Software
Houzz Logo Print
jessaka

trees resistent to brown rot

16 years ago

i live in green country of oklahoma and my peach and necterine trees lost their fruit due to brown rot. i can't see taking them out but if they ever die i would, but i don't know if there are better varieties. i don't even know how to prevent brown rot except to keep fruit trimmed, branches trimmed, and mulch under the tree and spray. but i know one woman that kept spraying with fungicide and they all died. i hate uses this poison. what to do? thanks

Comments (13)

  • 16 years ago

    Use the right fungicide, Monterey Fungus Fighter, which won't harm you or the trees if used according to directions (read carefully as you would any medicine label).

    Elberta and Georgia Belle usually have more resistance than newer varieties of there season (mid-late). Early fruiting varieties also tend to be more resistant if it means they ripen when there tends to be less humidity. The also may be more resistant just because scab has less time to develop on fruit which works hand and hand with brown rot.

  • 16 years ago

    Should have mentioned that nectarines are notorious for high susceptibility to rot and my experience confirms this.

  • 16 years ago

    Jessaka,

    I can also attest that it would be extremely difficult to kill fruit trees from using a fungicide as labeled. Off the top of my head, I can only think of the fungicide/bactericide copper that might possibly do it. I'm pretty sure your friend lost her trees from some other cause.

    I'm not sure what the "green country" of Oklahoma is, but peach/nectarine trees can be hard to keep alive if you're trying to do it on red Oklahoma clay. I'm a big fan of mulch, but if the soil doesn't drain well, mulch will kill peach trees that much faster. The answer to this problem is to get the trees up in mounds.

    A good fungicide used at the right times will pretty much eliminate brown rot on typical Midwest peach varieties. As stated, Montery Fungi Fighter is probably your best option. Captan is also effective.

  • 16 years ago

    thanks for all your help. i didn't like the idea of fungicide on my fruit on in it if i used fungicide. don't wish to eat poison but may have no choice. had another friend suggest that vinegar/soap and one other item combo.

    also we don't have red soil. we are in the ozarks. we had a ton of necterines this year, right next to the peach, and the necterines went first.

    i am rather discouraged. not sure when to spray them.

  • 16 years ago

    The last month before ripening is when the fruit are the most susc. to brown rot. Earlier in the season, when the fruit are green and hard, they're pretty much impervious to brown rot.

    Your nectarine may be unsuited for your area. The Ozarks get more rain than I do, and I've not yet tried to grow nectarines here because of the purported difficulty, even though I grow lots of peaches.

  • 16 years ago

    Most medicines are poison. Fungicides are designed to kill an organism not closely related to you (as life forms go). Do you mean poison or synthetic poison? Maybe you just mean "synthetic compound".

    Although fruit tends to be more susceptible to rot the riper it gets, I stop spraying fungicide here a month before harvest so the fungicide has long since become inactive by the time I harvest my fruit. Anything remaining on the fruit isn't anywhere near enough of a poison to even kill what it was designed for.

    My stone fruit has a short shelf life and I lose a few fruit to rot but I even am able to grow nectarines this way. However, you may not be so lucky in your climate. You have to experiment to discover least-spray options.

    The residue issue is another matter, but I suspect that the residue of the fruit I produce with 2 insecticide and fungicide sprays in spring and 2 or 3 fungicide sprays in summer, well before harvest, leaves only the tiniest trace by the time I eat my fruit. I'm not saying that spraying closer to harvest causes a risky exposure, but as long as I don't need it, why bother.

    If you are nervous about using pesticides, I suggest you research this forum for growing with ziplock sandwich bags around individual fruit. With this method I believe you can get by with a single spray at petal fall.

  • 16 years ago

    Hman, the ziploc bags don't work for peaches and nectarines, it makes brown rot worse.

    Jessaka, a spray or two of the Monterey product mentioned above in early/mid season should keep the brown rot down. If only one tree is getting it badly after spraying it means that variety is too susceptible and I would consider replacing it. As olpea mentions above, most nectarines are highly disease-prone.

    Scott

  • 16 years ago

    thanks. i am not sure what variety i got of either. it is what they grow here, according to lowe's. i will keep this thread and spray in the spring. i am sure what i get at the farmer's market has been sprayed, so i will just grin and bare it. ha.

  • 16 years ago

    So zips are only for apples and pears?

  • 16 years ago

    jessaka, what you get at the farmers market was probably sprayed with a ton of stuff. Peaches are in the top category of chemical residues found on grocery fruit due to the high pest pressure on them.

    hman, zips work on apples and pears. For peaches and plums you can use cotton drawstring bags, they usually ventilate enough to avoid the rot (but, it does make the fruit somewhat more prone to rot).

    Scott

  • 16 years ago

    Why not nylon stocking material? I'd think cotton would really hold the dew.

  • 11 years ago

    Our grapes get brown rot which I have prevented by using a paper bag over the fruit, tied with a twisty. This has to be done as soon as the fruit sets before the brown rot spores are air born. If their are no spores in the bag the fruit is ok with the humidity which we have a lot of in WV. Surprisingly a paper bag survives all summer long. This is a lot of work and would require thinning the peaches which is good for making big peaches anyway. I've heard the Japanese growers do this because buyers there are very picky about even cosmetic specks on their fruit.