Software
Houzz Logo Print
emyers_gw

Lime recommendation.....

18 years ago

Sandy land with ph 5.6 & buffer ph 7.75 , incorporating pine bark fines (ph 4.9) into the soil at a rate of say 50% fines to 50% sand/soil (by volume).

How many pounds per 1000 sq ft would you recommend?

Comments (7)

  • 18 years ago

    To achieve a pH of EXACTLY what? And I want your answer to be in terms of hundreths.

    Also, we need to know which form of lime you prefer to apply to achieve your goal, and if you intend to apply it in one load or several increments.

  • 18 years ago

    Exactly? Man, talk about putting me on the spot.
    Well, trying to grow mostly brassicas. So, I'm ASSUMING somewhere in the 7.0 range?

    However, it's been said to me to not to raise ph by more than one point at a time, so I'm thinking 6.6 ish?

    Planning on using dolomitic limestone (fine) since my calcium level is borderline medium/sufficient (770 lbs per acre)and magnesium level is borderline sufficient/high (99 lbs per acre).

    Any more thoughts?

    Trying to get soil balanced out this initial year in this plot, then hopefully everything will work itself out for the seasons to follow.

  • 18 years ago

    Who told you not to raise your soil pH level more than 1 point at a time?
    You had a soil test done and that soil test had a recommended amount of lime, and which kind, to apply to get where you need to get. Follow that advice.

  • 18 years ago

    emyers,

    I would ignore the pine bark as it has no buffering capacity. Lime to the soil test recomendation and you should be fine. If they didn't give you one, you only need about 1/2 ton of lime per acre (~25lbs/1000sqft) judging by your buffer pH which is what one would expect with a sandy soil.

  • 18 years ago

    kimmser-
    I'd heard not to try and get more than 1 point per season before and someone on here also mentioned it. I think it has more to do with being relatively cautious so that other factors don't potentially take ph too far the other direction (which apparently is harder to correct).
    Have you heard differently?

    As far as going with the recommendation on my soil test, well, it gets a little complicated. If you're interested I'll explain....

    I had numerous soil tests done, and in an effort to save some money, I kind of combined soil tests for my lawn and my garden. It went like this...

    My garden is land that I removed centipede sod from, and broke up the sod in order to remove the "top soil" that was contained in the sod, to incorporate into the garden. I had my soil test done for the top 4 inches of soil after the sod was removed, for the purposes of using it to determine what was lacking in my lawn and my garden. I also had a baseline from the previous year I took for the exact same type of plot to 8" deep.

    So, two soil samples from the same relative area of my lawn with soil removed. One was treated as a garden test and the other treated as a lawn test specific to centipede.

    Well, the ph for the centipede test came back at 5.6 and the soil test for the garden came back at 5.9. Interestingly enough, for centipede, they have a different standard for ph, so the test came back that no lime was required. For the garden test I did, similarly, it came back that no lime was required (although a different cut off). So, bottom line is there wasn't any recommedation for lime on either report that told me what I needed. My next step was to call the extension office to try and get a recommendation... if I didn't get an answer here.

    fetilizersalesman-
    Thanks for your insight. Interesting that I can basically ignore the pine bark fines... I'll take your advice.

    Thanks also for your lime quantity recommendation. Looking at a separate lime recommendation that was made on a DIFFERENT section of lawn test for centipede (no grass, no topsoil, hardpack, hardpan sand) it came back 5.0 ph with a buffer ph of 7.8. Clemson's recommendation for that particular sample was 34 lbs/1000 sq ft. Just so I can BEGIN to start understanding this, what ph would you say they are trying to get the 5.0 up to? Then, as a comparison, were you trying to help me get my ph up only one point or something else?

    Then, is it more difficult to get say, 5.0 up one point vs 5.6?

    FWIW, I'm NOT doubting your recommendation. Just trying to understand this a little more.

    Thanks.
    Eddie

  • 18 years ago

    I would guess they were shooting for 6.5 as I was. If you get lime out this fall a large portion of it will react over the winter. Check it again next year and see how it went. Keep in mind that it will continue to react for a couple of years.

  • 18 years ago

    OK. Thanks.