Software
Houzz Logo Print
glenn_russell_gw

Apples sorted by type sweet, sour, balanced

18 years ago

Hi All-

I think this is a simple question... Has anyone ever seen a good sized list of apples sorted by flavor type: sour, sweet, balanced, etc? I'm finding that I really prefer the sour category. Often, a apples description will have so many flavor references that it's difficult to tell what category it really falls under. The only list I've seen is linked below. Has anyone seen a more comprehensive one? Thanks,

-Glenn

Here is a link that might be useful: Apple Source Growing Tips (look halfway down the page)

Comments (4)

  • 18 years ago

    I have never seen one. Just use a keyword search through any description list for "tart" or "sour" or "brisk". In the ARS online database you can also search by their database properties and get a list. See the link below for their "code 4" (sour) apples. Looking at this list it is very good but includes many very obscure apples and is probably missing many common ones - their collection is not complete.

    Scott

    Here is a link that might be useful: ARS sour apples

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks Scott.
    Yep, I can search through any description list, and that's basically what I've been doing.
    That ARS database may help. But, I can't find where on that large site to do my own query (it might be at some sort of apple database page?). Can you point me to the right place? Thanks again,
    -Glenn

  • 18 years ago

    The main search page is here but you can't get these lists through this search, only accessions. What you can do is from a particular apple's page click on "Observations" and then click on a particular value and you can get to the list of all other apples with the same observation ("Accessions with same code" link). Maybe someone else knows a better way. This database webpage is not the best-organized I would say.

    Scott

  • 18 years ago

    I don't find any of the listings very reliable. And, besides, apples that come out tart in one climate come out balanced somewhere else. For example, I grow king David, and for me they turn out amazingly well balanced. For Someone who lives right on the beach up here, though, they will turn out quite tart and need to sit in storage first to sweeten up.

    then, on many varieties, sweet/balanced/tart is a function of ripeness. For example, get a jonagold early, and it's tart. Get it late, and it's almost too sweet.

    Finally the whole sweet/tart thing is completely subjective as well. I love Belle de Boscop when it's dead ripe, and for some, it's still too tart. same with pink pearl, I wouldn't characterize it as tart. But others won't eat it.

    To me, a true tart apple is one that is tart early, and tart late, even after storage, and goes from tart to mealy, so the only way to eat the apple is as a tart apple - usually, that is an authentic cooker. So far, Allington pippin is the only apple I've come across so far that is a true cooker. Even granny smith here will become very lovely and balanced when left on the tree past X-mas.

    So if there is an objective way to classify apples, I would love to hear about it.