.
    People say the darndest things when they don't have to look you in the eye. I think people were a bit unkind here (and I am understating on purpose to avoid turning the crowd onto myself; although it may be too late to prevent that from happening).
    You asked for advice in a forum where people ask for advice. You asked for advice on a forum where LOTS of people fancy themselves experts, and where some clearly are. People spend time and effort into thinking through the landscaping/gardening problems of others, and they seem to enjoy presenting themselves as people who know more than most of us mortals do. In other words- they sound like experts, act like experts, post the way I suppose experts would post, and then when you call them an expert they get their backs up and tell you to go out and hire an expert.
    Which brings me to another point: Who has the money to hire all these professionals? I cerainly don't, what with my advanced degrees and years of professional experience. If it wasn't for IKEA, we wouldn't have any furniture. (I may drool over DWR, but I buy IKEA). Who can afford a landscape expert?
    I want to know! I have enough trouble affording to pay someone to do yard clean ups in the fall and spring.
    I'm sorry you were run off by a bunch of people who don't like to take responsibility for how their behavior and words make others feel. Unfortunately, the world is filled with them. And the internet brings them out.
    People are blunt and curt and, well, they can quite frankly, be cruel.
    When someone says, "I don't mean to hurt you....." or "I don't mean to be rude....." that usually means that they are about to say something rude or hurtful. I know. I've done it myself.
    Imagine........asking for free advice on a forum where people write questions asking for free advice! What were you thinking???
    Now I will brace myself for the responses to this posting.
    Reading these responses to your posts made me cringe. Like Bill Clinton has been known to say, "I feel your pain."
    It is not pleasant getting a lecture (even if it anonymous) from a bunch of know it alls.
    I'm starting to repeat myself (I once was blasted on a forum for repeating myself) and it is the middle of the night but I felt I just wanted to extend a human hand and do my part to make the world a little bit better.

    Or are you just really an undeserving, manipulating, unworthy person who is using us for your own evil purposes??????????????? (A joke, just in case my middle of the night humor is not very funny or self-evident).

    P.S. If I wasn't so tired I'd stay up and search other forums to see if you've posted any questions on them, as well. Imagine. People asking questions on these forums. This has got to stop!

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    emmagloria: I think it really must have been late and you must have been very tired to write a post like that. In the rational light of day maybe you will see that the only "cruel" post on this thread was your own. You have really ripped into some posters who were just trying to help.

    Think about most of the questions on this site. They are things like what can I do to improve the curb appeal of my house, or how can I screen a view that I don't want to see. People make suggestions for shrubs, maybe a tree or two perhaps moving a path. So what do you invest in this free advice, four bucks apiece for gallon shrubs or you splurge and pay thirteen for five gallon size. Maybe a box tree that you pay a hundred fifty for. You end up not liking the free advice and are out a couple of hundred bucks and have to dig out some shrubs.

    Now imagine some bad advice happens to this OP. Maybe someone doesn't understand the complete situation and who can from a photo. Maybe they are not expert in landscape grading. OP can end up with drainage - we know it's wet with a wetlands thirty feet behind the house - into the house ruining the foundation and costing 50 thousand to repair. This is why the posters are encouraging the OP to get information from someone who is qualified and can visit the site in person and give constructive advice that won't potentially damage the house.

    If they didn't want to help they just would have not posted. Nothing easier than that and from other posts I've seen from them they do try to be helpful.

    Maria

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lilyny621, are you looking for draingage advice, for landscape plant and layout suggestions, or for both?

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    One more thought: For professional help, without the professional help price you might try posting on Craig's list (or somewhere) asking for a professional who will give you an hour or two (or three) as a consultant.
    I did this type of thing with a house I am flipping, when I was at my wit's end over how to proceed with reconfiguring the house. My partner and I weren't sure whether we should add on, move up, etc. I met with an architect (who had assured me that he would be able to work with me within my budget of $30,000, and then not only gave me $100,000 ideas and suggestions, but sent me a letter with a price breakdown of each step of the process that was so out of my price range that working with him was out of the quesiton).
    I contacted a contractor who had done some work for us, and I knew had also flipped houses, and I asked him if he would work with me as a consultant.
    He met with me for two hours, walked through the house, measured, checked out plumbing, etc., and then gave me a comprehensive rundown of what HE would do if it were his house to flip and he were working within my budget.
    It was the best $250 I ever spent!
    I also hired his firm to do some of the work!
    So it worked for both of us, and quite frankly, I think he enjoyed the consulting work.
    If he hadn't agreed, I would have gone onto Craig's list looking for someone else.
    I also found out that he used an architect when he needed to submit plans, but in the same way I had hired him. Instead of using one throughout the whole process he'd simply contract out to have this professional draw up the plans he needed.
    There are people out there who are experienecd professionals who might be more affordable than we know, if we know what to ask for.
    Here, in the NY area, contstruction costs are quite high, and $30,000 does not stretch very far.
    We also once hired a contractor who had just gotten his license and we were his first "big" job. He did amazing cabinetmaking and fine wookworking, but he was eager to do a job where he did the contracting. (I knew his wife well).
    He insisted that his prices for kitchen cabinets could come close to matching IKea's prices. I showed him pics of a Martha Stewart kitchen cabinet (from an old book of hers) and he essentially made them for us! We may have actually paid him too little for the kitchen, but he also did other work for us over the years. We have an amazing built-in bookshelf that lines the entire wall of our living room (and never fails to get "oohs and ahs" when people walk into our home). He also got lots of other work through us.
    You might say we took a risk hiring him. He was licensed, I had seen his carpentry work, we bought a wreck of a house, and our tastes ran much higher than our budget. New professionals, straight out of school often need the jobs as much as we need them. I once called the Pratt Institute and was given the names of three recent grads (architects) who might be able to help me with some structural changes I had in mind. I ended up paying for plans that I never used, but clearly these new grads had more experienced people around them who were willing to assist them with their ideas. Most of us CAN'T afford the mouth-watering work we see in shelter and landscape magazines. We have to be creative, and willing to work hard. Hence, so many DIYers. I've always been a crafty person, but I've forced myself to learn other things, as well, like laying tile. Now, I'm trying to learn some landcaping basics because I don't have the money to hire someone to do it for me.
    Sometimes, the line between being a profesional and a lay-person is blurry.
    I've been trained as a hypnotherapist. My training was long and comprehensive. However, people can learn to hypnotize themselves, as well.
    I give people tips and ideas about how to use these techniques when I'm not around. There are many books out there, as well, that offer wonderful and sound advice.
    I hope at some point in time we will see your "after" pics.
    Lots of luck to you.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    WOW what drama. I have to agree with emmagloria by saying that I was kind of put off by the responses I got...yes I understand I have asked this before but I figured- why not, maybe there are new opinions and new people to advise me on what to do here.
    Anyway, I do plan on taking some additional photos with the grass now planted. Hopefully we can start our landscaping project next spring, but yes, there is a huge financial factor involved.
    We did have someone from a reputable landscaping company take a look at our property and he quoted us some ridiculous amounts. Just for a retaining wall it was going to run around $20,000. We can't just put all of our money into a stone wall- the entire scope of this project is huge and we need to attack the whole picture, not just one aspect.
    I will try and get some new pictures up by tomorrow for those of you interested in giving advice and opinions. Those of you that are not, don't click on my post.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    emmagloria: Thanks for contributing in your own way. I will admit that I find your two posts very hard to follow. About the only advice that I see in there focused on the original poster is to follow your lead and...pay a professional for a consultation...and that "$30,000 does not stretch very far".

    "Who has the money to hire all these professionals?" If I was investing a huge chunk of my income into creating a home for my family to live, you are darn right I would consult a qualified professional!

    - Brent (who, for the record, is not an expert)

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Brent, You said, "If I were investing....creating a home for my family to live" and Emmagloria was talking about "Flipping" which is in my opinion a nasty process that unnaturally drives up the cost of homes by reselling them over and over for profit, until prices are inflated beyond reason.(disallowing many from ever achieving the dream of a little home of thier own) It seems like you are speaking from the point of view of one who is making a little slice of happiness and Eden for the family. Emmagloria is speaking from the point of view of one who makes money no matter what the cost to society. I wouldnt feel bad, or take her little critique very much to heart.

    Most of us will spend what we can or must to keep our homes and grounds in safe livable (Pleasant) condition, and do the rest ourselves as a matter of course.

    I can think of several ideas that would be sort of cool with what the OP has to work with , but as everyone else has said, if you dont really know what the site is like, as far as climate, water,(how you will keep it watered, REALISTICLY) etc, then its sort of a moot point.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Where are you? No, not exact location, but planting zone, in an area tht has zoning, building codes, or way out in the boonies where you can do anything you want? (At your own risk.) That info will haelp posters answer your questions.

    Did you build the house or buy it? If you built it did you do any soil tests and borings before hand? Did you do any research on the property? Was the site ever mined? Surface or deep? That is an issue where I live. From your posted picture it appears that you fell in love with a pretty wooded hill site and didn't do any deep thinking about the ramifications of building on a side of a hill. Hopefully all you have is landscaping aesthetic issues. I keep hearing the old Paul Simon song in my head: "Slip sliding away"

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm new to this forum (this is my first post), and I am by no means an expert, but do have my own nightmare of a yard. (It makes yours look like nothing if thats any consolation) I am not making suggestions, but I think anyone in this type of situation needs to answer some questions for themselves. Some that come to mind are:
    1. Do you like plants themselves or what they can do for your house? If you are only interested in what they can do for your house, research some categories,- shrubs, perinnals, annuals - choose a few low maintence and use them everywhere. Fill in with various annuals in the summer. If you like plants then have a ball exploring your options!
    2. Are you one to change things or work with what you have? I would keep the wall where it is, others would obvoiously move it. Where do you fall?
    3. What hits you in the face when you drive up to your house? I have found that although it might not follow offical advice, making some changes out of order that make me feel better, goes along way to making things more bearable.
    4. Are you going to plan it all out or have a profesional do it - or are you more of an "evolving" designer who plans as they go? Try to make some informed decisions, but don't be afraid to "just do it" Granted you end up working around some "Wish I had thought that through!" mistakes, but if that is your nature, than so be it. Remember - Layering is the key to hiding mistakes. :)
    5. Lastly, know that most people are in their houses 15 years before it gets to the point they envisioned when they moved in. Take a deep breath, enjoy the little one, and think of your yard as a gym membership. Exercise in the outdoors - what more can you ask for?

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Brent:
    Thanks for your kind and helpful words.
    Sorry if I wasn't clear.
    Tell me exactly what you didn't follow and I'll be happy to explain.
    In NY $30,000, if you're INCREDIBLY frugal, might allow you to renovate a kitchen and a bathroom. If you are dealing with a fixer-upper like we are, that doesn't get you very far.


    Re: "flipping". I think I might be using the wrong word here. We are doing a thorough renovation of a home that had been on the market for quite a long time. We are upgrading and improving and enjoying an adorable but neglected house. One day the bell rang and there stood an 80 year old man who had spent time in the house as a little boy (his grandfather owned the house then). It is near a lake and since the house is on an elevation it was known as "Goat Hill." He was kind enough to send us a wonderful picture of the house being built over 70 years ago!

    We are bringing a lovely little neglected house back to it's former and rightful "glory," and we will either use it ourselves as a summer house, or sell it to a very lucky family.

    (For Brent: Thanks also for contributing in your own special way to this forum. We are all unique).

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This thread is a very important thread to read. It started out with a big house on a big lot. The house was sited by cutting into a hillside on the back and filling in front of the house. The concept is OK, but the entire set of issues that this thread is about is resolving the issues caused by the siting of the house, or more to the point, the lack of a thorough plan that calculated and showed how exactly the site would be finished. The concept of the plan may have been alright, but it was not thorough in resolving how the entire site would be finished.

    The problem started by avoiding the investment in professional planning. Yes, two or three thousand dollars is a lot of money. But now the project is dealing with a $20,000 wall in the back yard just to stabilize the site. It is entirely possible that some retaining would be necessary to site any house in that position, but there are more methods that can be used to site a house and designing a house for a particular site than were used here.

    This looks like the result of having a house plan, buying a lot, and having a builder and excavator site it. I'm not saying this was the case, but it really looks like it. It looks that way by noticing what is resolved and what is not. The plan created a place to build a house and access to building it. It did not do anything else to function as a home.

    I think it would do some good to invest (not spend) money into some professional planning that can lead the way in resolving all of the problems not addressed, or at least not thought through in the original plan. The best you are going to get from a few paragraphs on an internet discussion messageboard is an understanding that you will not get simple cheap fixes to situations such as this. Hopefully, that is what you got.

    This thread is more important for folks who have not yet made the same mistake by not having thorough planning. Hopefully, they will understand that a few thousand not spent will often result with a mess that will require several thousand to make it a stable mess.

    This is a coherent discussion and not a personal attack.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Who has the money to hire all these professionals?"

    I think Laag points out something which probably should have come up a lot more during this thread (but surprisingly didn't). People talk very much about the price of hiring landscaping experts, but sometimes neglect to take into account the price of not hiring an expert. I'm definitely no expert on the matter, but when it comes to large retaining walls holding back large amounts of soil, there can be large problems if things are not done well.

    I'm not implying that there may be problems in the future with your retaining walls (I don't know enough on the matter), but I am asking you to try and consider all of the factors involved. $20 000 is a significant amount to spend and does require careful thought, and hesitation is a natural response. I can't say that it's a bad thing, because it's much better to be more critical about the people you're hiring, what they propose to do, etc. etc. than to spring for the first firm willing to do the job.

    -Audric

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I haven't participated in this thread for a number of reasons. First is the vast difference in climate, which comes in to play because of the depth of ground frost with regard to hardscape. What might work for retaining walls and other hardscape in Arkansas might be a distaster in NY.

    Second is the type of advice sought. To me, it seems that
    the homeowner is asking for a planting scheme that will correct the basic hardscape deficiencies. I doubt that any such animal exists. If installing a few plants could solve grade, drainage, function, and aesthetic problems, the pros would go broke for lack of work.

    Moreover, any work done before the hardscape issues have been dealt with is likely to be lost, ripped out in the new construction, should the real fix ever be implemented.

    I would echo the advice to seek proffessional help to develope a plan, but some people just don't have the money to take that route. I am a big fan of DIY, but few are prepared to spend the time to get it done right. The pros are efficent and might spend 20 to 30 hours developing a plan for this property. Without the pro's knowledge and resources, a homeowner might take five times as long to duplicate what a pro does, and the effort would span several months.

    It's all very sad. The best I can say of the situation is that the homeowner will find it easier to live with as the months and years pass.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Even with respect to the current poster's problems, there are another couple of ways to analyze it. Since the problem is a major site issue, that's why just more photos and more discussion won't result in the the homeowner learning what to buy, install, in what order, and so forth, from this forum. So only a more thorough evaluation of the site directly can answer these questions. For example, you couldn't send these photos to ANY experto, I don't care how expert and experienced, and get the answers that the poster needs, either (meaning, what, where, how much--not accurately, anyway). So the first problem comes from trying to avoid working with real people in person because a real person or persons, in person, are needed to identify the work to be done. One way to save, possibly, money is if you have access to real, qualified people who will work for less or no money--friends, relatives, swap jobs, etc. I'm not proposing that as a guarantee, I'm just identifying the issue. Another way is for the homeowner to "become" qualified since, by definition, she/he is on site. All over America, people learn skills and tackle jobs. Here, the skills involve aspects of site analysis, engineering, drainage, materials, purchasing and installation. Go for it. Again, I'm not suggesting that will work, just pointing out that you do save money by DIY but you have to identify what it is you must do yourself.

    That's why there's so much advice as to investing in an overview analysis EVEN though it would consume $$ that one might think should be spent on an actual "project" itself, because with the correct overview analysis, then one can begin to decide, hmm, this one I might be able to do myself, this one I will bid out, this one I will do in 5 year, this one will just never happen. So then one would put one's efforts and energy into researching who might be the best person or firm to give this analysis. That speaks to the concern about the $20k retaining wall and the statement, we have to tackle the whole mess. Well, you might not be able to tackle the whole mess, ever, for your budget--I would say that most people can't ever get their whole mess under control, under budget! That's why it's key to be able to really discuss which items might be needed structurally, which are cosmetic, what are in fact realistic costs. That's how people make decisions to come up with the best "cost-benefit" for them.

    I'll add that I believe that while $$ is a big limiting factor for many if not most people in hiring professionals, I would wager that for many people there is a great fear and insecurity of working with various professionals outside of our own fields--fear of getting wrong one, fear of how to work with someone, getting ripped off, how to be assertive but not offensive, then the whole idea of doing that 3 times to get multiple bids. That's my story and I admit it. I often just feel so inhibited about how to find someone to do ANYTHING. I finally found a person who does good remodeling type work and then he retired, and I feel just stymied on projects that need to be done. And I've put off talking with landscape designers for the same reasons. So there.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I guess one thing I was trying to get at, but didn't very well, is an area in which I would need advice here if it were my situation, might be not just, hire a professional, but some more of the specifics (akin to the frequent question: "LA or LD?") about what is the type of person or firm I am looking for, is it typically a LA or is it found under various other types of firms by other names, how it might be advertised, how to check credentials, what am I actually asking for (terminology, since I dunno it--site analysis? site plan? ) are there different levels (depths) of site plans, what kinds of fees to expect for the site plan (I know these may be too variable), what are the warning signs of wrong person, what kind of self-education would make me a better consumer in hiring and working with such a person while not trying to be the professional myself. These types of things would help me.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    FOR THE FILL: How about calling local excavators (those contracted by your city for road repairs etc are a good bet) for free fill. My husband works construction and we've had his company bring all soil from excavation projects to our new property to assist with the mess of leveling the property off (there's portions that have to be raised and leveled by two feet!). Some of the dirt was very poor quality and we had to pull pieces of black top out of it, but it WAS free, delivered, and dumped for us - all we had to do was push it around and level it out! It worked to level the place (3/4 of an acre) off. We still have to bring in top soil which we are budgeting for now, and I have been colelcting shrubs, trees, perenials and other items for the last year to put in once I get the place ready. For now everything is sitting in pots around the property - arranged into temporary "gardens" so that from a distance it does look like I have gardens and landscaping, and walls and unfinished projects are hidden from view by potted trees.

    For your project - Grass definitely a must for erosion control and give your little girl a place to play. Beyond that go slow, be patient for the results, and plan carefully. Rome wasn't built in a day, and can you imagine how disppointing the pyramids were to look at for the years and years before they were finished? Look at them now - people come from all around the world just to stare in wonder. Start small, and try not to get discouraged by the time it will undoubtedly take.

    For our wall I used trailers like indian strawberry (tasteless, fast spreading strawberry like plant) which has filled up fast but is now slightly out of control - the bunnies in our neighborhood however love me for them! There's also things like passionflower and countless other vines that people normally have climb UP a trellis - have them climb ALONG the wall instead.

    With a new construction things are never going to be finished and pretty right away. Start by collecting small plants, cuttings, immature trees (I started last spring and now have over 250 plants, vines and fruit trees and stayed completely within budget by just doing a few things a week, although it is tough to walk out of a nursery with 3 plants when I really want to get all 300something right then!) I also learnt how to make cuttings and have grown tons of stuff from 4-8 inch cuttings I snipped off my friends, parents, and neighbors plants. The plants are small but I get far more for my money, and with time I will fill in more space with more plants, rather than having very few, very big trees. I'd spend $5 for a 3 foot tree rather than $40 for a 6-7 foot tree - and come out of the nursery (or home depot) with 10 things instead of 2 or 3. It will seem like things are not filled in, and not the look you want, BUT you can do 4 times the work for the same money, and in 2 growing seasons it will look like you really wanted it. If you try to get the whole thing perfect right away you will run out of money fast. It's disappointing to look at a property and house and have it not be your dream vision you were hoping for - man do I EVER know that - but sometimes you just have to force yourself to go it slowly and be patient for the perfection that will eventually come...

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Laag offers the professional point of view and it is a view I agree with, what we have here is a remedial problem and mistakes have already been made. "Who has the money to employ professionals?" is such a silly question, "the dog I love is sick, the clutch on my truck needs fixing, my house is in danger of slipping down the hill." You want some kind of landscaping around your house that looks like it might have a problem with, in non technical terms: moving down the slope and adding $3000.00 worth of fill dirt up there seemed like a good idea? Will a $20,000.00 retaining wall hold up the garden and the house? if so it is money well spent. For heavens sake spend the $300.00 it would probably cost for a LA to come out there to give you some advice. It makes me ill to see this kind of crap and to be criticised for pointing it out.

  • 20 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Don't be afraid to call a Civil Engineer's office and explain the situation. One might come out and have a look at it. This is more of a site design issue than a landscape planting issue. The planting advice can come from a lot of sources like this board. That is fine and of low risk.

    A good civil in your area almost certainly has dealt with the same problems at other sites, knows the solutions, can recommend qualified contractors, and will most likely have some relatively inexpensive methods of dealing with some of your problems. If not, you might get pointed in the right direction for a local person to deal with this.

    Its has to be worth dialing the phone to find out. That is eleven key strokes on the phone vs. what I just did to suggest it. Not too difficult.

Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH