Software
Houzz Logo Print
tcstoehr

Ziplocs, earwigs, watercore

16 years ago

First I'd like to recommend the practice of cutting a slit in the center of each Ziploc's zipper, barely thru the zipper, to make the bags fit snugger around the apple stem. It does work, although I don't always manage to get it right and some practice may be required. This year the incidence of earwigs was greatly reduced by using this method. In the picture below, you can see why an earwig would have trouble getting into this bag. The zipper is able to close completely on each side of the stem while the plastic has to stretch to accommodate the apple's stem.



One additional note, as I harvest mature apples so far this year I'm finding no earwigs however I can see that they have been there in some bags from the mess they make, but they are gone now. I wonder if as the apple grows the Ziploc seal at the stem becomes tighter until the earwigs are excluded. Without the slit in the zipper, the Ziploc seal would simply expand with the apple's growth.

Last year I noticed some Fiesta Apples having irregular dark patches on the lower halves of apples that had been bagged. I attributed this to the bagging and actually started a thread about it in this forum. However, this year I can see that it's the earwigs that apparently are responsible. The bags without earwigs had no problems. The bags *with* earwigs did have problems. Notice the picture below.



The top three apples came from Ziplocs with earwig infestation and all show darkening patches around their lower halves. The bottom three show no problems. The bottom two on the left came from Ziplocs without earwig infestation. The bottom right apple didn't have a bag at all. This is consistent with all the apples I have taken off of this one Fiesta tree.

I now believe this problem to be Watercore induced by the presence of earwigs in Ziplocs. Observations over the course of three years on this one Fiesta tree are consistent. I could well believe other varieties are susceptible but perhaps less so.

Comments (15)

  • 16 years ago

    That looks like a very tight fit. That is what i needed to do, because just zipping them up tight against the stem wasn't enough to keep Plum Curculio out of my bags.

    I also had watercore in the apples that made it through the PC barrage. Not all of them, but quite a few had significant watercore. I blamed it on the excessive rains and heat...although i don't even know what causes it.

  • 16 years ago

    I don't know how earwigs could induce watercore. I had the worst year for watercore ever this year; makes me think heat/humidity is a factor since we had that in spades around ripening time for many apples.

    Scott

  • 16 years ago

    interesting- i did not have a single apple with watercore this year though i had watercore last year. wonder if using footies as opposed to ziplock/sandwhich bags helps defeat watercore. (i used only footies this year).

  • 16 years ago

    That seems even more labor intensive than bagging alone. How many apples do you bag in a year?

  • 16 years ago

    I had a bunch of watercore this year (hot, dry) and I wonder if the ziplock baggies are a cause. They are little greenhouses really and must trap some heat in the bag. I had a few apples that looked like that had sunscald inside baggies just on the southern side.

    Is there a point when switching from ziplocks to footies would make sense? Does the bug pressure let up mid summer or at all? I tried a few footies this year but didn't keep good records about which bagging technique did better.

  • 16 years ago

    > I don't know how earwigs could induce watercore.

    I have no idea either. But I think it is plausible that something they do promotes watercore. They create an impacted mass of bug crap around the stem that promotes damage and rot in that area. That could be a factor.

    All I can really say is that there is a correlation. If I go out to that tree and unbag an apple and earwigs fall out, that apple will have watercore. Otherwise, it won't.

    Another correlation is that this year I do not have a single case of watercore outside of a Ziploc. That's on ten dwarf (M26) trees.

    > I had a few apples that looked like that had sunscald
    > inside baggies just on the southern side.

    I will have sunscald with or without the Ziplocs. It seems to make no difference. Hot weather will do it regardless.

  • 16 years ago

    Earwigs get into footies.

    I put footies on peaches to try to save them from the birds. All the footie peaches had earwigs inside the peaches. None of the peaches without footies had earwigs.

    6 of one, half a dozen of the other, no footies, the birds ruin them; footies and the earwigs ruin them.

  • 16 years ago

    I never had earwigs in my footies; you should be able to tie them tightly at the top so no earwigs can get in. Twist the fabric on two sides to make a proto-rope and then tie a knot, pulling hard to seal it well.

    For me I think it was the hot weather that gave the bad watercore, it was horrible this summer here.

    Scott

  • 16 years ago

    Of the 300 zips that I put on my apples and a few on pears I found perhaps 10% that had earwigs. They did not destroy the flesh of the apple however. I did do the cut at the center of the zipper and applied it very tightly. I think it is very possible the wiggies are getting in on the corner drainage cuts. I will change this next year to a cut daigonally towards the center of the bag and not remove any plastic but still allow drainage. I did notice a couple of things about the zipped apples. They did ripen slower and had less color than the unzipped ones. This was however a smashing success in the face of incredible insect pressure from the thousands of wild trees here. Kudos to the guy who started this. Now you apple mongers let's perfect this method. How about a wiggie repellent like lemon Dawn on the stem and drainage cuts while the zips are being put on. I hope to double or triple the amount zipped next year.

  • 16 years ago

    There are different ways of cutting the zipper. I first heard of it on this forum where the guy used a paper hole-puncher to remove a small section of the zipper that would accommodate the stem. This allowed the zipper to close fully on each side of the stem. I didn't have a hole-puncher so I just made a single cut with scissors and it seemed to work fine.
    I have also heard on this forum that you can exclude earwigs from your trees by placing a paper or cellophane collar on the trunk and coating it with Tanglefoot. I have not tried this.
    While the earwigs do not destroy the flesh, they do make a mass of impacted waste material around the stem that can actually permeate the skin. While this does not ruin the apple for immediate usage, I fear that it will make them unsuitable for storage. This problem has been greatly reduced by the zipper-cutting technique.

  • 16 years ago

    I had the same experience trying the footies on my plums this year. Earwigs got into more than half of them and ruined the fruit, as brown rot then invaded the wounds. I won't be doing THAT again!

    It was a bad year for earwigs generally and I've never had a problem with them so early (June). They don't really seem to harm the apples when they invade the bags later in the year, and by that time the bags aren't necessary and I remove them. I also wash off the apples before storing.

  • 16 years ago

    One other problem with the footies - they tend to promote sooty blotch. On my yellow tree this year, the fruits in the footies had the worst case of the bloth - some were entirely black.

  • 16 years ago

    I also never had any problems with sooty blotch -- the footied apples were clean and the non-footied ones next to them were coated in blotch. I wonder why.

    The main problem I had with footies was the moths could just bite through them, I was still getting a lot of damage and for all that work I wanted perfect apples.

    Scott

  • 15 years ago

    Sooty blotch was nearly universal on my bagged Honeygolds this year. Wonder if spraying fungicide just before bagging would prevent or reduce the blotch?

  • 15 years ago

    I've had enough problems with the ziplocs that I'm going to try the following instead next year.

    Footies with Surround/Kaolin

    I used footies one year and preferred them over ziplocs except that they didn't work against Coddling Moth, and that's really the only thing that matters. I've talked with some people claiming that these Kaolin Footies do in fact work against Coddling Moth. So I will try it. I will post my results next fall.

0