Software
Houzz Logo Print
huttnem

How bad would this be to do?

16 years ago

I have a 27" pot and planted a rose in it. I want to plant companions in it too and realized I didn't fill the container with enough soil. I could add another 2 inches so it is filled just under the lip. Instead of repotting the entire rose how bad would it be to simply add 2 inches of potting soil to this pot? When I have planted roses high in the ground, they end up sinking down after some time so was hoping the container situation would not be a problem. Tia, Marlene

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago

    Not good. Fastest way to kill a plant. You'd have to repot and place it in the proper depth.

  • 16 years ago

    Thank you, Kate. Can you explain why/how it could actually kill this rose? I ask because I had posted this question on the Rose Forum as well and got the opposite opinion! Both of you seem confident so now I don't know what to do...

  • 16 years ago

    I added 1" mix to 3 tomato plants in 5gallon pots about 3 weeks ago.

    they seem OK; guess I was lucky; .

    yours would be about a 20 gallon pot?

    d

  • 16 years ago

    Not sure how many gallons, col_sprg. But it's a large pot about 27-30" across and about 2 feet tall. Glad you had success adding more soil. In the ground, roses I originally planted high have sunk a lot with time and sometimes below the surrounding soil level. But a pot planting may be different so I am wondering why some think this is a bad practice.

  • 16 years ago

    In general terms, burying the root system in more soil more deeply than is natural is something akin to smothering the root system. It is NEVER recommended when planting in the soil (in situ), but can probably be forgiven in container culture.

    Root systems behave differently in the completely artificial environment of a container, partly because of the make-up of the planting medium as well as the limitations of the container itself.

  • 16 years ago

    Tomatoes and peppers can be buried deeply, and roots will emerge from the nodes.
    When transplanting peppers, for instance, I always bury the node from which the
    cotyledons (seed leaves) emerged. Some bury their plants 2 - 3 nodes deep even.

    With the woody plants, the bark adapts to the dry conditions above soil.
    If you then bury the woody trunk, moisture will soften and compromise the trunk,
    leading to pathogen pathways - rot, mold, fungus, infection.

    Josh

  • 16 years ago

    Planting a rose deep is a common cultural practice and depends on whether the rose is grafted to some extent. The rose will not suffer at all if it's stems are buried unless it is a variety that tends to be weak and fussy, in which case if it's overwatered there is a slim chance it will rot. Often roses are grafted onto a rootstock with an interscion forming a stem in between. When you pile wet soil against this you're encouraging it to root and make it's own growth, pesky to trim off and it might reject the bush that has been grafted onto it eventually. Many rose growers will take a new grafted plant and plant it deeply intentionally to encourage the top to develop it's own roots, growing into a larger more robust plant in most cases. The rootstock, in the case of many roses, is there to keep the plant's growth in check, not to keep it alive. Almost all roses will readily put out roots along their stems if soil is mounded over them. I imagine there are some fussy exceptions, but I've planted everything from hyb teas to miniatures this way, due to a long period of summer drought in my area, and they all seemed to appreciate being planted deeply, often far too much, resulting sometimes in rampant growth the following years. In a pot it shouldn't be an problem.

  • 16 years ago

    Thank you, Zandra. Same time I posted this question to this forum I also did to the Rose forum. Some people there thought it would be fine to top the container with more soil but I was concerned about the contrary opinions I got here. I'm more confident about doing this now after your post!

  • 16 years ago

    Not exactly your situation but not completely different.

    A few years ago I had two rose bushes in the wrong places that I wanted to move. I dug them out, going down close to a foot. Then in the yard, I dug holes close to 18" deep and put them in those. Then I built boxes around them and added another 4" of potting mix. The plants went through a bit of transplant shock (expected) and then completely recovered.

    Burying part of the stem that was previously above ground did not cause any problems.

    Mike