Software
Houzz Logo Print
larry_t

Question - branch spreading in winter

19 years ago

Well, as usual, I didn't think far enough ahead.

Over the spring and summer I've been spreading tree branches by attaching plastic milk jugs, with various amounts of rocks in them to pull branches into position, and a hole in the jug bottom to let water drain out.

Oh no. Here comes winter, and that jug can fill with ice and snow, and the drain hole can freeze shut. Then, the added weight on the branch really messes things up.

If I remove the jugs now, and replace them next spring do you think the branches will go back to the desired position they're in now, or will they get set into a more upright position during the winter months? It seems that because the trees are in dormancy and the limbs not growing any larger that they should be as "limber" in the spring as they are now, but I'm not sure.

Thanks for any insight you may have.

Comments (7)

  • 19 years ago

    Larry:

    If you tie off the branches to anything in or on the ground, you won't have this problem. I tie to the steel pins used to hold down weed barrier. Much better than hanging wts on the limb.

    You should remove the wts. After one season in a new position, the limb will stay where you have it. It shouldn't need further positioning the next yr.

    The Fruitnut

  • 19 years ago

    I used tent stakes and string to tie all my limbs down. Only problem i ran into was Robins trying to take my string a build nests with it.

  • 19 years ago

    I tied the limbs down to stakes, which worked fine until clumsy me walked by and tripped on the string, snapping the branch off at the tree a couple times (D'oh!).

    Applenut

  • 19 years ago

    I spread some pie cherry branches once using sisal baler twine. Tied it loosely midway out on the branches using a side branch to keep the string from slipping inwards, then to the trunk near the base, just below a branch again to keep it from slipping. The twine rots away in the weather, think the last one took a couple years to rot, most had rotted by the next spring. The branches retained their new positions and the string rotted away before constricting the trunk/branches.

    Lately I have been trimming a branch that has been pruned off, then notching the ends into a V and spreading the branches, inserting the spacer between the trunk and the branch to hold it outwards. Sometimes they fall out and I have to put them back, but generally they stay.

    If you want to keep the jugs attached, I assume they are attached with some sort of string and you could just lengthen the strings so the jugs just about touch the ground, then any extra weight from snow or ice will drop the branches only a fraction of an inch before touching the ground, yet keep the strings tight to keep the branch in position.

    You might lift the jugs to take the weight off the branches and see how much they lift up, just to see if the new position is "set". They will lift some, but see if the unweighted position is satisfactory. If it is, just remove the weights entirely since as others have noted, they should be set.

  • 19 years ago

    As no one has mentioned this I think I should. Dormant branches are less flexible and easier to break than growing branches. Al

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks to all of you for your advice. I appreciate you taking the time to reply.

    I've used wooden spreaders, and sometimes they've worked but they often fall out. I think we have too much wind which caused the branches to move.

    I've used string tie downs and still had some of them, and they work OK, but not sure about the long term use. I'm getting some deer in the orchard, and have put our dogs out to scare the deer, but the dogs (and deer) can run into the strings, which isn't good.

    So, trying the weighted milk jugs.

    But, over the weekend I removed the jugs and took off all of the tie downs. Most of the branches stayed right where they were. Great! A few moved, but I'll see what they look like in the spring, and if they need to be repositioned I'll do something then.

    Thanks again.

  • 19 years ago

    One of the nice things about tying the limbs down is that it is very easy to tell when they are ready to be removed. Simply feel how much slack there is in the tie. If its slack then the limb has taken the set.

    With weights there will always be the same tension until the weight touches the ground or the limb breaks.

    I tie my limbs to green fence stakes with a white tip. The stakes are several feet tall above the ground so an animal would be more likely to hit the stake than the string and should be able to see both which are kept within the dripline.

    I've also used plastic spreaders. If you use wooden spreaders you can nail them in. That should stand up to wind!