Software
Houzz Logo Print
splishsplashwaves

Quick help needed -- horse manure and vegetables!

18 years ago

Hi, I'm new here, but I've been searching the archives. I am attempting to plant a garden; I have seedlings and plants waiting to go into the garden but have been slowed down by heavy rains in the past month.

I was intending to do some raised beds in layers. I've put down black landscape cloth on top of the weeds, and then I added a couple of inches of peat moss. Then from a local farmer, I just got a big load of horse manure mixed with a bit of pine sawdust bedding and some uneaten hay. I put several inches of that on top of the peat moss (about 4") and was intending to top that with a couple more inches of peat moss, plus maybe some bone and/or blood meal and possibly some wood ashes.

However, now I'm wondering if that was a bad idea, as looking through the archives says that fresh horse manure may burn the plants, and it may poison the vegetables! (I don't know if the farmer feeds the horses organically, if that matters.) I really don't want to poison my family!

So help, please! Should I not use the couple of beds I've started thus far? Should I let the manure compost until next spring and then use it? (I don't think I have time to let it break down this year, as it's already getting late.)

If I shouldn't use it this year, what would you recommend I do? I had wanted to use raised beds to make weeding easier and to avoid having to dig/till, but maybe that's not a good idea this year. I have room to start over if need be. Could I dig enough to loosen the existing soil, cover with landscape cloth to keep down weeds, and then make small holes in the cloth as needed to plant my plants?

Many thanks for the help! It seems the more I read, the more confused I get!

Comments (4)

  • 18 years ago

    First of all, relax. I am in your zone and I regularly use LOTS of horse manure without any problem. The manure I get is mostly fairly fresh, but also some is in aged condition. I have, in the past, filled new raised bed frames with as much as 2/3 horse manure and 1/3 garden soil/compost/leaves etc. and have experienced no ill effects. NEVER have I seen anything "burned" from horse manure. Cow manure is a different story and that MUST be composted first, but horse is way milder. If I were you I would use all the stuff you have there (minus the black weed cloth) and either mix it together or leave it layered and top it off with some bagged garden soil or have some soil delivered depending on the size of your project, and plant away - you will be happy with the results. At the end of the season turn the mix and add more stuff (leaves, grass, scraps) and you will see that rich black soil coming your way. Another thing I might do is double dig instead of just piling layers on the surface, in order to mix some of the native soil in with your amendments, but you don't HAVE to as the worms will do this over time. Honestly, don't worry about the horse manure, it's fine.

  • 18 years ago

    I have also used horse manure much sooner than advised in lasagna beds for a vegetable garden with no problem. I scavenge a lot of things, so I have a lot more to work with than horse manure and peat moss, though. I wouldn't worry about the horse manure, it could be so fresh and thick it will damage your plants, but there is no poisoning involved. If the vegies grow, they are fine to eat.

    My poisoning concern would be the landscape fabric. When and how are you going to remove that from the BOTTOM of your garden before it starts ripping and shredding itself? I have never heard of that being on the bottom of a lasagna bed. Normally cardboard or several layers of newspaper are used. That will break down and add to the soil over time.

    Also, next fall gather up other people's bagged leaves for your lasagna beds. There is no reason to buy peat moss when you can get organic materials that are more nutritious and free. Other common sources are coffee grounds from Starbucks, old produce from stores or farmers markets, grass clippings if chemical free, wood chips, your kitchen scraps, etc.

    Marcia

  • 18 years ago

    Ditto on the horse manure- it's my favorite for veggies because of it's nonburning and rapid assimilation into the soil. Often I will rip out an old crop, manure the bed, and replant immediately. If you want a margin of safety, plant your starts with a small amount of potting soil or garden soil around the roots. By the time the roots get into the manure, it's decomposed. Horse manure is also one of the safest manures pathogen wise. If in doubt as to the quantity, use more. Beware too many shavings, rice hulls, saw dust, etc as horse manure doesn't have enough extra nitrogen to break them down and still have some N for your plants.

  • 18 years ago

    Well, thank you all so very much for the quick help! I think I feel better now. One of my gardening books had recommend the landscape cloth for smothering weeds, but if that's really not a good idea, I can use cardboard instead.

    So using fresh, not aged or composted, horse manure isn't likely to lead to e. coli contamination in my veggies? It'll be mostly peppers and tomatoes, with a few other things in there. I like the idea of using some potting or garden soil around the roots just to be safe. All the sites I found were saying that fresh manure, including horse, is very likely to cause e. coli contamination. I have young children and am pregnant, so I'm particularly concerned. (Of course I will wear gloves and wash hands and produce well.) But all your practical advice makes it sound like that's not really likely.