Software
Houzz Logo Print
toad_ca

spikes versus granular fertilizer

15 years ago

What are the pluses and minuses of organic granular fertilizer versus spikes for apple and pear trees?--aside from ease of application.

Comments (6)

  • 15 years ago

    Well, if the basic product is the same, the ONLY advantage of the spike is that it's an easy, pre-measured dose. The main disadvantage is that you pay a big premium for the convenience. I wouldn't buy the spikes unless they were on a really good clearance.

  • 15 years ago

    I found out about spikes this winter and I am sold. 5 spikes for $3 at my local nursery. I am not even trying to calculate if it is more expensive or not. I am going to use them for all fruit trees. with Granular fert - I always felt that I was not sure if the roots were getting any of it. It has more chances of being washed away or needs to be worked into the soil. With spikes, I feel that ALL the fertilizer amount gets into the soil close to the roots without any loss. Besides, the visual proof is there -- all my fruits trees have taken off this spring at a higher rate than for last 2 years when I was applying granulars.

  • 15 years ago

    I think spikes are a waste of money and don't make it easier for the tree to absorb nutrient- if anything harder by limiting the area where they can be absorbed. N. is just as likely to leach below the rootzone with spikes and there's no reason any fertilizer should "wash away". It's a ploy based on the myth that trees absorb nutrients more deeply in the soil than grass. Anyway, that's what I was taught and is my opinion.

    Whats so hard about spreading a cup of fertilizer under the drip line of a tree before a rain or watering in?

  • 15 years ago

    I have been taught the same as Harvestman.You would have to surround your tree with spikes to get to all of it,and that could be expensive.Fertilize when and how you should with granular.

  • 15 years ago

    Agree with HM/GD. I only fertilize anything before a rain, or water it in, or make a solution ahead of time. Virtually all farmers nowadays are N-fertilizing via solution, so we are hardly alone.

    Alternatively, if you scatter granular just before mulching, essentially 100% will be absorbed. and for non-N fertilizer, scattering on the surface still works, none of it evaporates.

  • 15 years ago

    Thank you everyone for your responses. I'm sticking with the granular.