Software
Houzz Logo Print
eric62687

beer and slugs

16 years ago

Slugs are eating my seedlings and I don't like using pecesticides on plants that I'm going to be eating. I heard from a friend that beer kills snails and slugs so I poured some beer in an old dust pan and set it out in my garden. During the night there where several baby slugs and a few adults there for the party. I checked it in the morning expecting to find dead slugs but I only found the dust pan. Did the beer kill these slugs when they went back into the ground, or did I just get them drunk for free?

Comments (20)

  • 16 years ago

    slugs have to be drawned in the beer and die.The container need not to be
    big. A small dish like ashtray will do. You will need several of them here and there.
    Another way is just to go out there, after dark, with a flash light and get them, one by one. Do this several nights in a row untill you zap them all.
    If you don't want to handle them, just sprinkle few grains of salt on them.

    They also sell some slug killer that is organic:Its brand name is SLUGO.
    YET Another way to prevent slugs, is to throw some nylon tulle on your seedling,

  • 16 years ago

    If you don't want to handle them, cut them in half with a trowel or an old pair of scissors. Or pick up w/tongs & drop into slightly soapy water.

  • 16 years ago

    For my number one enemy, beer and yeast/sugar tonic worked... before the dogs started drinking them. My guess is your dust pan probably has a flat side which allows them to exit. If you use something that's harder for them (the slugs, not the dogs) to climb back out, then you may see the drunk and drowned in the morning. Search on gardenweb and you'll find many tips on different ways to set beer traps.

  • 16 years ago

    you can use empty tuna cans, just make them level with the ground, and fill with beer, slugs will definitly want to party, :) and drown.

  • 16 years ago

    eric62687,

    I am in the bay area too and every year, slugs/snails devour lots of plants. I have learned to grow them in my improvised nursery and transplant after they are a month old to minimize damage. Basil, cucumbers etc are devoured within a few hours of planting sometimes but I don't want to use any pesticide etc.

    I tried beer trap but realized it was getting too expensive - one or two for half a can or Corona/Heineken was too much. I then read somewhere about them eating in the evening so I go out with a torch around 9 - 9:30 and I either just kill them with trowel. I could not bare the thought of slow-death with drowning them on soap water.

    On a positive side, I found that around mid-June/July, the slug problem just comes to halt. It has to do with either their lifecycle or weather but every year around that time, the problem stops until the next early spring. I have not done my research on that but if you can save your plants somehow for the next month or two, you will get lots of great fresh produce.

    HTH.

  • 16 years ago

    Corona?!? This is what they invented Old Milwaukee for (they can't really expect people to drink it, right?).

    Sluggo is pretty good and non-toxic, but not organic. Wood ash can be useful, but your soil is likely already slightly alkaline, so you don't want to raise the pH too much. Diatomaceous earth (food grade) will work until it washes away.

  • 16 years ago

    Howdy Folks,
    New Sluggo Plus IS Organic and it works great too ;-)

    {{gwi:47584}}

  • 16 years ago

    1. If you add beer in a pan make sure it is aleast 2" deep and the edges sharp. Less than that they would crawl away.
    2. I tried wood ash - it works but when it rains wait till it is dry to replenish it.
    3. Diatomaceous earth would work - same as wood as in case of rain. I have to try this as I couldn't get it so far.
    4. So I tried crushed egg shells - Seems to be working along with the copper mesh nailed around the beds.

    Here is a link that might be useful: uj's vegetable garden

  • 16 years ago

    Pabst blue ribbon is a great choice, in my area I just go get a 40 and share with em! I also use the tuna can, wash good though cause cats dig it too. I tell you there is nothing like sitting in your garden at night in your unmentionables with a tuna sandwich and a cold 40 oz listening to the sweet sounds of slugs drowining and the lady bugs munching aphids! I can almost hear them screaming! I dont recommend setting up camp in your neighbors garden though, unless its a party! lol!

  • 16 years ago

    I tried the beer in a dish thing for a while last summer. The slugs were just decimating my marigolds. It does work, but then I got another critter (raccoon or possum I suspect) that was taking the little beer pools out of the ground and drinking the beer. I would go out in the morning and the little beer tubs would be sitting on my sidewalk with no beer and a few dead slugs laying around. I finally resorted to Sluggo. It does a decent job, better than the beer anyway.

  • 16 years ago

    I lay down a layer of crushed egg shells, they wont cross the rough shells :>)

  • 16 years ago

    Diatomacious Earth is cheap and works a treat. You may need to reapply it after a rain, though.

    YMMV,

    Mike

  • 16 years ago

    I've read that it's the yeast in the beer that attracts them. Being someone who tends to make things from scratch, I figured I'd go for the basic ingredients, since it's cheaper. When my little bottle of yeast runs out, I've got a whole GIANT cake of the stuff from Costco. Those dang slugs ate 3 consecutive melon plants last year - that my son picked out at the store - no making my kid cry again you little buggers!

    Mix some yeast - I looked up the recipe in a book, promptly forgot - dunno, a couple teaspoons? with some sugar - roughly the same amount - in some water. For those who don't bake, yeast dissolves easier in warm water.

    I just use a pie tin - like the kind in cheapo pot pies. Dig it in so it's level with the surface. Evidently, they can't get out of it that way. I catch them every time I remember to put new "slug bait" in the trap in my cold frame. Being a gentle soul, I'm embarassed by how happy I am to find their little corpses in the morning.

    Incidentally, don't let anyone tell you it's a good idea to make a cold frame out of bales of straw and the storm windows from your screen doors. It's like slug heaven out there!! So disappointing, as I was excited to make myself a cold frame out of leftovers from my older kid's fall birthday bonfire. As soon as I can find some windows on the cheap, I am definitely building one out of wood - maybe with some strips of copper flashing around the inside. The copper is supposed to shock the slugs.

  • 16 years ago

    I did the beer in a cat food can thing last night on a whim because I had a little bit of leftover beer (such a thing DOES exist!), and all I caught in the morning was an earwig.

    One earwig.

  • 16 years ago

    Just a note - Sluggo is toxic to cats, not sure about dogs.

  • 16 years ago

    When they got really bad at our place, I took the tops off of empty soda cans with a can opener and buried them until the tops were level with the soil. Then I filled them halfway to the top with beer. I put a couple in each little bed.

    Beer is kind of expensive, so you can mix it with flour, yeast and water to stretch it. Also, if you end up killing a whole bunch of them, the traps get to reek after a while and it becomes necessary to replace them or change the solution.

    "Some say a margarine tub works better than a tuna can. Cut holes near the top of the tub, bury it up to the holes and leave the lid on. The lid keeps rain from diluting the beer. If you don't want to use beer, mix 2 tablespoons flour, 1/2 teaspoon brewer's yeast and 1 teaspoon sugar with 2 cups warm water."

    Here is a link that might be useful: Slugs: Get them now, or they'll get you

  • 16 years ago

    Ammonia and dishsoap works, i had these megaslugs destroying my hostas and veg seedings, i went out there at night and sprayed the lil snotwads, it was really gratifying watching them curl up and die....BTW i do love most lower life forms, but i drwa the line when it comes to my pea seedlings!!!!

    Lemme go find a recipe....

  • 16 years ago

    1 part ammonia to 3 or 4 parts water...you do have to spray it right on the slugs, if you have any concerns about plant damage (i never had a problem with any babies i sprayed) you could rinse them...the ammonia breaks down and feeds the plants too.

  • 16 years ago

    I've tried all the home remedy type stuff like beer and copper etc. and what finally worked for me was the slug bait, the active ingredient was iron something keyword iron and i think it was organic, I had no choice, they were devouring my broccoli. This year I'm saving my $17.00. 3-4 nights a week I go over the yard and garden with a flashlight and drop them in a bucket w/about 5 tbs of salt. I average about 20 to 75 a night. I've got about 7-8 days so far and a few hundred snails. I'm seeing fewer and fewer. Wear latex gloves or fight the slime!

  • 16 years ago

    Hello,

    I have a hobby gardening site and have nine natural ways to get rid of snails which may interest you. There are photos and simple instructions for each solution.

    http://www.sustainable-gardening-tips.com/garden-snails.html

    There are many different ideas around and some work better than others depending on your climate and the design of your garden to name just a couple. At this time of year you will need to have some clever ways to stop them.

    I really don't like commercial baits as they can cause death and / or illness in other innocent pets, birds and animals.

    Please have a look and choose from the nine options and try to eliminate them sustainably.

    Kind regards
    Robyn
    (Gardener and Permaculturist)

    Here is a link that might be useful: My hobby gardening website

Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz