Software
Houzz Logo Print
lacanadagardner

Tree Planting Soil?

18 years ago

The soil in my backyard seems to be extremely "sandy". So whenever I watered the existing trees in my backyard the water doesn't drain as fast as i think it should.

So, when I planted my Valencia Orange, Plum, and Apricot tree I dug out the hole and then filled it up with just EB Stone planting compost.

Was that the right move?

Comments (10)

  • 18 years ago

    "Sandy" soil is such that water drains faster than it should. Did you mean "clay" soil? If so, filling a hole with compost may create a "bathtub" effect. Most would advise filling the hole with native soil or with a small mix of compost, then mulch on top.

    Btw, I am curious where you are in CA since you planted a Valencia. It doesn't seem to do well in CA or more precisely it doesn't do well in my yard.

  • 18 years ago

    The water doesn't drain very fast at all in the soil in my back yard. Should I dig up some of the planting compost and mix in some native soil?

    I live in La Canada, CA. My grandpa lives in Burbank, CA and he has 2 Valencia Orange trees in his back yard. One of which is HUGE!

  • 18 years ago

    So I should probably dig out all that compost that I filled the hole up with and replace it with the native soil?

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, dig out the compost. And, if possible, consider planting on a raised bed. That is usually a good idea with poorly drained soil. The compost could make up a part of the raised portion of the bed.

    The Fruitnut

  • 18 years ago

    Yes if you want to grow them in different soil order some that seems suitable and plant them in that, on top of the soil that is already there. Or dig out an entire large bed of the existing soil and re-fill it with the new soil.

    The first method is less work and does not require as large a purchase of new soil. You also do not have to dispose of the existing soil.

    What you want to avoid is planting in small areas of one soil texture surrounded by another. The difficulty with this is how it affects the movement of water into the small areas and out of them. In addition to the possible bathtub (or sump) effect on heavy soils during wet conditions there may also be a problem with unmodified existing soil having a greater attraction for water than the amended backfill inside the small planting hole during dry conditions. These occurrences are the main reasons for not planting in amended planting holes (or other small areas) and not the false idea that roots reach the edge of the amended planting hole and then circle around (or turn around and grow back toward the plant!). Unfortunately, the latter seems to have become the primary oft-repeated reason for not amending planting hole backfill.

  • 18 years ago

    I had actually heard both reasons. Odd things happen with the water when clay soil and sandy soil meet because the clay particles want to hold onto the water molecules. I had assumed that the roots were thought to stay within the amended hole because of water difference. Is that no longer thought to be true?

    Rosefolly

  • 18 years ago

    Most of this stuff was found out decades ago and is taking a long time to become widely known and accepted. So, no, it isn't just now thought that roots stay in the amended hole because of water related problems. For one thing they don't stay in the amended hole - as a routine occurrence.

    For the watering situation would affect roots getting out of the amended hole would be if the dampness or dryness stunted the plant enough the root growth was too minimal for the plant to get out of the hole in a timely manner.

  • 18 years ago

    If you were dealing with a very high clay soil and dug the hole with an augur or something similar which put pressure on the sides, you could compress/polish the sides of the hole, which would create a clay pot effect of compacted soil. When roots hit a compaction zone, they will tend to veer off into the softer soil. The result with a hole for a tree is that the roots can be pretty well contained in the hole for a couple years until this compaction zone breaks down naturally through freeze/thaw cycles, worm and soil insect activity, moisture and dryness, root action, etc.

    When dealing with a soil with a high clay content, check the sides after digging and if compacted, use a shovel and shave off a couple inches to widen the hole and remove this compaction layer so the tree roots aren't held in their hole until the compaction zone breaks down.

    For the most gardeners, this compaction zone isn't created because their soil doesn't have a very high clay content, or they are not using digging methods that will create a compaction zone. The problem with amending the soil is that you create two soils with different affinities for water so that either too much water is wicked to the newly planted tree, or it is all pulled away from the tree. In addition, adding a lot of organic matter such as peat or compost or manure to the soil you fill the hole with results in the organic matter breaking down over the next few years and the soil settling in the hole, creating a basin to hold water you don't want, or exposing the trees roots, or lowering the tree deeper than you want it compared to the surrounding ground level.

    What you might do is dig your hole, then refill the native soil around the tree, but put the topsoil in first so that it is around the roots, and the subsoil in last at the surface where the new tree will not have roots. This enriches the soil around the roots, maintains the same soil composition as the soil surrounding the hole, and gets the poorer soil near the surface where you can top with compost and over time convert the poorer subsoil to good topsoil again.

  • 18 years ago

    Roots are geotropic, they grow away from the center of the plant unless stopped by an uncrossable barrier like fiberglass or plastic. Even cracks in stone are penetrated by roots. Glazed planting hole walls are penetrated less readily than aerated loosened soil but it wouldn't be expected that the roots would "veer off". It is fundamental to the health of the plant that it has a constantly outward-growing, questing root system. The outer roots of some potted plants actually spring away from the surface of the planting medium when the pot is slipped off.

    Subsoil on top of topsoil is topsy-turvy. With gardening there are certain ways and times when you can depart from the natural model for that situation to a certain extent, otherwise it works best to follow it. Subsoil belongs underneath topsoil. Never plant with zones of one material buried within another material. If the zone of topsoil around the roots has a different texture from the native soil around that it may affect how water moves into and out of the topsoil the same as if organic amendments had been mixed in - here purchased topsoil is often basically the same thing as a liberally amended backfill anyway. And the tree is not liable to wait while the subsoil on top of it is "developed" into a better soil but rather may have problems like root suffocation, subsoil on top of topsoil (or mixed together, as in double digging) basically amounts to spoiling the topsoil with the subsoil. The topsoil was formed by natural processes over a sometimes very long time from the subsoil and now you are putting the unimproved subsoil over the top of the roots, like a cap, with the topsoil underneath - instead of up near the air, where it is supposed to be.

    Always plant with the same soil throughout the entire potential rooting area.