Software
Houzz Logo Print
iknowyourider0

Raised Beds Retaining Water?

15 years ago

My girlfriend and I built a basic raised bed with 2x6 (about 15sq ft.), and planted some hot peppers and tomatoes 3 days ago. We've been watering everyday in order to establish the new plants. Today we started noticing signs of overwatering (yellow leaves, wilting) and have noticed that the soil is still wet 24hrs after watering (and we live in Florida!)

I believe it's because we added DRY cardboard to the bottom layer and forgot to wet it before covering it with soil. If this is the case I'm not sure how to remedy the our situation. We are grateful for anybody's tips and advice.;

Dave

Comments (12)

  • 15 years ago

    If it were me...I'd quit watering them until they looked like they could use a good drink of water. Make those roots reach for the water in the bottom of the garden box.

    I stick a rain guage in my gardens and if they don't get an inch of rain in a week's time, I water them, in the early morning, until they rain guage reads 1 inch.

  • 15 years ago

    I believe it's because we added DRY cardboard to the bottom layer

    Now you know. Tell others. If you don't incorporate new into native soil, this is what happens.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks. Now thinking of ways to remove or saturate the cardboad.

  • 15 years ago

    You don't really need cardboard at all, and I'm not sure what it's adding to your bed. Can you carefully remove the plants with a soil ball around each, put them aside on the ground or a tarp, and reach in and get rid of the cardboard? Compost it in small pieces with kitchen waste, or throw it in the trash.

    What's underneath the bed? If it's compacted soil or untouched turf, you might want to dig into it or at least rough it up with a garden fork. You want it to be something that will drain quickly and that your plants' roots can eventually penetrate.

  • 15 years ago

    Using cardboard on the bottom of a new raised bed is a very common and quite a good recommendation. It works exceptionally well.

    HOWEVER, the recommendation normally also includes something like "hosed-down well before adding the soil" or "well soaked" etc.

    But adding the dry cardboard instead won't actually cause major problems unless you over-water - which you are doing. Daily watering is not required to "establish the plants". A good watering when first planted and a subsequent one perhaps 3-4 days later depending on the weather is all that is needed IF the plants were not rootbound to begin with and if your soil mix is a properly draining one. You don't mention what you filled the box with.

    In other words there are several other possible causes for your problem than the dry cardboard.

    The cardboard, even tho dry when laid is wet be now and it will serve you well down the line. For now you need to quit over-watering the plants and if necessary, improve the soil quality so that it drains better.

    Dave

  • 15 years ago

    Even if the cardboard was dry when you put it down, it is certainly soaked by now. I used dry cardboard and dry newspaper in the bottom of all my raised beds. I've never had a problem with my plants. Just stop watering and your plants might rebound.
    Kim

    Here is a link that might be useful: My Garden

  • 15 years ago

    Hi there, this is Rider's girlfriend posting. The cardboard was my idea (after reading a lot of testimonials that cardboard was good to put at the bottom of a raised bed to prevent weeds growing up), however we completely missed anything about wetting the cardboard beforehand. Needless to say, our learning curve is humongous right now and we're very grateful for your suggestions so far! Feeling much more hopeful about things today. The fleet is perking up and the soil is drying out. There's a habanero plant that isn't doing so "hot," but I don't think that's a drainage problem. Maybe either too much sun (it's in the sunniest spot), or not enough nutrients.

    Our soil under the bed is completely sandy and seemed to us to be pretty useless, hence not incorporating native soil with the new soil. Our makeup is about 5 parts topsoil to 2 parts Black Kow composted manure, 2 parts peat moss, and 1 part coffee grounds. Our theory was just trying to incorporate a number of the suggested composted materials we'd read about, along with some "filler" topsoil. We haven't done any soil testing or even pH testing, but realize that this would probably be a good idea to make sure our babies are getting the right stuff.

    I think for now we'll let them get thirsty again before watering, perhaps another couple of days. Thanks again for your help, and we'll be posting often with questions and updates I'm sure!

  • 15 years ago

    partlycloudy... Sounds like a good plan. :)

    One doesn't learn unless they ask questions.

    Good luck with your new garden area.

  • 15 years ago

    Use a spading fork to puncture the cardboard as much as you can between the plants.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm sure it was the over watering that caused most of the problem. As I've said, I never wet my cardboard and never had a problem with it. I do agree with you that it does sound like your soil mixture might need some nutrients. The ingredients you've added are lacking in them. I like to add in garden soil to my beds. The kind that is sold in bags, because they have fertilizer and organic matter in them. This will give your soil a boost. You can side dress your plants with it to help them out.

  • 15 years ago

    Alright! This is great and we're feeling pretty hopeful about things at this point. Here's a brief rundown of what we're looking at, in case any of you are curious:

    - 3 tomato plants of different varieties, 2 of which look excellently strong, and one of which, a cherry tomato plant, has some yellowing leaves at the bottom, but a teeny tomato growing, which we are very excited about - our first fruit! Will keep an eye on the yellowing, but think that was probably a result of the overwatering.
    - 2 pepper plants, a jalapeno and a habanero - the jalapeno is strong, but the habanero was fading fast. We transplanted the habanero into a pot with some "organic potting soil," and moved it to a slightly shadier area near our very tiny garden - hopefully the nutrients in the potting soil will bring it back, and we'll keep it from the hot-hot sun for a day or so to see how that goes (we're having 85+ degree days here). Will water it in a day or so, because the peat pot it was still in when we transplanted was still very moist from the "overwatering"
    - cilantro - which is gloriously thriving at the back and shadier end of the garden. Wow, this thing has taken off, and we are thrilled. We love cilantro, and it's so nice to have something so obviously working!
    - basil - see above notes for cilantro. Woot!

    When we removed our wavering habanero, the cardboard beneath was indeed very saturated, and produced no resistance when punctured. So thankfully we no longer feel the need to remove it and disturb the whole system. We've driven holes through in several places to help with drainage.

    These forums are very encouraging, and again, we're grateful for these suggestions!