Software
Houzz Logo Print
terran_gw

Organic is more nutritious - article

17 years ago

Organic is more nutritious - article with link to the scientific report.

http://www.foodmag.com.au/Article/Organic-is-more-nutritious-according-to-the-French/496876.aspx

Here is a link that might be useful: Foodmagazine

Comments (20)

  • 17 years ago

    And the next article/report you'll read is likely to say "no difference."

    Suspect that a balanced diet is the most important thing.

  • 17 years ago

    Yeah, there are a zillion studies on this issue and the majority report no significant difference, but depending on the study (and often who pays for them) you can find conventional = better or organic = better.

    One blurb from your link I found asinine was this: A new report by the French Agency for Food Safety (AFSSA) has found that organic foods are better for you and contain less pesticides and nitrates, which have been linked to a range of health problems including diabetes and AlzheimerÂs.

    Rotenone (organic) is widely known to produce symptoms that mimic dementia/alzheimers in lab animals. This is not to say it causes the disorder or that it would necessarily work the same way in humans, I just found mention of Alzheimers odd in a hypocritical way since it's the organic Rotenone that is the 'Alzheimer pesticide' in the lab.

    It should also be noted and remembered that organic farms can use plenty of pesticides routinely and non organic ones under limited circumstances and there is no regulation of their usage and no limits on residuals on the harvested crop like their is in conventional farming.

    It should perhaps also be noted that 80+% of the foods in the grocery labeled as organic aren't from local farmers, but from large agribusiness and around 20% of what it sold in the US is from China, makers of lead containing kid's toys.

    Please, don't settle for fluff pieces serving an ideology, educate yourself as to what you are really putting into your body, your yard and the planet we all share.

  • 17 years ago

    Far better to read a literature review or a survey of the literature to get what the breadth of the studies say. And they say...little difference in nutrition. This is the first review I've seen that sez otherwise, not exactly sure why but I'm interested in why the refs cited is so short; can't really take the time to scrutinize the refs and perhaps someone has the time.

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    In comparison after comparison the Food and Drug Administration has found that foods grown organically do have the same level of nutrients found in founds grown beore the 1960's while foods grown "conventionally" are loosing those nutrients, have lower levels of those nutrients.
    This is kind of similar to John Stoessels 20/20 supposed expose that purported to find that organicaly grown foods had higher levels of E-Coli, Salmonella, and Listeria than the same types of foods grown "conventionally". Then the labs that did the testing came out and stated that in reality they found no difference between them. That ABC News suppressed that and kept Stoessel on should tell you something about that organization. That the news media is not doing a very good job of relaying that information to the average consumer should tell you something about the news media. There are some, few, people in the media (Mark whathisname that writes a food column in the NYTimes is one) that have been writing about this for some time.

  • 17 years ago

    no offence to the poster but it just proves that you can find research to back up almost any statement you like just depends who pays for it

  • 17 years ago

    Perhaps much more supportive of organic practices is not trying to claim the produce is more nutritious, but rather that the practices are beneficial to the earth and environment. That's the reason I garden organically. But I guess that wouldn't help agribusiness PR attempts to convince consumers that the produce is better or more nutritious as the organic market expands and is embraced by agribusiness. Many people just don't give a damn about protecting the earth and environment.

  • 17 years ago

    while foods grown "conventionally" are [losing] those nutrients, have lower levels of those nutrients.

    This has much to do with the distance food travels, not in the actual growing part of it.

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    "Nutrition: What food, Grown where." I think that was a Chapter title, in a book, I'd read as a child. It said: Some parts of the country have soils, deficient in one mineral or another.
    In our neck of the woods, its Chromium, or so I've heard.

    A good organic program should, at least, be a greater variety of sources, and produce a more balanced plant. Organic plants grow better, and utilize greater amounts of nutrient, because the optimum levels, of all nutrients, were readily available.

    I know it is not a perfection of that goal, but for comparison to synthetics, organic, is closer.
    Is that true?

  • 17 years ago

    I know it is not a perfection of that goal, but for comparison to synthetics, organic, is closer.
    Is that true?

    If we are limiting the discussion to nutrients available to plants then no, it's isn't true. There is nothing preventing a land owner from getting a soil test done and adding whatever nutrients are required. This addition can be from synthetic or organic sources.

    Over the years I have read a bunch of studies on various differences in organic vs conventional grown produce and in terms of nutrient content in the produce organic/synthetic doesn't appear to matter, but the farming/horticultural practices do.

    As one example the farmer who manages soil fertility with regular additions of organic matter which releases nutrients slowly over time may end up producing a more nutritious crop than the farmer who applies heavy doses of synthetics infrequently over the season.

    The reason isn't a synthetic vs organic issue, but rather the organic crops in this case were continually provided a moderate amount of nutrients and the conventionally grown were supplied with a boom/bust or feast/famine cycle of nutrient availability. Had the conventional farmer managed soil fertility similarly to the organic farmer (but using synthetics) the expected result would be no difference in the nutritional content of the produce.

  • 17 years ago

    The problem with comparing nutrition of produce is that we don't know all there is about nutrition in particular phytonutrients. Another problem in my opinion is that the organic movement has been overrun by big business. I've visited a few local organic farms and have seen what the soil looks like and prefer to eat foods grown from that type of soil. Unfortunately most of the organic food one can buy doesn't come from these small farms but rather mega farms.

    Maybe it's time to move beyond organic.

  • 17 years ago

    gjcore, Whether the food you buy comes from a mega farm or not is a choice you make. We find all the food we need readily available from local growers. Beyond organic is what is called today "conventional" farming which is where the real problem is.
    Not too long ago I had a hard time finding Michigan apples in any of our local mega stores, and was told there were none available when over in Sparta there were warehouses full of apples that could not be sold, because the mega stores were not buying them. If you refuse to buy what the stores sell, unless they stock local produce, they will do just that. Use your power as a consumer to influence where food is purchased.

  • 17 years ago

    There was an author?(I think) on "Nightline" sometime back this spring/early summer and he made the comment that today you'd have to eat 2.5 apples to get the same nutrition of 1 apple from a 100 years ago or something like that (long time ago)!

    Could this possibly be true? If i can find the transcript, i'll post it.

  • 17 years ago

    Certainly there is a lot of food that is grown in semi-depleted soils. I'm not sure how one would test something from a hundred years ago.

  • 17 years ago

    I researched that claim a bit a couple years ago, Frank. I don't recall all the details, but concluded the claim was somewhat accurate, but also somewhat meaningless.

    Part of the equation is different plant varieties. Most of what the big farms grow are hybrids and these hybrids were not bred with nutritional content in mind, but rather shipping/storage/uniformity type qualities. So, nutritional content has decreased *in some cases* from this.

    Other issues are produce that is harvested before fully ripe. This doesn't allow the full development and thus not the full nutrient value.

    There were other reasons why this is sometimes the case, but in no case is it due to the soil or the method of growth (conventional vs organic). Plants just don't work that way. If the plant doesn't have what it needs to grow well, then it doesn't ;)

    AFAIK, things like how ripe the produce is at harvest, how long it takes to get to market, how processed it is, and variety all play a much more significant role in nutritional content in produce than does the farming method.

  • 17 years ago

    While I was just out picking beans and tomatoes I was thinking about this thread and some of the books that I've read in the last couple years which unfortunately I can't remember the titles of right now. Anyway they describe how humans have spread around the globe and most everywhere they have gone with few exceptions they have destroyed the topsoil to the point that it becomes desert or fully depleted soils barely able to support goats.

    At this point humans don't have any other continents to exploit. Whether organic or non-organic farming and gardening are practiced we must take better care of the soils or there simply isn't going to be enough food at whatever nutrition level to go around.

  • 17 years ago

    gj, how'd you like the planes out of Buckley the past two days? They go right over our house and always a hoot.

    At any rate, it is well known that we are substituting oil for knowledge and soil fertility and care, and soon that will end. Which is why we need organic gardeners around to teach everybody what to do when the time comes.

    What jg said in Other issues are produce that is harvested before fully ripe. This doesn't allow the full development and thus not the full nutrient value. is what I meant above when I stated This has much to do with the distance food travels, not in the actual growing part of it. Comparing nutrient value is a poor substitute for care.

    Dan

  • 17 years ago

    dan, I noticed a few jets today and they were loud. Didn't see them though as I was blanching tomatoes

  • 17 years ago

    I am pretty much under the impression that conventional vs organic = same nutrition amount.

    I think what should be stressed is that convention store bought DOES NOT MOST LIKELY contain the same nutritional amounts.

    Store bought produce tends to be picked early which of course mean less nutrition in the product. I think conventional and organic are pulling nutrients from the air and some from the ground, therefore, nutritionally identical, I would think.

    Advantage in organic is possibly less heavy metals, hopefully less pesticides, fungicides or another kind of "'cids". :)

    Healthy soil = hopefully healthy plants. Organics / Biologically grown, probably just will not have all the extra crap WE DO NOT need in the final product.

  • 17 years ago

    A dissenting opinion, at the link.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Dissenting opinion at Bad Science

  • 17 years ago

    Basically you can find anything you search for the internet. If you're looking for information that says no difference or looking for information that says there is difference you WILL find it.